Personal Finance for PhDs

Live a financially balanced life - no Real Job required

Blog

New Fellow? Pay Your Quarterly Estimated Tax for the First Time This Week!

by

Did you start receiving a fellowship this academic year as a graduate student or postdoc? First, congratulations! Second, I must clear up a pernicious misconception about fellowships in the US: you do owe federal income tax (and probably state, too) on your fellowship income. If income tax is not being withheld from your stipend/salary (and the majority of universities do not offer withholding on this type of income), you may be responsible for making quarterly estimated tax payments throughout the year. The next payment is due tomorrow, January 16, 2018! This post will guide you through how to determine whether you owe quarterly estimated tax and how to pay it if so.

Do You Receive Your Gross Income?

The IRS expects to receive income tax payments throughout the year, not just each April. Employees almost always have income tax withheld from their paychecks; instead of receiving their gross (full) income, their employer sends approximately the amount of tax the employee owes from each paycheck to the IRS and the employee receives the rest (net income).

Fellowship recipients (when the term is used conventionally; perhaps not universally) have non-compensatory pay and are not considered employees of their universities. Most universities do not offer income tax withholding on fellowship stipends/salaries. Taxpayers who do not have income tax withheld from their salaries (or who have too little withheld compared to the amount of tax they owe) are sometimes responsible for manually sending money to the IRS. This is called making quarterly estimated tax payments.

If you are a fellowship recipient (e.g., the NSF GRFP), your first step is to confirm that you are in fact not an employee, and your second step is to check whether you are receiving your gross or net income.

Step 1: The easiest way to determine if you are an employee (or rather, confirm that you are not) is to check whether you receive a W-2 for your fellowship income. (If you had an assistantship in this calendar year, you will receive a W-2 for that position, so be sure to check specifically about your fellowship income.) However, if you just started your fellowship in the 2017-2018 academic year, you aren’t due to receive (or not receive) your tax forms until the end of January 2018, and the estimated tax payment is due in mid-January. Your next best option is to inquire into what tax form you will receive for your fellowship stipend/salary. Non-compensatory pay will appear on a 1098-T, 1099-MISC, or courtesy letter or will not be reported in any way. Compensatory pay (indicating that you are an employee) will appear on a W-2. You should try asking your departmental administrative assistant, university fellowship coordinator, Bursar’s Cashier’s office, and/or payroll office. You will most likely be told that they “cannot give tax advice,” but confirming what type of tax form your income generates is not advice.

Step 2: Having confirmed that you are not an employee (if you are, you don’t need this post!), double-check the stipend/salary amount that hits your bank account. If you multiply it by the number of pay periods over which you will receive it, is it equal to the gross fellowship stipend/salary you were told you would receive or is it less? If it is less, did you at any point file a W-4 (e.g., when you had an assistantship)? You may be one of the few students/postdocs who has income tax withheld from a fellowship stipend/salary. As stated earlier, a small minority of universities do offer withholding on fellowship income, and they should use a W-4 to determine the amount of withholding.

If you are not an employee and are not having income tax withheld from your fellowship stipend/salary, you may need to make quarterly estimated tax payments.

Are You Responsible for Paying Quarterly Estimated Tax?

The IRS explains who is responsible for filing quarterly estimated tax on Form 1040-ES p. 1.

Right off the bat, you are not required to pay quarterly estimated tax if in the previous tax year your total income was zero or you did not have to file a tax return (and your return covered all 12 months). For example, if you were a student for all of 2016 and either didn’t have an income or your income was so low that you didn’t have to file a tax return, you aren’t required to make quarterly estimated tax payments.

If that first provision doesn’t apply to you, the IRS has a helpful flow chart on Publication 505 p. 24.

Publication 505 Figure 2-A

At this point, you’re going to have to do a few calculations to determine what amount of additional tax you owe for the year (additional to any withholding you already had). You simply need to fill out the worksheet on Form 1040-ES p. 8 for your household. It looks sort of involved but if you have a simple financial life you won’t actually need to put very many entries into the worksheet. You will need at your fingertips your 2016 tax return (or at least the total amount of tax you paid), your gross income for 2017, the amount of income tax you had withheld in 2017 (if any) and an educated guess as to your 2017 deductions and credits (your 2016 return will be helpful for this).

Once you calculate the amount of tax you owe in total for 2017 (Form 1040-ES line 13c), you can determine whether you are responsible for paying quarterly estimated tax.

First, look up the total amount of tax you paid in 2016. Second, take your total tax due for 2017 and multiply it by 90%. The smaller of these two numbers is the amount of tax you need to pay throughout 2017 to avoid a penalty (Form 1040-ES Line 14c).

Subtract the amount of income tax you had withheld in 2017 (Form 1040-ES Line 15) from the amount you need to pay to avoid a penalty. If the result (Form 1040-ES Line 16) is less than $1,000, you are not required to make a quarterly estimated tax payment. If the result is greater than $1,000, you are required to make a payment.

Please note that just because you are not required to make quarterly estimated tax payments does not mean you will avoid paying tax the whole year, only that the additional tax due does not have to be paid until you file your 2017 tax return this spring. Now that Form 1040-ES has given you some warning, use the next few months to prepare to make that lump sum income tax payment.

How to Pay Quarterly Estimated Tax

If you are required to make a quarterly estimated tax payment, the calculation is pretty simple since this is the last payment due for 2017! You should make a payment for all the additional tax due that you calculated you owe (Form 1040-ES Line 16a). If your calculations were exact, when you file your 2017 tax return in the spring, you won’t receive a refund or owe any additional tax. More likely, filling out your full tax return will bring to light a few adjustments in your calculations, so you may end up receiving a small refund or paying a small amount of additional tax.

