• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Personal Finance for PhDs

Live a financially balanced life - no Real Job required

  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Tax Center
  • PhD Home Loans
  • Work with Emily
  • About Emily Roberts

international student

Increasing Income and Giving Back as an International Grad Student

September 22, 2025 by Jill Hoffman Leave a Comment

In this episode, Emily interviews Snehanjana Chatterjee, a 3rd-year international graduate student at Texas Tech. Snehanjana recounts her financial journey over the past few years, from how she funded her start-up expenses upon moving to the US to how she’s gained scholarships and awards to increase her income. Snehanjana volunteers to help international students acclimate to the US, and she shares some of their concerns and questions. Finally, Snehanjana asks Emily about banking and investing as an international student not planning to stay in the US.

Links mentioned in the Episode

  • PF for PhDs One-on-One Financial Coaching
  • PF for PhDs S4E17: Can and Should an International Student, Scholar, or Worker Invest in the US?
  • PF for PhDs S22E1: The Simple Way to Invest as an International Grad Student or Postdoc
  • Host a PF for PhDs Seminar at Your Institution
  • PF for PhDs S20E8: Business Class Flights and Hotel Elite Status on a Grad Student Stipend
  • PF for PhDs Subscribe to Mailing List
  • PF for PhDs Podcast Hub
Increasing Income and Giving Back as an International Grad Student

Teaser

Snehanjana (00:00): For one fiscal year after it was done, um, they paid me a thousand dollars as like a scholarship at the end of it.

Introduction

Emily (00:20): Welcome to the Personal Finance for PhDs Podcast: A Higher Education in Personal Finance. This podcast is for PhDs and PhDs-to-be who want to explore the hidden curriculum of finances to learn the best practices for money management, career advancement, and advocacy for yourself and others. I’m your host, Dr. Emily Roberts, a financial educator specializing in early-career PhDs and founder of Personal Finance for PhDs.

Emily (00:48): This is Season 22, Episode 3, and today my guest is Snehanjana Chatterjee, a 3rd-year international graduate student at Texas Tech. Snehanjana recounts her financial journey over the past few years, from how she funded her start-up expenses upon moving to the US to how she’s gained scholarships and awards to increase her income. Snehanjana volunteers to help international students acclimate to the US, and she shares some of their concerns and questions. Finally, Snehanjana and I discuss banking and investing for international students not planning to stay in the US.

Emily (01:22): Would you like to ask me a question like Snehanjana does in this interview or work through a tricky financial challenge? I have recently opened my calendar for one-on-one financial coaching sessions, priced on a sliding scale. I can help you with budgeting for an irregular income or irregular expenses, selecting and pursuing a financial goal using my 8-step framework, getting started with investing, evaluating a new stipend or job offer, and much more. Please find additional information and sign up for a free introductory call at PFforPhDs.com/coaching/. I can’t wait to speak with you! You can find the show notes for this episode at PFforPhDs.com/s22e3/. Without further ado, here’s my interview with Snehanjana Chatterjee.

Will You Please Introduce Yourself Further?

Emily (02:23): I am delighted to have joining me on the podcast today, Snehanjana Chatterjee, a third year graduate student at Texas Tech, and we’re here to talk about her financial journey as an international student. So, Snehanjana, I’m so glad to have you on the podcast. Will you please introduce yourself a little bit further for the listeners?

Snehanjana (02:40): Thank you for having me on the podcast. Uh, I’m Snehanjana Chatterjee. I am from Kolkata India and this is my third year in my PhD journey at Texas Tech University. I am studying, uh, plant mycorrhizal interactions and how they’re helping in using, uh, uh, resources from the soil and the economics behind it. Um, I’m in the Department of Biological Sciences at Texas Tech.

Emily (03:09): Wonderful. Tell us about how you’re funded as a PhD student.

Snehanjana (03:12): So I am funded through a teaching assistantship mainly. Um, so I have to teach, uh, every spring and uh, fall semester. Um, and you can reach out to the PI that you want to do a TAship under beforehand and you have to indicate that you want a TAship for that. Uh, previous, um, uh, semester and for summer, my PI provides, uh, funding, which is, uh, kind of more than what I get during spring and, uh, fall semesters. And I’m funded for those three months. And in those three months I do my research mostly.

Start-Up Costs and Challenges of New Grad Students

Emily (03:56): Let’s take it back to when you first arrived in the US and started graduate school. How did you, there’s a bit of money that’s needed up front, right? For the move and just everything that has to happen before you get paid for the first time. So for you, where were you drawing that money from?

Snehanjana (04:13): So, uh, one thing that I had to keep in mind that I didn’t get paid until October 1st. My TAship started from September 1st, but we didn’t until the 1st of October. So I had to come, uh, with a bit of money from India, uh, to make sure that I can sustain myself. Uh, I also had to pay the tuition, um, during that semester. So, uh, we have something called emergency payment plan, which divides the semester, uh, tuition into, into three parts. Um, so you can pay it upfront on September, in September or you can pay it like in different, uh, three install installments. So that was kind of tough and I did not know how to handle that and I thought they’re not paying us enough, um, which is a struggle we are still going through actually.

Emily (05:13): Can you tell me a little bit more about that? So you had the TA position and you had a paycheck coming, starting on October 1st, but they weren’t paying for your tuition that semester at all, or just the payment was like later

Snehanjana (05:26): They weren’t paying for a, uh, semester tuition. The thing is, so for fall it’s like from 2000 to 2,300, uh, dollars, and for spring it’s much more because it includes our health insurance. Uh, so for that, if you divide it into three installments, you have to pay like, I don’t know, 800 or 600 per month by 24th of that month. Um, so I did not have enough money, uh, to sustain myself at the beginning. Um, so I had to use whatever I brought from India, and that’s a big chunk of, uh, money that, uh, I had to ask from my parents.

Emily (06:13): Yeah, I I’m sure other people who are going through a similar transition have these same kinds of like concerns. Do you mind sharing with us like how much money you asked to, I don’t know if it was a gift or a loan, but how much money you asked from them for those, you know, the initial tuition payments and the move and the setting for the apartment and all that stuff, like it kind of to help other people estimate their budget?

Snehanjana (06:35): Yeah, I, uh, brought at least like $3,000, um, with me. And, uh, I had to open a bank account here. I did not know how to do that. I had to take help from previous students who were already here and after opening the bank account, I transferred all my money from my card to the account. Uh, so I think 2000 to 2,500 is completely fine if you, uh, bring that kind of money.

Current Grad Student Take-Home Stipend

Emily (07:05): Okay. So you kind of mentioned just now that getting paid enough is a struggle. Can you tell us maybe either what your stipend currently is, let’s say what you’re actually able to take home after you pay all your education related expenses or maybe what it’s been over the past few years?

Snehanjana (07:24): Yeah, so when I started, it was 1800 per month after taxes, but the department increased it gradually, uh, each semester and now it’s 2,300 per month after taxes. Um, but after paying my tuition and my rent, I barely have, uh, 1300, maybe a thousand to 1300. And with the grocery prices going up, it’s, it’s getting a bit difficult to live with that wage.

Emily (07:59): I can definitely understand <laugh> that it’s not going very far. Yet, that is actually a pretty big increase over just a couple of years. What was the reasoning behind why they increased the stipend? Was it due to students asking for it? Was it due to other factors? Do you know?

Snehanjana (08:16): Yeah, so we have a graduate representative committee and the this committee, uh, works with the graduate student and with the faculty and they listened to our grievances. Uh, like maybe they send a Google form and ask us what kind of concerns do you have? And they talked to the department chair and other faculty members at faculty meetings. And from that they decide if, uh, they need to increase our, uh, wages and if they have the certain budget for it. And I think they talked to the graduate school about this as well.