The easiest way to make your quarterly estimated tax payment is online at www.IRS.gov/payments (find all your payment options on Form 1040-ES p. 3-4 or Publication 505 p. 32-33).

If you were unaware that you had any income tax liability on your fellowship income and are unprepared to pay what you owe by January 16, 2018, don’t avoid the issue! Give the IRS a call and they may be able to work with you to minimize the penalties you owe (though not the interest).

Calculating your quarterly estimated tax is not very difficult; the most challenging aspect is knowing that you’re supposed to do it! If you are a new fellow and this is your first time making a quarterly estimated tax payment, rest assured that it will be easier going forward. You first quarterly estimated tax payment for 2018 is due on April 17, 2018. You’ll want to freshly fill out the 2018 1040-ES once it’s available, but it should be similar to the form you just worked through.

Loading…

How to Put Your New Postdoc Salary in Context

by

After a long, arduous journey through graduate school, you’ve successfully defended your PhD and are about to take the next step in your research career: a postdoc. One of the best perks of transitioning from being a graduate student to a postdoc is the pay increase. While postdocs aren’t exactly rolling in dough, they are usually paid significantly better than graduate students, and after 5+ years of zero to tiny raises, it’s gratifying to finally receive a higher salary.

postdoc salary in context

However, before you buy that new car or put an offer on a house, take some time to put your new postdoc salary offer in context. There are a few subtle changes common to the grad student-postdoc transition that will decrease your take-home pay and/or discretionary income.

(This post is specific to the US.)

Employee or Fellow?

The very first question to clarify is what exactly your employment status will be with respect to your university/institute. Just like in graduate school, there are two broad ways you can be paid: compensatory or non-compensatory. In academic-speak: Are you an employee or a fellow?

If you see “fellow” in your title or offer letter, have heard “fellowship” from your advisor when discussing funding, or have won an outside individual fellowship, you are a fellow and not an employee of your university. As a fellow, you may receive no benefits from your university or only a few; you are almost certainly not going to receive all the benefits a full employee would. You should contact your university’s postdoc office or your departmental administrative assistant for a full explanation of your benefits.

If you aren’t labeled a “fellow” you are most likely an employee, but there may be multiple classes of employees at your university so it’s important to determine which one. (Postdocs may not be offered the same benefits as faculty, for example.) Once you know exactly your class of employee, you can read through material provided by Human Resources to determine your benefits, and direct any questions you have to Human Resources or the postdoc office.

When in doubt, ask if you will receive W-2 pay or not. W-2s are used for employee pay, while non-compensatory pay is not reported to the IRS or reported on a 1099-MISC.

Further viewing: Types of Grad Student Pay and Their Implications

Some of the common, though not universal, differences in benefits offered to employees though not fellows are: income tax withholding, 403(b) access, 403(b) match, subsidized health insurance premiums, health insurance premiums paid as a payroll deduction, Health Savings Account/Flexible Spending Account, group disability and/or life insurance access, and official paid time off.

Income and FICA Taxes

If you’re earning more as a postdoc, you’re also going to pay more in federal income tax (given no other changes in your personal life). Your effective tax rate will increase and possibly your marginal tax rate as well. So if your gross pay increases by $1,000 per month, for example, federal income tax may take a $120 or $220 (or somewhere in between) bite out of that increase.

The same broad story would be true for state taxes if you are not moving states, but many postdocs relocate states as well with their new positions. If you don’t want any surprises in your first paycheck, look up how your new state’s tax brackets and rates compare to your old state’s.

One of the biggest tax changes that occurs when going from a grad student to a postdoc is FICA tax (Social Security and Medicaid). As a graduate student, you did not pay FICA tax. Postdoc fellows will also not pay FICA tax (or self-employment tax) on their income as they do not technically receive “wages.” However, postdoc employees will begin to pay FICA tax. On the employee side, the Social Security tax is 6.2% and the Medicare tax is 1.45% on all of your income up to $128,400 (in 2018). If your new postdoc salary is $45,000 per year, for example, you will pay $3,442.50 in FICA tax. That can be a big shock for someone who wasn’t paying any tax in that category previously.

The best way to calculate your new take-home pay after all of these changes is to use a paycheck calculator, of which there are many.

Further reading: Why Is My Take-Home Pay as a Postdoc Nearly the Same as When I Was a Grad Student?

Health Insurance

While your grad school and postdoc universities almost certainly offer you the option of buying group health insurance, who pays the premium and how might change.

As a graduate student, it is typical to have your health insurance premium paid partially or completely from funds that are not part of your stipend pay, so many graduate students don’t have to factor that cost into their take-home pay.

A postdoc employee will likely pay part or all of his insurance premium through a tax-free payroll deduction. A postdoc fellow’s insurance premium may be paid on her behalf, similar to a graduate student, or come completely from her salary.

This is an important benefit to check into prior to starting your postdoc position as you don’t want any lapse in coverage or to be surprised by the additional expense. The premium for a postdoc’s insurance may be much higher than a graduate student’s, depending on the risk pool each position is put in.

Student Loans

Another big change when you transition out of being a student is that your student loans, if you have any, are no longer eligible for in-school deferment. Beginning to pay off student loans can be a large monthly expense on a postdoc salary, depending on the total amount owed.

Contact your lender(s) to find the minimum payment due and the period over which you will repay your loans. Federal student loans have a standard repayment period of 10 years, but private student loans may take a shorter or longer period of time. Factor this minimum payment due into your planning for how to allocate your salary.

If you want to pay off your debt faster than the standard repayment period, which is an excellent idea for debt at a moderate or high interest rate, plan on paying more than the minimum amount due each month.

If you don’t think your postdoc salary can handle even the minimum payment on your student loans, you have two options to immediately consider.

1) With respect to your federal student loans, you may be eligible for one of the many repayment programs that lower your minimum payment due (even, potentially, to $0) by extending the repayment period and overall amount of money you will repay (income-based repayment, pay as you earn, etc.). Your eligibility for these programs depends on your household income. Carefully consider whether it is in your best interest to use one of these programs, even if you are eligible.

2) There are many lenders currently offering student loan refinancing at competitive interest rates. When you refinance, you are paying off your old loans and taking out new private loans, so make sure you would not be losing any benefits unique to student loans, such as the repayment programs for federal student loans. Be forewarned that these lenders only work with borrowers with excellent credit and low debt-to-income ratios. If you can significantly lower your interest rate, refinancing may be a positive step for your personal finances, both lowering your minimum payment due and reducing the total amount of money you will repay.

Cost of Living

With a change in university naturally comes a change in the local cost of living. As you well know, living expenses vary greatly from city to city. At the lower salary levels of a graduate student or postdoc, this can be a major concern.

There are two quick methods to estimate how the cost of living will change between your grad school city and your postdoc city.

CNN offers a cost of living comparison calculator. Plug in the two cities in question (or as close as you can get to them) and put in either your grad student salary or your postdoc salary. Your greater familiarity with the cost of living in your grad school city combined with this calculator will help you estimate how far your new salary will go in your new city.

MIT’s living wage database also provides insight. Look up the living wage for your grad school university’s county and your postdoc university’s county. The living wage will be closer to your grad student salary than your postdoc salary, but the difference between the two will also help you determine how much of an increase or decrease in cost of living you will experience.

A more involved but also more effective step if you have not yet moved to your new city is to sketch a budget. Using your best estimate of your take-home pay based on the above factors, research how much you are likely to spend on housing, food, transportation, etc. if you kept your perceived lifestyle the same from grad school into your postdoc. Ideally, this exercise will help you decide in which areas of your budget you are able and would like to upgrade your lifestyle, such as living without a roommate.

Personal Experience with the Transition to a Postdoc Position

My husband stayed in his PhD advisor’s lab for an extra year as a postdoc to finish up a few papers before applying for a “real” multi-year postdoc at another institution. My husband received one postdoc offer that he seriously considered before ultimately choosing a position in industry. We performed the calculations above regarding increased taxes and insurance costs to compare the take-home pay of his new postdoc offer directly to the take-home pay from his short-term postdoc and graduate student positions. The take-home pay from the postdoc offer was slightly less than that of his short-term postdoc position and much higher than his pay as a graduate student.

However, when we compared the cost of living in our grad school city, Durham, NC, to the cost of living in Boston, MA, where the new offer was from, we were shocked by the results. In terms of the effective purchasing power from my husband’s take-home pay, the pay for the postdoc position in Boston was “less” than even his grad student pay in Durham. We would not have expected to experience an effective pay decrease moving from a grad student position to a postdoc position, but that is how the numbers worked out. I’m very glad that we took the time to do those estimates before he made a final decision about the offer.

Further reading: An Agonizing Decision

While the gross pay from your new postdoc position may seem great in comparison with your grad student pay, don’t be fooled! You must account for several important changes in taxes, benefits, and cost of living to compare apples to apples.

How Will Taxes for Grad Students and Postdocs Change Under the New Tax Law?

by

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act has been passed by both the House and Senate and signed by the president, and grad students are rejoicing that their tuition benefits were preserved in the final version. This is really the first opportunity we’ve had to figure out what the changes to the tax code will mean for graduate students and other individuals. In this post I’m running some numbers for a few different income levels and family configurations that are relevant to grad students and postdocs (similar to this article but for lower incomes). The good news is that it does seem that taxpayers at these lower income levels will see a reduction in their tax burdens as long as they take the standard deduction (or their itemized deductions are within about double of the standard deduction).

2018 tax for grad students and postdocs

Download the Tax Spreadsheet

Sign up for our mailing list to receive the spreadsheet I used to write this post, including a 3-question calculator for your own 2018 tax due.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by Kit

Tax Concepts and Terms

Many Americans don’t realize that our income tax structure is tiered. If your income falls in the 15% marginal tax bracket, for instance, it’s not the case that you pay 15% of your gross income in income tax. Part of your income (the amount that goes into your deductions and (currently) exemption) is not taxed at all. The next chunk of your income is taxed at 10%, and the last chunk is taxed (currently) at 15%. This would continue up the tax brackets if your income were higher.

Further reading: Marginal Tax Brackets, Deductions, and Credits Explained Graphically

A deduction is an amount of money that is excluded from your taxable income. You will choose to take the standard deduction or to itemize your deductions, whichever will give you the larger deduction. There are other deductions that fall outside of the standard/itemized deduction (above-the-line deductions), such as interest paid on student loans (up to $2,500), qualified education expenses if paid out of gross income, and contributions to a traditional IRA. The amount of the deduction multiplied by your marginal tax bracket is the amount that your tax will be reduced due to the deduction. For example, if you are in the 15% tax bracket and apply a deduction worth $1,000, your tax will be reduced by $150.

A credit is an amount of money by which your tax is directly reduced. A credit is worth the same amount no matter what marginal tax bracket you fall in, e.g., a $1,000 credit takes $1,000 off your tax bill. Examples of credits are the child tax credit, childcare expenses credit, and the saver’s credit. Your tax may even be reduced to zero due to credits, and refundable credits allow you to pay negative tax, i.e., receive money instead of paying money at tax time (non-refundable credits stop at a tax liability of $0). Sometimes a credit is applied at a certain percentage, e.g., a 20% credit on an amount up to $1,000 if worth at most $200 but would be less if you spent less on the expense in question.