Different Strategies for Increasing Your Stipend

Emily (08:57): Okay. And I understand that you have also, aside from what the department chooses to pay you, like you personally have increased your stipend through various actions over the years. Can you tell us what those have been? What’s been effective?

Snehanjana (09:09): I personally, uh, reached out to certain, um, organizations. So I was Secretary of Association of Biologists at TTU and uh, for, uh, one fiscal year after it was done, um, they paid me a thousand dollars as like a scholarship at the end of it. And I am currently secretary at, uh, American Society for Microbiologists at Tech. And for that, uh, you also get a scholarship at the end of the fiscal year for about $500. Um, apart from that, I was also associated with the international, uh, council, uh, center, and I was a global guide there, so I was helping new and upcoming students to settle down. And for that I was paid $500 per semester. These things were added to my tuition, so they were not giving checks away, they were just adding it to my tuition bill.

Emily (10:14): Those almost sound like, well, they kind of sound like volunteer positions. Um, right. And then you sort of get like a, um, a sum of money as like a thank you for it. Any other ways that you’ve like increased your income or decreased your expenses over the past few years?

Snehanjana (10:30): I wouldn’t recommend this to anyone, but, uh, there was a time, um, I used to have one meal a day, which is not good. Um, so, uh, that is, that was one concern for me. But now I have like improved that, uh, and I have like three meals a day now. Uh, but circumstances, uh, kind of pushed me to do that. Um, and I was, uh, not being able to ask for help from my family because my mom and dad both are retired and that would put a lot of pressure on them, so I just did not tell them anything. Um, but I did apply for a scholarship, it’s not kind of a scholarship, it’s called, um, I forgot the name, but it’s for Texas, uh, students, uh, people living, sorry, students living in Texas. Um, so you tell them how much funding you need to pay your tuition, um, and it can be like from 500 to 1500 and uh, they give you the amount of money, they add it to your tuition account. But yeah, it has to be, if you’re going through like a very bad situation, like you have, uh, war back at your country, um, or you are going through really bad, um, I don’t know, financial situation, something like that.

Financial Hardship Scholarship

Emily (12:04): Hmm. It definitely sounds like you were there if you were eating only one meal per day and at some point. Yeah. I’m really sorry to hear that. Um, where did you find out about that scholarship?

Snehanjana (12:15): So the international office advertised about that and uh, I reached out to them and, uh, it doesn’t require a lot. You just have to write a, like a financial statement. Um, what kind of hardships are you, are you going through and, um, upload your, uh, tuition statements like how much you have paid over the, uh, semesters and they look at it and if you can provide more proof that uh, you don’t have enough, um, money in our account, they will definitely help you.

Emily (12:52): Hmm. Yeah, I’m really glad that they were able to connect you with that resource. Do you have a sense of like, were a lot of your peers applying for that scholarship?

Snehanjana (13:03): I don’t think so because it kind of is like a discreet thing that they do. Uh, it, it opens from like first to 10th of, uh, like February, March and April and then again in, uh, fall, maybe in, um, September, October, November. And they announce the awardee by the 24th of that month. And, uh, I have gotten that award three times. And, uh, it’s sometimes they give you the amount you want, sometimes they give you how much they could have given. Like if I want $700, it’s not, uh, like guaranteed that they will give me $700, maybe they will give me $400. So it depends on how much funding they have.

Emily (13:57): I’m, I’m really glad you’re sharing this though, like even though it sounds like kind of a, obviously you had to be in a difficult spot to be applying for and qualifying for the scholarship, but I’m really glad that you’re pointing this out because people may be, they may have access to this kind of resource at their institution and they’re just not aware of it yet. So it’s definitely worth asking. So your financial situation has been getting better over the years from the departmental side, from, you know, you taking some actions on your own behalf as well. So are you able to reach towards any financial goals at the moment?

Current Financial Goals

Snehanjana (14:33): For now, I don’t have a savings account. I would like to open one. I just have a checking account and, uh, to be honest, I don’t know how to invest money. So that is one, uh, goal that I would like to achieve maybe in 2025. Um, and whomever I reach out to, like any, uh, international students that have been alumni of Texas Tech, uh, they don’t really, uh, make me understand the process and it’s kind of confusing. So if you have any pointers that I can, I can learn from, maybe I can follow some of them.

Emily (15:18): I have a tip that I learned from, there was a podcast interview I did back in I think 2019 with Hui-chin Chen, um, who is a certified financial planner who specializes in cross-border tax issues. And this actually didn’t occur during that, that recorded episode, but something I learned from her during our later conversations. Um, so I don’t know if this is necessarily one of the difficulties you’ve been running into, but what I understand is that, um, not all brokerage firms where you would open, you know, an account to invest in, not all of them work with non-residents. So you may, and you can tell me if you have sometimes international students approach brokerage firms to open an account and somewhere in the paperwork it’s like, oh, no, no, you’re a non-resident, we can’t work with you. Has that happened to you?

Snehanjana (16:02): Uh, no, I have not approached them.

Emily (16:05): Okay. Um, but I know this is like something that is intimidating, like to non-residents, um, because they, they don’t wanna get told no and, you know, have to go through that process. So what I learned from Hui-chin Chen, um, is that there’s a brokerage firm called Interactive Brokers, which specifically sort of caters an advertises to non-residents. So if you or someone else is getting told no by a couple of your like top choices, then you could go to them and you’re gonna get a yes because that’s like part of their express business model. So that’s kind of one thing is like where to open an account, um, can I even open an account? Like those kinds of questions. What, what else has you like sort of stumped about the process?

Investing in the US Stock Market as an International Student

Snehanjana (16:50): So, so, um, in my bank app they always tell me to invest in like stocks and stuff, but I don’t understand that as well. And I don’t know if investing in stocks in the US will lead me to earn any money or not.

Emily (17:08): Hmm, yeah, kind of depends on your financial goal, right? Because with stock investing, um, it can be very volatile in the short term. Like we’re recording this interview in, uh, early March and the stock market has had some down days, um, in the past like month or two, like big downs. So we, when you say, you know, is it going to earn me money, you really have to talk about the timeline because over the short term, weeks, months, even small number of years, you know, you could put money in and have less money, you know, the next time you check, that’s absolutely possible. Yet over the longer term, 10, 20, 30, 40 years, um, you know, historical trends show us that the US stock market does very well over those kinds of periods of time. Um, as long as you stay invested <laugh>, right? As long as you’re not, you know, pulling money out, uh, when it drops and buying in when it’s high and, and those sorts of actions.

Emily (18:06): So, um, one of the things I talk about in that interview with Hui-chin Chen, which I would absolutely recommend, um, to anyone who’s a non-resident in the US, um, is about whether it’s, you know, prudent to invest in the US as an international grad student or postdoc, et cetera, when you’re not sure, are you gonna stay in the US long term or maybe move to another country afterwards? And her attitude was like pretty pro investing in the US but I would say you still have to, um, have that long term timeline in mind. Like if you’re going to be invested over the first few years, like you have to have a plan to probably stay invested over the long term to sort of, not guarantee, but have a much, much higher likelihood of a positive return on investment in that time.

Snehanjana (18:55): One other question is, I maybe don’t want to stay for long term in the US uh, so I have like two years left for my PhD. So for short term, maybe for the next two years, what do you recommend for international students? How, how should they proceed?