Changes to the Tax Code in the GOP Bill

There are a few tax policy changes that will affect every American taxpayer, and many more that affect only high-income individuals or individuals in specific scenarios (e.g., taxpayer who previously had a large amount of certain itemized deductions, owners of pass-through businesses). In this post, I’m focusing on changes that will apply to all or many graduate students and postdocs. I have omitted noting at what income levels most of the benefits phase out, instead assuming that graduate students and postdocs will fall under those limits.

In creating this post, I have largely leaned on this great summary of the changes proposed in the GOP tax bill placed side-by-side with the current tax policies. Please note there is a typo in the individual tax rates table ($19,050 is correct, not $19,500).

Standard Deduction

The standard deduction is a set amount of your income that is tax-free. The alternative to the standard deduction is to itemize your deductions, which means documenting one or more types of deductible expenses throughout the year and choosing this deduction type if they add up to more than the standard deduction. (Some of common itemized deductions as of 2017 are medical and dental expenses if over 10% of your adjusted gross income, state and local income or sales tax, property tax, mortgage interest, charitable gifts, and unreimbursed employee expenses.)

One of the stated goals of the GOP with respect to this tax plan was to simplify the tax code, and itemizing deductions is one of the headache-inducing activities that is part of preparing a tax return for some taxpayers (less than 1/3 of households). Raising the standard deduction means that a larger amount of everyone’s income will be tax-free and that many fewer households will have to itemize to receive their largest deduction. However, some types of deductions that previously could be itemized have been eliminated or capped, which could negatively affect taxpayers who heavily relied on them to reduce their tax due. Two of these types of deductions are:

  • the state and local income/sales/property tax deduction is limited to $10,000 and
  • the mortgage interest deduction is now for loan sizes under $750,000.

Exemptions

In 2017, another amount of income was tax-free for each member of your household, which was your personal exemption. If you are single, you receive one exemption; if you are married filing jointly, you receive two exemptions; you also receive one exemption per dependent child. In 2017, each exemption is worth $4,050.

The GOP tax bill eliminates exemptions in favor of the larger standard deduction discussed above. Because the exemption amount scaled with the number of people in the household whereas the standard deduction is only applied once per household, this change is advantageous for smaller households (single, married couple) and disadvantageous for larger households (married couple with two or more children). However, the expansion of the child tax credit, discussed below, offsets this disadvantage for children up through age 16.

Tax Brackets

The lowest three tax brackets shift slightly under the new GOP plan. Their income ranges remain similar though not exactly the same (they change slightly every year anyway). The 10% bracket will still be taxed at 10%, the 15% bracket will be taxed at 12%, and the 25% bracket will be taxed at 22%.

source

source

Keep in mind that when you find your marginal tax bracket (the highest tax bracket your income falls into) in these tables, you will use your taxable income less deductions and exemptions.

Child Tax Credit

The 2017 child tax credit is $1,000 per child for households under certain income limits and is partially refundable for some low-income households. In 2018, the child tax credit will be $2,000 under higher income limits and is fully refundable up to $1,400. The child tax credit applies to children up through age 16.

Income Tax Charts

For Single People and Married Couples Filing Jointly

I have created charts of the tax due for individuals and couples with various incomes under the 2017 and 2018 tax laws (assuming no children for now). I assumed the filers would take the standard deduction and no additional deductions (such as student loan interest or qualified education expenses).

Keeping in mind the income ranges of graduate students and postdocs, the ‘single’ table incomes range from $15,000/year to $50,000 with increments of $5,000, and the ‘married’ table incomes range from $30,000 to $110,000 with increments of $20,000.

 Income (x $1,000) 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
2017 Tax Due ($) 460 974 1,724 2,474 3,224 3,974 4,724 5,639
2018 Tax Due ($) 300 800 1,370 1,970 2,570 3,170 3,770 4,370

Income (x $1,000) 30 50 70 90 110
2017 Tax Due ($) 920 3,448 6,448 9,448 13,778
2018 Tax Due ($) 600 2,739 5,139 7,539 10,799

Income (x $1,000) 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
Single Absolute Reduction ($) 160 174 354 504 654 804 954 1,269
Single % Reduction 35 18 21 20 20 20 20 23
Income (x $1,000) 30 50 70 90 110
Married Absolute Reduction ($) 320 708 1,308 1,908 2,978
Married % Reduction 35 21 20 20 22

Under the above assumptions, graduate students and postdocs across these income levels will see a reduction in their tax burdens between 20 and 35%.

Download the Tax Spreadsheet

Sign up for our mailing list to receive the spreadsheet I used to write this post, including a 3-question calculator for your own 2018 tax due.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by Kit

Adjustments for Children

In 2017, if you have a dependent child under the age of 17, you can take the child tax credit for $1,000 per child. A credit is worth the same across the tax brackets because it directly reduces your tax due. In addition, you can also take an exemption for your dependent child (possibly up to age 23). In terms of the effect on your final tax burden, if you are in the 10% tax bracket the exemption is worth $405.00, if you are in the 15% tax bracket the exemption is worth $607.50, and if you are in the 25% tax bracket the exemption is worth $1012.50.

In 2018, the child tax credit has been expanded to $2,000 per child, but only up through age 16.

Download My Spreadsheet

You can download the spreadsheet I used to make the above charts with the complete tables. I have also included a sheet where you can estimate your own tax due by answering three questions.