Emily (19:12): I think in my conversation with Hui-chin, if I remember correctly, the question was more about like, well, I’m not sure if I’m gonna stay in the US long term. And so she was kind of like, well, just get started investing. Now you don’t necessarily know what’s gonna happen, but maybe you’ll end up staying long term, or even if you don’t, you can like move the money. But if you’re saying more to me like, no, no, I’m sure I’m leaving in a couple of years, um, then I don’t know, I think cash is king in that case, like just, you know, park it in a high yield savings account. I mean, you said you don’t have a savings account here yet, but like, yeah, just park it in a savings account, get what you can without taking risk with it and start investing, you know, at the next place you move to whether it’s back, back to India or somewhere else, um, as soon as you can when you arrive there, because yeah, it’s certainly possible you could invest now and in two years if you’re trying to pull the money out, have less money than you did when you started, that’s definitely possible.

Snehanjana (20:07): Yeah. Okay.

Commercial

Emily (20:11): Emily here for a brief interlude. Would you like to learn directly from me on a personal finance topic, such as taxes, budgeting, investing, and goal-setting, each tailored specifically for graduate students and postdocs? I offer workshops on these topics and more in a variety of formats, and I’m now booking for the 2025-2026 academic year. If you would like to bring my content to your institution, would you please recommend me as a speaker or facilitator to your university, graduate school, graduate student association, or postdoc office? My seminars are usually slated as professional development or personal wellness. Ask the potential host to go to PFforPhDs.com/financial-education/ or simply email me at [email protected] to start the process. I really appreciate these recommendations, which are the best way for me to start a conversation with a potential host. The paid work I do with universities and institutes enables me to keep producing this podcast and all my other free resources. Thank you in advance if you decide to issue a recommendation! Now back to our interview.

Common Concerns of New International Grad Students

Emily (21:30): So you mentioned earlier that you were volunteering, I think you said as a global guide. What, what, what, um, office was that through?

Snehanjana (21:38): It was International Cultural Center.

Emily (21:40): Okay. So volunteering with the International Cultural Center. And part of your role was to like help new graduate students adjust right to life in the US. Um, and what kinds of questions or what kinds of concerns have you heard from those like new graduate students coming in that you know, you’ve learned from or you like to share, you know, what you’ve learned like with them or like what were those kind of common questions?

Snehanjana (22:05): The most common question is, uh, getting an apartment and before signing a lease, uh, they need to have like a person who guarantees that, uh, they’ll pay their, uh, rent every time. And if they’re not being able to have a guarantor for the lease, they need to pay extra money for that. So that is one of the concern that I heard. So, um, sometimes, uh, so when I came in I asked one of my lab mates, uh, to be a guarantor and she agreed, but that is not the case with everyone. Uh, most of the people who come here as undergrads maybe do not have friends yet. So, uh, finding a guarantor can be a bit of a problematic situation. And then they have to pay like $500 more, uh, for the rent, um, for first month at least.

Emily (23:02): Hmm. Yeah, I hadn’t heard of that in like a housing market before. So that, that’s a yeah, that’s a huge issue. So people are like arriving to your city and they don’t yet have a place to live, right? So they’re staying at, you know, hotels, Airbnbs, that kind of thing and finding a place to live signing a lease. But if they don’t have a guarantor, then they have, is it, um, is it money that they won’t get back or is it like an extra deposit that they do get back?

Snehanjana (23:31): They do not get back that. Um,

Emily (23:33): Wow, okay.

Snehanjana (23:34): Yeah, so that is a big chunk of money that is just taken away from them. And some of these, uh, places, they do not let the people move in until 18th of the month. So if the students come in for orientation day, like an eighth or ninth August, they either have to stay with, uh, someone else or at a hotel. Uh, fortunately, um, what the International Cultural Center is trying to do is trying to put them, um, at hotels that they do not have to pay for sometimes. Um, sometimes they find, uh, Texan residents who are willing to help these, uh, kids out and maybe they can stay with those residents for like 10 days and then move in later on.

Emily (24:20): Wow, okay. So it’s like the whole market is kind of, they have these sort of wide policies around this extra money that they have to pay or the date they can move in, like, wow, I hadn’t heard of that before. I wonder, I wonder how widespread that, that, that is in other, other cities.

Snehanjana (24:36): Yeah, so I think, uh, that is quite widespread, uh, at least in Lubbock. Um, because uh, the community I used to live at first, um, the management was not that good and uh, I used to get a huge utility bill at the end of the month, like $80 per person, uh, when we are sharing three bedroom, uh, apartment. Um, but uh, that has decreased for me when I moved into a different, uh, uh, community. Um, they have a cap for the utility bill and that helps out a lot.

Emily (25:17): How much like were these international students prepped in advance of their arrival of like, this is how this works. You’re gonna come here, we’re gonna try to help you find a place to stay, you’re not gonna be able to move until after the 18th. You’re gonna like, are they told this stuff in advance or, or not?

Snehanjana (25:33): Yeah, so the Global Guide program, um, hosted several, uh, seminars, uh, webinars. Uh, so some of the kids joined both grad and undergrad and we had to like tell them repeatedly that these are the rules that you have to follow. You’ll have a culture shock when you come in and it’ll get frustrating, but you can reach out to us anytime you want. Um, and they have voiced their frustrations whenever they get to learn that they can’t move in before like 18th of the month, but they have to pay the entire rent for the month. Um, yeah. So they have to pay like $480 for staying 15 days or less than 15 days, uh, in that apartment. And that’s a lot of money for an international student.

Emily (26:26): Yes, I would be culture shocked by this as well, moving from another American city to, to Lubbock. Wow. Okay. Any, any other like common questions or concerns that you’ve noticed?

Snehanjana (26:37): So some of them, uh, don’t know how to do groceries. So most of them, uh, either take the buses and the buses here stop running at 7:00 PM so it’s from 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM Um, you don’t have to pay for the buses, uh, but carrying the groceries from Walmart to like your house is a big task. So what they do is go and go with a bunch of people together, either to Costco or to Walmart, and uh, they have all the groceries together and they carry those groceries all the way from Walmart, uh, to their house. Um, that is one huge thing that they do. And, uh, there are not many people who have cars and uh, that’s one of the big struggles that they go through. So they have a designated date or a date that they go for groceries, but some of the global guides are helping them. If they have cars, they take uh, like three or four of them together to the grocery store and they buy whatever they need and they give a ride back as well.

Emily (27:49): Yeah, those infrastructure issues are such a big thing. I remember when I lived without a car, I also was like, how am I doing this grocery thing? How, how was this happening? Um, and it was always kind of like a catch as catch can kind of like situation. Wow. Well, do you have, as we’re like wrapping up here, any um, questions for me beyond what you were just asking about investing? I mean, I’m happy to talk more about investing if you want, but any kind of other financial wellness related things that I might be able to help you with right now?

Savings Accounts and Credit Cards as an International Grad Student

Snehanjana (28:18): Not really. I just, I just really need to open a savings account as soon as possible, but it’s not, uh, you have to go to the bank to do that and with my schedule it’s kind of busy. Um, and you have to take an appointment with the bank, so I need to do that ASAP actually.

Emily (28:37): Hmm. Yeah. Um, who are you banking with?

Snehanjana (28:41): Uh, Bank of America.

Emily (28:42): Hmm. That’s your first problem. <laugh>, um, bank of America, I, I am a former Bank of America customer myself. Um, and the customer service is very difficult as you just said. Wait, why do you have to go into an account? Why into a branch? Why do you have to make an appointment? This is an easy process. Um, so I would actually say maybe don’t open a savings account with Bank of America. I doubt they’re gonna give you a very good interest rate anyway. Um, I would say look to the online only banks, um, that might be available. So for example, I bank with Ally. Um, another good one is Capital 1 360. Um, but even if you look at like a website like Bank Rate or NerdWallet, those kinds of sites, those aggregators, um, you can kind of search for like okay, what’s the best, you know, high yield savings account available, um, now and since you have an established bank account with Bank of America, like you’ve gone through the process of showing your ID and all that stuff that you have to do, um, once you have that it’s easier to get like a second account somewhere else ’cause the first bank has done like the work for it. Um, so yeah, I would say check out like an online only bank. Um, and I’m not sure if you would even have to open checking. You could probably just open the savings account if you’d like to and you know, start transferring money over there and getting a halfway decent interest rate on it.