Download the Tax Spreadsheet

Sign up for our mailing list to receive the spreadsheet I used to write this post, including a 3-question calculator for your own 2018 tax due.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by Kit

Do Your Own Calculations

This post skips over many of the nuances of the current and new tax law, so it does not substitute for plugging your numbers into a calculator (once full ones become available) or the math you will do in preparing your tax return. It is only intended to give an estimate of the tax due for ordinary wage earners (and, I presume, fellowship recipients) in the income ranges relevant to graduate students and postdocs. If you have automatic withholding on your paycheck, you should see changes to your take-home pay in early 2018. If you file quarterly estimated tax, your first payment is due in mid-April, so you have a few months for the IRS to adjust Form 1040-ES and to calculate your new tax burden.

Everything You Need to Know about Roth IRAs in Graduate School

by

As you are no doubt aware, graduate students are clamoring for information on investing for retirement. I’ve observed this during my seminars and it’s been documented by the Council of Graduate Schools’ Financial Education. Graduate students are wondering how to get started saving for retirement during graduate school or want to be prepared to start immediately following graduate school. Roth IRAs are an integral component of preparing for retirement for graduate students. This article covers everything you need to know about Roth IRAs in graduate school: what an IRA is, why you should use one, the differences between traditional and Roth IRAs, the type of income you need to contribute to an IRA, how much to contribute to an IRA, and how to open an IRA.

Roth IRA graduate school

If you want to know with which firm I have my own IRA and in what I’m invested, sign up for my mailing list to receive a unique 700-word letter. If you have any remaining questions on Roth IRAs in graduate school after reading the article, leave them in the comments or email them to me; I’ll respond directly and update the article with the answer.

Free Email Course: Investing for Early-Career PhDs

Sign up for the mailing list to receive the free 10,000-word email course designed for graduate students, postdocs, and PhDs in their first Real Jobs.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by Kit

The information in this article is current as of 2023.

What Is an IRA?

IRA stands for Individual Retirement Arrangement. It is a tax benefit offered by the US federal government to incentivize saving for retirement. Anyone with taxable compensation (or a spouse with taxable compensation) can contribute to an IRA; it is not a benefit offered by your workplace like a 401(k) or 403(b). The contribution limit to an IRA in 2023 is $6,500 ($7,500 for people aged 50 and older) or your amount of taxable compensation, whichever is lower.

An IRA is not synonymous with particular investments; you buy investments inside (or outside) of your IRA. An IRA (and other tax-advantaged retirement accounts like a 401(k) or 403(b)) is like a shield that protects your investments from taxes.

If you invest in a regular taxable investment account, every year that you realize a gain you will pay some tax on the gain. This tax effectively suppresses the growth rate you see on your investments, which saps the power of compound interest. An IRA or other tax-advantaged account maximizes that growth rate by eliminating the tax, which ultimately maximizes the amount of money you have in your investments.

However, this tax-advantaged status comes with a trade-off. The purpose of an IRA is to help Americans save for retirement, so there are restrictions on when and for what purpose you can remove money from your IRA. In limited cases, you can remove money from your IRA without incurring any penalty, but in general you have to wait until you are 59.5 years old.

Why Use an IRA Instead of a Taxable Investment Account?

If you were to save for the long-term into a normal investment account, every year you would pay some tax on the gains you realized in the account. If your account had a great deal of turnover in the course of a year, you would pay your marginal tax rate on the gains (10%, 12%, 22%, etc.) plus whatever state tax would be due. If your account had very little turnover, your tax rate(s) would be lower. If instead your money was in an IRA (or a similar tax-advantaged retirement account like a 401(k) or 403(b)), all the gains would be tax-free.

Taxes on a regular investment account amount to death by a thousand cuts. Every year, a fraction of the growth (if there was growth) is removed through taxes and no longer serves as part of the principal for the growth in a subsequent year. Using a tax-advantaged account like an IRA allows the growth to continue unfettered. Over many decades, the balance in an IRA can be hundreds of thousands of dollars larger than the balance in a taxable account to which the same contributions were made.

Further reading: Taxable vs. Tax-Advantaged Savings

For short- or medium-term investing goals, taxable accounts are appropriate because of the complete accessibility of the money contributed. But for long-term investing goals such as retirement, it is very advantageous to use an IRA or other tax-advantaged retirement account.

Why to Contribute to an IRA during Graduate School

Graduate students have a limited income and plenty of claims on that income. They must first and foremost pay for their basic living expenses, which not all stipends can even cover. If there is any money remaining, the student must choose among upgrading his lifestyle, saving up cash, paying down debt, investing, giving, supporting family members, etc. They may very well have higher priorities than saving for retirement. However, there is a very compelling reason for starting to invest for the long term if possible: the power of compound interest aka the time value of money.

As graduate students are most often in their 20s or 30s, time is currently on their side with respect to investing. Many Americans put off saving for retirement until their peak earning years in their 40s and 50s, but the advantage of starting earlier is that you need to save less money overall to reach the same endpoint. This is the time value of money: the money that you invest today is worth more than the money you invest years from now because the intervening time adds value. Investing even small amounts of money during graduate school can massively add to your wealth in retirement, much more so than large amounts of money saved later on.

The mechanism of the time value of money is the power of compound interest.

In qualitative terms, this is how compound interest works: In year 1, you invest some money and it earns a return (we’ll say a positive return, to keep things simple). In year 2, you invest more money which earns a return, plus your contribution and the return from the previous year also earn a return. In year 3, you invest more money and it earns a return, plus your contributions and earnings from previous years earn a return. Before you know it the increases to your account balance each year are coming more so from the growth your previous contributions than on your current contributions; after decades, most of your account balance will be due to growth rather than your direct contributions.

The power of compound interest is modeled by this equation, which represents exponential growth:

compound interest equation

Using the equation for compound growth, you can get an idea of how much money can grow with a given rate of return and time period. In real investing in the stock market, you will not receive the exact same rate of return each year like clockwork; in some years you will lose money, in others you will see a very high return, and everything in between. But on balance, over long periods of time, the math of compound interest reveals the scale of growth possible with even an irregular return like you would see from the stock market. (Investments that give a regular and guaranteed rate of return, such as bonds and certificates of deposit, are comparatively low-returning and not usually considered appropriate long-term investments for a young person.)

For example, if you invested $250 per month at an 8% average annual rate of return for five years during graduate school, in that time you would contribute $15,000 and your ending balance would be $18,369.21. The growth over that time period is nice but not staggering.

But if you then leave that money alone to continue compounding at 8% per year for 50 years – make no additional contributions – your money grows to a mind-boggling $989,688.35!

That’s an extra one million dollars in retirement that you would not have had if you had not started investing during graduate school!

The numbers above are for illustrative purposes only. It’s still incredibly worthwhile to begin investing during graduate school even at a rate of less than $250/month. Compound interest works the same on any sum of money, whether $5 or $5,000. The point is that investing with time on your side turns small amounts of money into large amounts.

Further reading:

Free 10,000-Word Email Course on Investing for Early-Career PhDs

Subscribe to our mailing list to receive the 6-day email course designed for graduate students, postdocs, and PhDs in their first Real Jobs.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by Kit

The Difference between Traditional and Roth IRAs

When you open an IRA, you have the choice between opening a traditional IRA and a Roth IRA. (You can contribute to either/both in the course of a year, but the maximum contribution limit applies to them both together, not each separately.) There are a number of differences between the two types of IRAs, especially when it comes to eligibility and withdrawing money in retirement, but there are two key differences that are most salient for young people who are eligible for both types: when you pay income tax and how to withdraw money without penalty prior to age 59.5.

Further reading:

When You Pay Income Tax

With both types of IRAs, you won’t pay any tax while the money is growing inside the IRA.

With a traditional IRA – unsurprisingly, the first type introduced into the tax code – there is an additional tax incentive upon contribution to the IRA, which is that you exclude the amount you contribute from your taxable income for the year (take a tax deduction). You take a tax deduction on the money you contribute, then your money grows tax-free, and then you pay ordinary income tax on the amounts you withdraw each year in retirement. The traditional IRA is a mechanism of tax deferral.

The Roth IRA is the newer type of IRA (named after the senator who introduced it). The tax break on the Roth IRA is the flip of the one for the traditional IRA. You pay the full income tax due on the contribution you make to the Roth IRA, then your money grows tax-free, and you withdraw it tax-free in retirement.

The key to choosing between a traditional and Roth IRA is to guess when you will pay a lower tax rate: upon contribution or withdrawal.

One way to approach this question is by considering when you will be in a lower marginal tax bracket: now or in retirement? The rationale behind this is that you are going to get the tax break on the last dollars of your income, which are likely to fall in your marginal tax bracket. You know your marginal tax bracket today; most graduate students without outside sources of income fall in the 12% marginal tax bracket or even lower (plus your marginal state tax rate). But you have to guess whether the marginal tax bracket you will fall into in retirement will be higher or lower. In the intervening decades, you will experience personal changes in your income and tax bracket, and there are likely to be legislative changes to the tax code and rates.

This guess is probably easier for graduate students than for the average American. Graduate students can make the reasonable assumption that their current income is much lower than their income will be throughout their careers and likely also in retirement. (Ask yourself: Do you want to be living the same lifestyle in retirement that you are in graduate school or would you like it to be more lavish?) Whatever might happen to the tax code more broadly, confidence that you are in a personal low-income and low-tax bracket period is a strong argument for the Roth IRA over the traditional IRA. I and virtually every graduate student I’ve spoken with about this issue chose the Roth IRA over the traditional IRA during grad school.

However, there are more nuanced arguments that you might consider that are more in favor of the traditional IRA, even for someone in a low tax bracket currently. Such arguments are beyond the scope of this article, but there is plenty of reading material available on the decision between the traditional and Roth IRA for you to dive into if you are interested.

Further reading: Traditional vs. Roth IRA: The Unconventional Wisdom

Penalty-Free Early Withdrawal

One of the big planning/psychological barriers to beginning to save for retirement is the nagging question “What if I turn out to need the money in the near future?” After all, life is unpredictable; sustained loss of income or a very expensive emergency might be just around the corner. Some people find it difficult to put barriers between themselves and their money no matter what degree of cash they may have accessible in an emergency fund or other savings. The prospect of sequestering money that can only be used many decades from now in retirement can be daunting.

The Roth IRA (as opposed to the traditional IRA) helps to alleviate this anxiety. While it is rarely a good idea to take already-contributed money out of an IRA (after all, you are unplugging that money from the power of compound interest), you do have that option with the Roth IRA. Because you have already paid your income tax on your Roth IRA contributions, you can withdraw those contributions at any time without penalty (or additional tax). Certain conditions must be met to withdraw earnings early without penalty or tax. For one example of a qualified distribution, the IRA must be at least five years old and the withdrawal is used to buy a first home (up to $10,000); there are other conditions that create qualified distributions as well.

With a traditional IRA, on the other hand, early withdrawals always result in tax due, and penalties are also assessed if the withdrawal is not qualified.

The Type of Income You Need to Contribute to an IRA

Only “taxable compensation” (formerly “earned income”) can be contributed to an IRA; while IRAs are independent of your workplace, they are not independent of work. For most Americans, this is a non-issue, because they work for their income. For example, they might be employees receiving W-2 income or self-employed; both of these types of income are taxable compensation.