Snehanjana (30:02): Actually I do have a question. So I have like four credit cards and I have friends that have like, I don’t know, 10 to 12 credit cards and they use these credit cards to book a flight and they get points for it and then they use those points back in India. And I was trying to understand the game, but it seems so complicated. 

Emily (30:28): Yeah. 

Snehanjana (30:29): Do you recommend having like 10 to 12 credit cards for like a each person to get these points? 

Emily (30:37): I don’t think you necessarily have to go that far, but, um, for international flights, I actually recently started learning from the brand 10x travel. There’s a bunch of brands like this, like where they sort of teach you these, um, travel hacking, you know, flight, getting free flights, like kind of strategies. But the general thing that you do, and I have, I’ve done this much more on the domestic side than for international flights. So I’m a little bit speaking about something I’ve like learning, but I haven’t actually practiced yet. Um, it’s more about you figure out like what airline or airlines you commonly use. Like do you already have a preferred airline for your trips?

Snehanjana (31:21): Yeah, it’s mostly either Emirates or Qatar.

Emily (31:24): Okay. So for Emirates and Qatar, then you would figure out what bank or banks like Chase, um, Amex that offer like credit cards. There’s a bunch of them. Um, what, which banks are offering points that transfer to either those airlines that you want to fly on or one of their partners? ’cause these airlines are all in like alliances together and you can kinda um, like book, you know, a flight that’s ultimately on Emirates but you’re booking it through one of their partners. So sometimes you can get deals that way, whatever. So you figure out where you can like basically accumulate points through your normal credit card, you know, everyday kind of spending and how those points can be transferred to ultimately get you on the airline that you want to fly on. So I don’t know offhand like who works with Qatar or Emirates, um, but you could look that up and figure it out.

Emily (32:17): So then like I’m really familiar with the Chase system for example. So let’s just say that like Chase did transfer to those, I don’t know if they do. Um, so you would basically accumulate points on one or more Chase cards and you would also probably sign up for some new, um, credit cards that have signup bonuses. You would do that slowly, like as your spending is able to support it. Um, ’cause maybe you only spend on a credit card, I don’t know, 500 or a thousand dollars a month. You would have to make sure that your spending can meet their like minimum spend. So maybe it’s $3,000 in three months or $6,000 in four months, like whatever it is, make sure you can do it based on your projections of your spending. But signing up for those new cards and getting signup bonuses and also putting ongoing spending on these cards is kind of how you accumulate those points. And then you turn the points into redeeming them as like free flights. So it can get complicated, um, if you want it to be, but I think there’s also probably a way to figure it out to do it since you already know like your preferred airlines to do it like fairly simply. Um, yeah, so that’s kind of what I’m learning slash starting to like redeem on my end.

Snehanjana (33:28): Yeah, yeah, because I was asking one of my friend and he was kind of directing me and then he got, uh, busy with his research. So <laugh> I couldn’t anymore, so Yeah.

Emily (33:41): Yeah. Well you might go back to him when it seems like he has more free time if he can teach you like the system or whatever. Um, or you can go through, you know, like I just, I just mentioned 10X travel. I think there’s like the points guy, like there’s other places you can learn from. Actually the points guy Brian Kelly, he just released a book on travel hacking that I just got from the library. I haven’t started it yet. Um, so you could read something like that and figure out like how to play this game. But to answer your direct question of like, do you need 10 to 12 credit cards? No, probably not that many. Um, but should you be signing up for a new credit card, you know, once a year, twice a year, however much your spending can support? Yeah, that would certainly help get you there faster if you do these signup bonuses. But you have to be careful about it because your spending as a graduate student is automatically kind of on the lower side and a lot of these cards have annual fees. You have to make sure that the, you know, the benefits you’re getting are justifying the fee and all that kind of stuff. Um, it was pretty intimidating to me when I was in graduate school to think about pursuing credit card rewards and stuff, so I kind of stayed away from it until afterwards. But I think if you’re very careful about it, um, it can be beneficial. And actually, I don’t know when this episode is going to air, but I have um, another one that I recorded with um, Brendan Henrique and I’m not sure again what the publication date relative is going to be, but I think they both, this episode and that episode are gonna come out sometime in spring 2025. So you could, you could listen to that or the listener can look for that episode, um, in the recent past or the near future, um, to kind of learn more about the system that, that he’s using.

Snehanjana (35:13): Okay. Yeah, sure.

Emily (35:15): Yeah. Any other questions I can try to help with?

Snehanjana (35:18): No, but, uh, one common, uh, I won’t say scam, but kind of scam ish thing that I faced when I came to Lubbock was everyone was telling me to, uh, sign up for the Discover card because they were like, oh, I’ll get a hundred dollars cash back and you’ll also get a hundred dollars cash back sign up for that. And that Discover card has never helped me. It keeps on telling me that you’ll get cash back, but then some problem or the other arises from that card and will get any kind of cash back. Uh, I am thinking about, uh, not using it anymore.

Emily (36:00): Yeah, I wouldn’t, I would not have expected that. So Discover is not the most popular type of credit card, but it’s definitely one that sort of caters to like students or you know, like people new to the US like you were. Um, so I wouldn’t necessarily have called it a scam, although I’m not sure about like the, you know, what the benefits are that they were sort of holding out and that like didn’t really happen like either I I, you would know more than I would, I would be surprised if they were like outright lying, but like maybe they just made it way more complicated than anybody reasonably like would expect it to be. Um, so yeah, but if a card’s not working for you, totally move on because a Discover card is a great first card, but like, you don’t have to once you get, once you’re onto card number two, don’t worry about card number one. Like you could, I don’t know, I don’t necessarily wanna say like close it because it is helpful to have your oldest card like remaining open, but you certainly don’t have to use it in any significant way. Right.

Snehanjana (36:56): Yeah.

Best Financial Advice for Another Early-Career PhD

Emily (36:57): Yeah. But thank you for sharing that ’cause yeah, discover definitely does sort of advertise and cater to like people new to the credit world in the US Right. Um, okay. Well it’s been absolutely lovely to chat with you over the last few minutes and thank you so much for sharing like your own story and like what you’ve, you know, been able to help other international students with. That’s really insightful. Um, I want to end with what is your best financial advice for another early career PhD? And that could be something that we have touched on in the interview already, or it could be something completely new.

Snehanjana (37:27): My best financial advice that I learned from my father mainly is to save as much as possible, but don’t just save for like, oh, I’ll use it in the future. Have fun with some of it. Uh, not too much fun though. I’m very, I I can, I can tell you that I’m stingy, but not too stingy. I do like, uh, things I do, I am materialistic, so I buy stuff for myself and my for my friends, but I make sure that I’m on my budget, I’m on my limit to use this. I have that kind of sense because I was told by my parents like, you need to save for this. And currently I’m saving up for a house. That’s my goal. Um, I don’t know when I can buy a house, but that’s one of the goals that I have. Um, yeah. I’ll, I’ll put that money towards like buying a house, definitely.