Up through 2019, taxable fellowship income not reported on a W-2 was not considered taxable compensation. Starting in 2020, taxable fellowship income not reported on a W-2 is considered taxable compensation. That means that a graduate student receiving a stipend is eligible to contribute their stipend income to an IRA, whether that stipend is reported on a W-2 or some other form (or not at all)—as long as it is taxable in the US.

If none of your income is taxable in the US because you are a nonresident and benefit from a tax treaty, you don’t have “taxable compensation” and are not eligible to contribute to an IRA.

Further reading:

Free Email Course: Investing for Early-Career PhDs

Sign up for the mailing list to receive the free 10,000-word email course designed for graduate students, postdocs, and PhDs in their first Real Jobs.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by Kit

How Much to Contribute to an IRA during Graduate School

The right amount of money to contribute to an IRA in a given year of graduate school might be $6,500, $0, or somewhere in between.

Graduate school is an extraordinary time of investment in one’s career, possibly to the exclusion of investing for retirement. While many graduate students are paid stipends that more than cover their living expenses, some graduate students are either not being paid a living wage or have unusually high expenses (e.g., have dependents).

To determine the right amount for you to contribute to an IRA, you must explore your means and your goals.

Means: How does your stipend compare to the local living wage? While the local living wage will not exactly match your expenses in every category, it should give you a sense of the baseline cost of living in your county or metro area. If your stipend is at or above the living wage and you aren’t able to save anything, try to reduce your expenses so you can start to invest or accomplish other financial goals. If your stipend is below the living wage, you may not have the means to start saving or investing right now; getting through graduate school without accumulating debt may be an appropriate financial goal.

Goals: Not all graduate students with discretionary income should jump right into investing. There may be higher-priority financial goals such as paying off high-interest debt or saving cash for emergencies or short-term expenses. But if investing for retirement becomes your top financial goal or a goal you work on concurrently with other goals, it is appropriate to contribute to an IRA.

If a graduate student does have the means to invest and investing is their top financial goal, rules of thumb come back into play. The most common (mainstream) retirement savings rates bandied about in the personal finance community are between 10 and 20% of income (gross or net). I think investing 10% of gross income into a Roth IRA is a great initial goal for a graduate student; it was my retirement savings rate when I started graduate school. It may be one easily reached (especially if you build it into your budget from the beginning) or quite challenging. If it takes you years of budget optimization to reach 10% (or you never do), that’s fine. If you want to go higher than 10%, that’s great too, and you’ll have a wonderful nest egg when you transition out of graduate school. (My husband and I reached a 17.5% savings rate from our gross income by the time we defended, but it took years to raise our savings rate to that point.)

A higher retirement savings rate will help you reach financial independence faster, but you always have to balance that against your quality of life in the present. But if you have the means and aren’t working on a more pressing goal, I do recommend regularly contributing to a Roth IRA during graduate school, even if it’s a small percentage. Getting into the habit of saving for retirement is as valuable as the savings itself; if you save during graduate school, once you have a Real Job you’ll never be able to tell yourself that you “can’t afford to save right now.”

Further reading:

How to Open an IRA

The actual process of opening an IRA is straightforward, but choosing where to open it and what to invest in inside the IRA will take some research and decisions on your part.

Briefly, using index funds (a passive investing strategy) is the most effective, least expensive, and most time-efficient manner of investing. You can buy index funds (e.g., the S&P 500 index fund) or a fund of index funds such as a target date or lifecycle fund at any number of brokerage firms. (Brokerage firms that specialize in trading single stocks, i.e., the ones you probably see the most advertisements for, may not offer index funds.)

When you select a brokerage firm, you need to ensure that: 1) it allows you to open an IRA, 2) it offers the investments you are looking for, 3) it is not too expensive to own the funds, and 4) you can meet the account minimums. Index funds are inherently inexpensive, but there will still be some price differences among brokerage firms. Different firms also set different account size minimums, such as between $1,000 and $3,000, but some waive these minimums if you set up an automatic savings rate into the account.

Further reading: Brokerage and IRA Account Minimums

Once you have selected your brokerage firm and investment, you are ready to open your IRA. You should be able to complete the process online in just a few minutes, and the brokerage firm’s website will guide you through the process. You will be asked for your personal information such as your name, SSN, and address. Once you have the IRA open, transfer in the amount of money you need to open the account and/or set up an automatic savings rate, and choose the investment(s) you want to buy with your money.

Give Yourself a Raise: Re-Evaluate Your Fixed Expenses

by

Increasing your income as a graduate student can be quite challenging, to put it mildly. Stipends sometimes increase with cost-of-living raises or the student’s advancement to candidacy. Fellowships that pay high stipends are quite competitive. You could take out (additional) student loans to give yourself more spending money, but you’ll pay back all that debt (plus interest) later. Establishing a side income or side gig is not an option for all grad students, and those that do are likely making a significant time investment.

A version of this post originally appeared on GradHacker.

give yourself a raise re-evaluate your fixed expenses

Because their options for earning more money are so constrained, grad students seeking to free up extra cash most often turn to decreasing their living expenses. You can effectively “give yourself a raise” by adopting positive financial habits or practicing frugality. This first post in my “Give Yourself a Raise” series focuses on doing so by evaluating your fixed expenses.

I always encourage people looking to reduce their expenses to consider their fixed expenses first. Your fixed expenses are those that are the same every time they occur, such as your rent/mortgage, minimum debt payments, and certain utilities. You only need to make and carry out a one-time decision to reduce a fixed expense, which will free up additional cash flow for you on a regular basis for months or years to come. While this one-time decision might be difficult to make or implement, in my opinion this is often preferable to trying to reduce expenses by methods that require willpower or time on an ongoing basis.

While any of your fixed expenses could potentially go on the chopping block, those that are largest and/or discretionary are usually the ripest for reduction.

Rent/Mortgage

Housing is usually the biggest monthly expenditure grad students have and therefore should be the first to be examined. We all know how to (potentially) reduce our housing expenses: move to a smaller, further, or otherwise less desirable residence; add one or more roommates; or find a better deal. More creative alternative housing arrangements may also be possible, e.g., house-sitting or serving as a resident advisor.

In this area, graduate students usually don’t have a lack of knowledge of how to reduce their housing expenses but rather may not re-examine their decisions as their priorities, finances, and options evolve or are unwilling to move even when it is warranted. My husband and I went several years during grad school without re-evaluating our housing choice until a rent increase compelled us to. Searching for housing and moving certainly wasn’t easy, but by giving up a few amenities and switching from an apartment in a complex to a privately owned townhouse we significantly reduced our rent. The result was an extra $100+ each month that we could put toward other spending that we valued more.

Cable/Internet/Subscription Services

They key question to ask yourself with respect to your fixed utilities and subscription services is “Am I getting the best deal available for what I actually need/want?” It’s easy to lose sight of how well what you’re paying for matches what you truly use, especially as offers and packages change so quickly.

In the last couple years many streaming options have become available for content that used to be the exclusive domain of cable TV. If you’re paying for cable, now is the time to determine if the channels you actually watch are available in a lower-cost form. Don’t forget that you can still watch network TV for free if you have an antenna.

After you’ve determined what you actually want to pay for, simply being a savvy consumer and shopping around for the best price may keep you from spending tens or hundreds of dollars over the course of a year. If you switch providers to get a promotional deal, though, be sure to factor in any activation-type charges that you may incur and the length of the contract you must sign.

Cell Phone Service

People frequently espouse fierce brand loyalties when it comes to their smartphone brands and cell plan providers, which can get in the way of finding the service that fits their needs for the best price. If you’ve never looked at providers other than AT&T and Verizon, you may be able to realize significant savings immediately or when your current contract ends. My husband recently halved his cell phone bill by switching from Verizon to Cricket Wireless, and I count my patronage of Republic Wireless as one of the best financial decisions I made during grad school. Project Fi, Ting, and other mobile virtual network operators are well worth considering, and the service and price are continually improving. Switching providers while keeping your current phone or paying up front for a new phone can give you a lot more options for lowering your fixed expenses than buying a phone through a contract (if you can manage the irregular expense of buying a full-priced phone every so often).

Insurance

Reducing insurance premiums can be tricky because forgoing insurance or paying the least amount possible is often not the best decision (e.g., dropping collision coverage on a car you can’t afford to replace), yet you don’t want to be over-insured (e.g., paying for life insurance when you have no dependents or co-owned debt).

Regularly shopping around for the best price for the types and amounts of insurance you actually need is a great habit to build. You need to do your own research on what coverage you need and not rely on a salesperson to tell you (e.g., begin your reading on auto insurance, renters insurance, and life insurance with independent sources). If you have a good emergency fund, increasing the deductibles on your policies may lower your fixed expenses without jeopardizing your finances. Buying your various policies through the same company may also lower your overall premiums.

While you can ‘give yourself a raise’ by reducing any fixed expense by any amount, in this post I have highlighted the most common fixed expenses with reasonable flexibility to effect significant savings over the course of a year. Your own budget may include other types of fixed expenses that are worth evaluating. When you desire additional cash flow and income increases are hard to come by, it is prudent to focus on reducing your living expenses as best you can. Ultimately, you are the best person to judge whether you are using your money (and time) optimally while you are in grad school.

What fixed expenses have you reduced during grad school and how did you do it? When searching for ways to free up cash flow, do you prefer to focus on your fixed or variable expenses?

Does Your University Use Section 117(d)? Please Take Our Survey!

by

There have been more developments with the GOP tax plan (the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act) with respect to graduate students’ tuition benefits.

Last week, I gave my interpretation of how the House bill selectively eliminates one form of tuition benefit (tuition reductions) while leaving in place another (tuition scholarships).

Since my writing, an amendment was proposed to maintain the tuition benefits as they currently are, but it was defeated. The House bill is expected to be voted on tomorrow (Thursday, November 16, 2017).

You can find more information and action steps on the NAGPS website.

The Senate version of the tax bill has also been released in the last week, and it apparently does not include the same changes to graduate student tuition benefits that was in the House bill.

If both bills pass as currently written, they will go to a conference committee to create a compromise between the two versions. Then, the agreed-upon version will go back to the House and Senate to be voted upon. It is still important to voice your opinion about this particular provision of the bill to both your representatives and senators so that either the conference committee does not include changes to the tuition benefit in the final version of the bill or your Congresspeople vote against the bill if it does.

tuition tax survey

In the meantime, I am collaborating with two current graduate students, Andrew McCubbin and David Dixon, to figure out which universities are using section 117(a-b) vs. 117(d) for their tuition benefits. My purpose is not to discourage anyone from taking action opposing the TCJA but rather to help students with their personal financial planning and advocacy at the state, university, and department level, should the TCJA pass with the tuition benefit cut in place.

We have a survey up right now; would you please fill it out to the best of your ability and share it with your peers? In the next few days, we’ll start sharing our determinations from the survey on this results page. Also, feel free to comment on this post or email me if you have relevant information but don’t want to fill out the survey!