Emily (38:26): Awesome. Well I love that advice too. It definitely is about having like balance, um, in your life and I actually really like saving specifically for fun things. Like, yes, I’m saving for the long-term future or yes, I’m saving for like emergencies boring stuff like that. But like yeah, I’m also saving for travel and I’m saving for entertainment and like having some, yeah, it just makes the whole process a lot more enjoyable when you can tie it to like, yeah, this is something I’m really going to, um, have fun with in the near future. So thank you so much for coming on the podcast and it’s been great to have you.

Snehanjana (38:56): Thank you so much for having me.

Outro

Emily (39:09): Listeners, thank you for joining me for this episode! I have a gift for you! You know that final question I ask of all my guests regarding their best financial advice? My team has collected short summaries of all the answers ever given on the podcast into a document that is updated with each new episode release. You can gain access to it by registering for my mailing list at PFforPhDs.com/advice/. Would you like to access transcripts or videos of each episode? I link the show notes for each episode from PFforPhDs.com/podcast/. See you in the next episode, and remember: You don’t have to have a PhD to succeed with personal finance… but it helps! Nothing you hear on this podcast should be taken as financial, tax, or legal advice for any individual. The music is “Stages of Awakening” by Podington Bear from the Free Music Archive and is shared under CC by NC. Podcast editing by me and show notes creation by Dr. Jill Hoffman.

The Simple Way to Invest as an International Grad Student or Postdoc

August 25, 2025 by Jill Hoffman

In this episode, Emily interviews Hui-Chin Chen, a Certified Financial Planner specializing in advising globally mobile professionals. Hui-Chin is a managing partner and financial advisor with Jade & Cowry, and she is a repeat podcast guest. Her first interview from 2019 is required listening for international graduate students and postdocs prior to starting this episode. Hui-Chin gives us a bird’s-eye view of a simple investing strategy for nonresidents in the US if using a tax-advantaged retirement account proves too complex. Hui-Chin and Emily review the IRA eligibility criteria for nonresidents with respect to fellowship income and married filing separately. They discuss whether and when someone moving out of the US should engage a tax advisor. Finally, Hui-Chin answers one investing and one tax question submitted by subscribers to the Personal Finance for PhDs mailing list.

Links mentioned in the Episode

  • Hui-chin Chen’s Company Website
  • Hui-chin Chen’s Blog
  • Hui-chin Chen’s LinkedIn
  • PF for PhDs S4E17: Can and Should an International Student, Scholar, or Worker Invest in the US?
  • PF for PhDs Quarterly Estimated Tax Workshop
  • Host a PF for PhDs Seminar at Your Institution
  • Emily’s E-mail Address
  • PF for PhDs Subscribe to Mailing List
  • PF for PhDs Podcast Hub
The Simple Way to Invest as an International Grad Student or Postdoc

Teaser

Hui-chin (00:00): Probably a lot of people have that decision fatigue and just, I don’t know what the first step should be. So if you’ve been thinking about this for a year plus and you haven’t taken action, I would say just take that action and that would you know your future self will thank you.

Introduction

Emily (00:25): Welcome to the Personal Finance for PhDs Podcast: A Higher Education in Personal Finance. This podcast is for PhDs and PhDs-to-be who want to explore the hidden curriculum of finances to learn the best practices for money management, career advancement, and advocacy for yourself and others. I’m your host, Dr. Emily Roberts, a financial educator specializing in early-career PhDs and founder of Personal Finance for PhDs.

Emily (00:55): This is Season 22, Episode 1, and today my guest is Hui-Chin Chen, a Certified Financial Planner specializing in advising globally mobile professionals. Hui-Chin is a managing partner and financial advisor with Jade & Cowry, and she is a repeat podcast guest. Her first interview from 2019 is required listening for international graduate students and postdocs prior to starting this episode. Hui-Chin gives us a bird’s-eye view of a simple investing strategy for nonresidents in the US if using a tax-advantaged retirement account proves too complex. Hui-Chin and I review the IRA eligibility criteria for nonresidents with respect to fellowship income and married filing separately. We discuss whether and when someone moving out of the US should engage a tax advisor. Finally, Hui-Chin answers one investing and one tax question submitted by subscribers to the Personal Finance for PhDs mailing list.

Emily (02:00): Let’s talk fellowship taxes for a minute here. These action items are for you if you recently switched or will soon switch onto non-W-2 fellowship income as a grad student, postdoc, or postbac; you are a US citizen, resident, or resident for tax purposes; and you are not having income tax withheld from your stipend or salary. Action item #1: Fill out the Estimated Tax Worksheet on page 8 of IRS Form 1040-ES. This worksheet will estimate how much income tax you will owe in 2025 and tell you whether you are required to make manual tax payments on a quarterly basis. The next quarterly estimated tax due date is September 15, 2025. Action item #2: Whether you are required to make estimated tax payments or pay a lump sum at time tax, open a separate, named savings account for your future tax payments. Calculate the fraction of each paycheck that will ultimately go toward tax and set up an automated recurring transfer from your checking account to your tax savings account to prepare for that bill. This is what I call a system of self-withholding, and I suggest putting it in place starting with your very first fellowship paycheck so that you don’t get into a financial bind when the payment deadline arrives.

Emily (03:25): If you need some help with the Estimated Tax Worksheet or want to ask me a question, please consider joining my workshop, Quarterly Estimated Tax for Fellowship Recipients. It explains every line of the worksheet and answers the common questions that PhD trainees have about estimated tax. The workshop includes 1.75 hours of video content, a spreadsheet, and invitations to at least one live Q&A call each quarter this tax year. The next Q&A call is on Thursday, September 4, 2025. If you want to purchase this workshop as an individual, go to PF for PhDs dot com slash Q E tax. You can find the show notes for this episode at PFforPhDs.com/s22e1/. Without further ado, here’s my interview with Hui-Chin Chen.

Will You Please Introduce Yourself Further?

Emily (04:30): I have a real treat for us today. I have a returning guest, Hui-chin Chen, who is the managing partner and financial planner at Jade and Cowry. Hui-Chin was first on the podcast in season four, episode 17, and by all accounts, this is one of the most popular episodes of this podcast, if not the number one most popular. And it is definitely the episode that I get the most thanks and compliments about. So I want to thank and compliment Hui-chin for the excellent interview that she gave last time, and for the listener we are going to build on that interview. We are not gonna go back and rehash all the points that we made in the first one, and I would say it is a must listen if you are an international graduate student or postdoc or worker or similar in the us, go back and listen to that episode, then listen to this one because we are building on top of it. Um, we are, we’re not going back and asking all the same questions. So Hui-chin, thank you so much for agreeing to come back on the podcast. Thank you for your previous contribution and the contribution you’re about to make. Um, is there any, is there any further introduction you would like to make to give us background on what you do and who you are?

Hui-chin (05:39): Uh, sure, uh, of course. Thank you Emily for inviting me back and thank you for all the compliments, <laugh> from, from you and the listeners. I definitely heard from some of your listeners reaching out, uh, in the past. So in addition to my work at Jade and Cowry, so I’m a cross-border financial planner. Uh, I work mainly with globally mobile professionals and multinational families, which a lot of you are. I also started a, a professional network called the CIGA Network. It’s for, uh, cross border financial planners from a lot of different jurisdictions outside the US so we can collaborate on work for clients better to provide cross-border financial planning better. So, um, so for, for those of you who are not planning to stay in the US or have, uh, plans to go around the world in the future, um, that could be a resource as well.

Investing While Living in the US as an International Grad Student or Postdoc

Emily (06:28): I know both of us reviewed that prior episode, which is published back in 2019 before jumping into this one, and you observed that we approached that interview, we got very quick into the tactics, how do I do this? Where do I do that? And I know you want to take a little bit of a step back and give us kind of a bigger picture about investing while living in the US as an international graduate student, postdoc, et cetera. Can you give us that perspective?

Hui-chin (06:56): Of course. Um, so now I have I, I guess five or six years more experience working with more people from walk all walks of life. All the commonality is that they have some kind of international background coming from different countries. We’re going to different countries. You realize that there are a wide range of possible tax situation, wide range of what people want from their life wide range of family situations, wide range of how many nationalities are in the household. Eventually, those are like Emily, like you said, and those are important considerations when you go down to the weeds. But if you’re new to investing, take a step back. The question if you’re asking, should I be investing while I’m studying in the US or I’m working in the us? I don’t answer a lot of questions with a hundred percent yes, but that’s probably a question I would give you a hundred percent yes, <laugh>, um, just do it.

Hui-chin (07:53): If you’re considering, um, you know, I have extra money, I have saved up my emergency fund. I want to prepare for my future. Should I be investing in an account in the US which I can right now open with no problem. And I say, yes, go ahead and do that. Don’t worry too much about, um, the future tax situation yet. Um, of course then there’s the, okay, if my situation’s a little bit more complicated, I want to know what kind of accounts to use. We’ll talk about that later. Um, but the big picture is investing for your future is important. If Emily hasn’t told you that, you know, in the past, I’m sure she, I’m pretty sure she has, and she probably repeat that over and over. And that’s one thing we really want to drill in. Don’t get bogged down down into your particular situation and just not do anything because you don’t know what the best way to invest is in terms of accounts. Just, you know, open the most simple accounts, uh, taxable brokerage accounts and start investing

Emily (08:55): Could not agree more. And I think that is actually a really good kind of summary of the highest level takeaway from that previous episode, which is, if you are financially ready to start investing, you have the emergency fund and so forth, as you mentioned, do not let your status in the US hold you back from engaging in this process if it’s right for your finances at this time. And the way that I’ve heard this phrase before, maybe from the US perspective, is like, don’t let the tax tail wag the financial decision dog, right? So like the taxes can be worked out <laugh>, there’s nothing to work out if you don’t just start investing, right? You just need to start, you know, if you’re ready. So thank you so much for that like high level, and I really, I’m glad that you added, Hey, if, if the account situation is so complicated and, and you don’t know if you wanna use a tax advantage retirement account and all of that, hey, a brokerage account is available to you, a simple taxable brokerage account, normal kind of account that you could open at a brokerage firm that is always available to you. Again, there may be tax implications, but it’s the simplest level. And so that is an appropriate way to get started investing. If that’s all you wanna do at that time, that that’s perfectly fine. Am I hearing that right?

Hui-chin (10:07): Correct. I, I know probably a lot of people have that decision fatigue and just, I don’t know what the first step should be. So if you’ve been thinking about this for a year plus and you haven’t taken action, I would say just take that action and that would, you know, your future self will thank you.

Taxable Compensation and IRA Eligibility for Non-Residents

Emily (10:25): Absolutely. Just get off the starting line, just do something. I I tell the same thing to, um, the people who I teach as well. It’s like you have a lifetime of investing ahead of you and it’s a long journey and you can expect that you will make mistakes or at least have to take steps that you’re not a hundred percent sure of along the way. And that’s okay. You have time to course correct, you have time to fix things later on. Getting started is the most important step here and then you can make some adjustments as you go along. Now I’ve gotta take us into the weeds. Okay. We got a lot of weeds questions. I had some weeds questions. I asked for questions from my mailing list. They submitted some down in the weeds questions. So, okay, we’re gonna go there. Now that we’ve gotten the high level, let’s assume that someone is ready to invest, uh, while they’re in the US and, and they have those questions about what kind of account should I use. Okay, I wanna go beyond the taxable brokerage account. So when we last spoke, um, it was right before the secure act passed and we did discuss the change that was coming in the secure act. So as a review for the listener, um, it used to be that income from fellowships, so like non-employee type positions, but given inside academic, you know, graduate student and postdoc positions, um, this was initially not eligible to be contributed to an IRA, an individual retirement arrangement. Um, the secure act changed that for graduate students and postdocs. So now even if you have fellowship income, not from an employee position, but you are a grad student or a postdoc, that income became eligible in terms of it being compensation from this term taxable compensation. But what we talked about is, okay, well is it taxable? Because that is what someone who’s a non-resident in the US needs to consider. Okay, yeah. If you’re a US citizen or resident, it’s gonna be taxable, we know this, but if you’re a non-resident, well, we have the questions about what is the tax treaty that applies and so forth. So can you elaborate on that anymore? How can someone who’s a non-resident in the US tell whether they have taxable compensation, whether they have income that is eligible to be contributed to an IRA?

Hui-chin (12:30): That’s a question I, I don’t know. I have a hundred percent answer to that. Obviously the, the original distinction be before like there was a confu, not the confusion, but before secure act, the distinction is if it’s W2 reported on W2 versus the income that you’re getting either from school or organization, that’s non W2, right? So that’s the fellowship income and things like that. Now it’s clarified or added in the legislation that those non W2 income that may, may be reported as miscellaneous income on 1099, those can be counted as fellowship income, but those supposedly would be reported, uh, taxable. Meaning when you file your tax return in the us it’ll be added depending on um, your tax, whether you’re already a resident past your exempted uh, uh period, or if you have, um, that the tax treaty like you mentioned so that you know not fall into the normal exempt period.

Hui-chin (13:37): My take is if it’s not listed on your tax return when you report as a taxable income, then you cannot use it to contribute to, uh, an IRA or Roth IRA or 401k for that matter. Of course, if you don’t have, uh, W2 income is unlikely, it’s 401k, it’s most likely your own IRA or Roth IRA. But the idea is that taxable means not, doesn’t mean that you didn’t pay tax on it because you have the standard deduction, you have potential other things to reduce how much become taxable income, but that income must be listed on your tax return to begin with for it to count as taxable compensation.

Emily (14:22): Yeah, I like that you pointed out that that’s a very clear resource that one can go to after you’ve filed one type of tax return. Um, in the US like a non-resident can see, okay, I had taxable, potentially taxable income, and then I have maybe some income over here that’s listed as tax exempt. You can see they’re in different, they’re different boxes, different sections. So did I have any in this taxable column? Um, then okay, then that’s taxable compensation. Um, and I like that you pointed out that just because income is taxable doesn’t mean it ends up getting taxed, but it has to be eligible to be taxed. Yes. So I think that makes total sense.

Married Filing Separately as a Non-Resident: Implications for Roth and Traditional IRA Eligibility

Emily (15:06): This next question comes from me actually because as I’ve been learning more about non-resident taxes, I realize that it’s pretty common for non-residents to file married filing separately. Can you explain why or in what circumstances non-residents would file married filing separately and then what implications that has for their Roth IRA or traditional IRA eligibility?

Hui-chin (15:29): Well, to clarify, there is no married filing jointly on 1040NR <laugh>. So you’re either single or you’re married, you know, and each filing as an individual. So I know a lot of countries like that in the world, like they don’t have filing joint option anyway, so you might feel like, oh yeah, it’s normal. But in the US the default when you’re married as a resident is filing jointly and they usually get better tax treatment than if you do married filing separately.

Emily (15:59): And this is one of those examples, is this Roth IRA eligibility? So if someone does is married and they’re filing separately as a non-resident, then what happens to their IRA eligibility?

Hui-chin (16:11): Yeah, so for the Roth, IRA, um, there is a income, uh, limit. Obviously if you are doing the normal single or married filing jointly, the income limit is much higher. But the married filing separately, because it’s not a, um, I should not comment, but it’s a, a specific thing that when they put in their legislation, they don’t want the people with married filed separately to have the same benefit as married filing jointly. So they set that limit very low at $10,000, I believe. And um, and that’s the one that doesn’t index by inflation. All the other are indexed by inflation. So right now, if you’re married filing jointly, the income limit would be like 200 something thousand. Yeah. And it, it changes every year. So I always, whenever I tell people, you just Google <laugh>, you know, Roth, uh, Roth IRA contribution can limit that year, like this year 2025 will show you a chart that clearly laid it out.

Emily (17:11): And then I also read something about there’s a difference if you never lived with your spouse during the course of the year

Hui-chin (17:17): For international student. Yes, I can see if you come here on your own and your spouse is not even here yet. I think that’s just this, the, the married filing separately distinguished between if you’re truly, you have basically you’re truly two households, right? So that they set that limit to be the same as what if you’re single.

Emily (17:35): Okay. So let’s take a couple scenarios here. So one, you’re a married non-resident and you and your spouse are living in the us you’re living together then for a Roth IRA, your income ceiling to be able to contribute is $10,000 and that’s the taxable in the US $10,000, right? Okay. Um, then let’s say you are married and you and your spouse live separately. Maybe you are going to two different universities for your graduate degrees. You do not occupy the same household, then the eligibility is is if you were single, is that what you’re saying?

Hui-chin (18:08): Correct, because the, the two uh, different sections are single head of a household or married felling separately as the, the same category. And you did not live with your spouse at any time. So the, I the basically the distinction is that if you’re clearly married, living in the same household, they want to kind of, I shouldn’t call it penalize you. They don’t want to afford you the same benefit of why not you could marry filing jointly, but obviously if you’re non resident then you cannot, so it’s not an option. Um, but for just because this, uh, specific rule applies to residents and non-residents. So the idea is that if you’re truly just, you know, even you’re married, you are in two different households, like you’re single, so they give you that same limit as if you’re single.

Emily (18:58): And same kind of logic if your spouse is in another country, not even living in the us correct?

Hui-chin (19:03): Yeah. So you would still have to file married filing separately unless you want to tell the world that you are single <laugh>. Again, the, the idea is that we’re into the weeds. If you are contributing so little and you just want to make sure you’re investing, don’t worry about Roth IRA, you know, traditional non-deductible, IRA, open a normal account, invest the same amount, that’s totally fine too.

Emily (19:30): Hmm. I’m glad you took us back there. I was gonna do the same thing. <laugh>. Um, if this is all getting too complicated, if you have question, like if you’re listening to us talk about the married filing separately stuff and you’re like, I’m just confused, I don’t know what my eligibility is anymore, don’t worry about it. You don’t have to use that type of account. You can just use a regular taxable brokerage account and that’s perfectly okay. <laugh> for the time being.

Building an Investment Portfolio as an International Postdoc Residing in the US

Emily (19:54): Now I received this question actually, uh, from someone who was at, I gave a webinar recently for the National Postdoctoral Association, um, overall, and then someone who, uh, is an international postdoc asked me this question as a follow up and I said, submit this to my upcoming interview because I’m gonna be asking question these questions. Okay. So her question was, given the high mobility rates of postdocs and balancing long-term investment with liquidation of assets, what are medium risk investments that international postdocs residing in the US can take advantage of?

Hui-chin (20:30): It’s a good question, but also, um, a question I think needs a little bit more, um, explanation from the person we’re asking what that means, right? So first of all, I wouldn’t say there’s one investment you can find is just medium risk, right? The idea is that when we’re talking about risk spectrum, so this is going back to investing 101, like how do we build a portfolio that’s appropriate for your risk tolerance and risk capability? Meaning a lot of times I deal with how long you can invest. This usually is come from a portfolio construction of different investments, and that’s what diversification is. It’s not just, oh, I’m buying a hundred percent stock, but you know, a hundred stocks in my a hundred percent stock portfolio. That’s diversified, that’s diversified within your stock, but your portfolio is not diversified across risk spectrum, right? So without going into, you know, like going into inve investment philosophy and basics, the idea I would say is looking at the asset allocation of, of your portfolio, are you, um, investing across stock and bonds, which is the two main building blocks of, um, the publicly traded portfolio.

Hui-chin (21:49): Usually if you go look at, um, for example, target date funds or, um, some other kind of life strategy funds, so like target date funds is based on risk capability. So how long you have to invest. So if you say, see a target date fund of 2050, that means they don’t expect you to need the money until you are in 2050. But if you get one that’s 2025, that means, oh, I need the money now. So you can see how those two funds have different stock versus bonds asset allocation, and that gives you an indication for your time horizon, right? So when you’re talking about you’re globally mobile and you know, you wanna balance liquidity, it sounds like in your mind there’s a chance you might need to take the money with you, you don’t wanna keep it here, but then, um, it doesn’t necessarily mean that’s your investment timeframe, right? If there’s an account, you can leave it there forever, you might. So again, like your balancing act might be different from other people’s balancing act. So you might in your mind, decided what my investment timeframe is, and that’s your, um, sort of risk that you are able to take. So I would suggest that without going into, you know, looking at everybody’s risk tolerance and how to build the proper portfolios, a starting point, when you’re looking, you, you can go look at, you know, Vanguard, fidelity, all of those companies, target date fund, and see how they have the different asset allocation and pick the date that matches yours. It doesn’t mean that you have to buy that exact fund because a lot of them are mutual funds. So for, um, non-residents, you can’t buy them <laugh>. And for people who are residents, uh, but you might eventually leave, but want to keep the account open. Um, mutual funds not the best option. So I don’t re recall if we discussed that in the last episode. So you might want to see, okay, how can I replicate this asset allocation with this kind of investment timeframe, um, by buying the ETFs myself. So for example, Vanguard, if you go to their target date fund, they will tell you exactly how, what other individual Vanguard funds or ETFs they use to build that target date fund, so you can replicate that strategy yourself.

Emily (24:15): Thank you so much for that explanation. And this is news to me about the mutual fund. So we’re gonna put a pin in that and come back to it in a minute. When I was conversing with this person who, who posed this question, I was asking her, what is your actual timeline on your investments? And not necessarily how long you think they’re going to stay in the us but overall do you think you’re going to be investing from now until you’re in retirement, you know, many decades from now? And so I, I think even someone, you can correct me if I’m wrong, but I think even someone who is planning on moving their money, let’s say in the next decade to a different country, they still may have a very long investment horizon and their choice of investments, how much risk to take on would probably still reflect that total view, not just the time period that they plan on keeping the money in a US type account. Is that correct?

Hui-chin (25:08): I think the main issue is, um, if they need to move the investments overseas, most of the time if you’re buying a US domiciled, um, investment, it may not be possible for them to move, move the investment in kind, meaning not sell them, right? If you need to sell your investments, then that’s what your investment timeframe is.

Emily (25:29): But wouldn’t, couldn’t you just sell and rebuy something similar?

Hui-chin (25:34): Correct. But the, the risk of your selling at a loss is the, is the same. So is the, so technically you’re right. If you like, they can come a hundred percent replicate their existing strategy and rebuy in a different jurisdiction. It’s kind of like when we’re talking about tax loss, harvesting <laugh> type situation where you can sell and rebuy and technically you are not losing out. But when you’re talking about transition, usually there’s a slightly longer timeframe. So I would say you are, you’re correct in that too. Like if you can, if you know that your likely will be able to create a strategy after it’s just a brief time outta the market to transition into that, you might take a loss, kind of like non-deductible loss or something. But the idea is when you repurchase the investment, it’s still at the low point, so you’re not really taking a full loss

Emily (26:34): So it could go either way. It depends on where you think you’re gonna move the money to the investment options that are there. So there’s again, a lot of considerations. We, it’s hard to simplify it down super, uh, super a lot. So as ever, it’s gonna depend on the specifics.

Commercial

Emily (26:52): Emily here for a brief interlude. Would you like to learn directly from me on a personal finance topic, such as taxes, budgeting, investing, and goal-setting, each tailored specifically for graduate students and postdocs? I offer workshops on these topics and more in a variety of formats, and I’m now booking for the 2025-2026 academic year. If you would like to bring my content to your institution, would you please recommend me as a speaker or facilitator to your university, graduate school, graduate student association, or postdoc office? My seminars are usually slated as professional development or personal wellness. Ask the potential host to go to PFforPhDs.com/financial-education/ or simply email me at [email protected] to start the process. I really appreciate these recommendations, which are the best way for me to start a conversation with a potential host. The paid work I do with universities and institutes enables me to keep producing this podcast and all my other free resources. Thank you in advance if you decide to issue a recommendation! Now back to our interview.

Investing as a Non-Resident: Mutual Fund Restrictions and ETF Options

Emily (28:12): I just learned that non-residents can’t buy mutual funds, but they can buy ETFs. Did I hear that? Can you expound on that a little bit more?

Hui-chin (28:21): Yeah, so in essence, mutual funds and ETFs are two different financial products. Mutual funds are when you are buying the shares, you’re buying directly from the mutual fund companies. So once they get your money, they go out there and buy more stocks and bonds that represent part of their funds. The ETFs are in a sense also a mutual fund, but the shares are traded on the exchange. So when you’re buying a share, you’re most likely buying from another investor from the fund. And because it’s treated on an exchange like a stock, um, there’s no restrictions on who you can, uh, who who can own those shares versus mutual funds. Because the us um, regulations or the compliance situation, they do not let non US resident tax resident, um, become a shareholder in that mutual fund company. So that’s the, the main difference. So a lot of times it’s, it’s not always like you cannot hold them. Like for example, I know, um, Vanguard in the past would let, um, if you say, oh, I no longer live in the us, they would just say, okay, we won’t sell it, but you can’t buy anymore. So the only, the only thing you can do is to take it, to sell it eventually. But there are some mutual funds that would say, we just don’t, we cannot have non-US tax resident as, um, a shareholder. So they would, um, ask you to sell.

Emily (29:57): Okay. So is it then up to the policy of the firm that you’re working with, whether they would allow you to buy and it’s just a widespread com common policy that you wouldn’t be able to buy mutual funds? Is, is that what I’m hearing?

Hui-chin (30:10): Correct, that’s on the custodian side. If you started your account as non-resident, most likely you’re not having access to mutual funds. You would just buy ETFs. If you started as a tax resident and you have mutual funds, when you change, um, your tax residency, they may ask you to sell all of your mutual funds, but technically it’s a mutual fund site, uh, decision, not the custodian decision.

Emily (30:37): All of this is, again, we’re getting down into the tiny little weeds there because in terms of investor strategy and behavior and so forth, mutual funds, index funds, ETFs, they can be very interchangeable in a sense. There, there are differences, but the differences are not super material for a basic investor, right? So it’s perfectly fine hearing this go ahead and buy an ETF that reflects, you know, the index fund that you wanna be in or the set of index funds. That’s all good, right?

Hui-chin (31:04): Correct. And Mutual fund has a benefit of, normally all you do is you send the money and you say, I want to put my $3,000 on Vanguard Total index mutual fund Admiral Shares, right? They would just take it, okay, you don’t even need to think about it in order to buy the same ETF class, you need to do it when the market is open and then, you know, between nine 30 and four eastern time, and then you go to the custodian and say, I wanna buy this number of shares. So it, it is a calculation <laugh>, it’s a change of mindset and I, I know a lot of people, you know, who start started investing previously when it’s more like a mutual fund, you know, uh, time before ETF’s prevalent, it’s used to like, I’m just throwing this money into mutual fund, I don’t have to do the actual purchase, right? It’s just saying, I’m giving you $3,000, I own the share, versus I need to actually go on the exchange. Meaning the market has to be open and to decide how many shares to buy. Like you would decide how many shares of Apple you want to buy, and then you own the shares. So it’s a, it is just a different, uh, type of investment process, but once you’ve done it, you’ll be more familiar with it.

Emily (32:24): Yeah, so slightly different buying process, but presumably we’re buying and holding <laugh>, so you just need to buy once per month or whatever your, you know, dollar cost averaging frequency is and then just hold it from that point. Uh, beautiful. Thank you so much. I’m glad I learned <laugh> something. Well, several things so far from this interview. Thank you.

Leaving the US After Investing as a Non-Resident

Okay. Let’s say we have a, uh, international grad student postdoc or other kind of worker in the US and they’ve been investing while they’re in the US and then they decide they’re gonna be moving to another country and they don’t know yet should they leave the money in the US in the US funds, should they, uh, be moving it at the time that they move. Is it appropriate to engage some kind of financial or tax professional with this decision perhaps about making the decision and perhaps about executing the decision?

Hui-chin (33:15): Correct. Um, I would say both. Um, it depends on what, um, at what point of decision you are, you are at, right? It’s usually a series of decision. I’ve worked with clients in like, uh, from, from the very beginning or they only engage me when, you know, we’ve decided we’re moving to this country because we get a job and we’re definitely going there at this date. So just tell me what do I need to do before I leave? Right? So that happens. And there’s also the, hey, I got three job offers in three different countries with three different packages. Which one should I choose? Right? Then that’s more at the beginning of the process. So depending on where you are or what you need, like a financial planner, cross border financial planner or people at least uh, familiar with international planning aspects should be able to do that kind of strategizing with you. Like if your decision is upfront or if your decision is just, okay, I have money, I have like, I have investments, I’m definitely going there at this time, what do I need to do? Gimme a checklist, that kind of thing. And we, we’ve also, you know, done that. So I would say definitely talk to someone before you move because there are are quite a few things that’s just easier, like most from a process perspective and also from sometimes tax savings, um, perspective because you, depending on whether you’re moving to a higher co, higher tax or lower tax jurisdiction, um, sometimes the jurisdiction has, you know, some exemption period upfront. So you want to, um, for example, we know that when, when you’re a true non-resident from US perspective, you can sell without paying taxes on your capital gain. So a lot of people plan to do that right when they leave, so they can cut off any US tax, but depending on where you move to, you might be paying the higher tax in the other jurisdiction anyway. So that’s one consideration. But if you’re moving to somewhere where they don’t tax foreign income, then that’s a perfect time to consolidate, uh, to, to sell. Then there’s also the, or there are countries where there’s exemption period or you know, the exemption period can be only six months or it can be four years, right? So it’s helpful to know in advance so you can, um, do the things, the right sequence and timing.

Emily (35:40): Okay. So let’s say we have someone who is planning that move, but it hasn’t happened yet and they engage someone like you to for help with this, are, are they gonna be able to know and do everything that they need by engaging someone, let’s say from the US side or do they also need to hire someone in the country that they’re moving to perhaps, or, or would you for example, be able to handle things on both ends

Hui-chin (36:07): Depending on the kind of structure that you’re working with the advisor. Some advisor, they specifically are cross country of those we call it um, country, country payer advisors. So they only deal with US Canada for example, or US UK. So they know everything they, you need to know <laugh> about those two countries. You can engage in one of them and then they can help you on both sides technically in terms of knowledge, right? So not all of them are registered to practice on both sides, like having their company on in two countries that requires, you know, heavier capital investments obviously. So some companies do they, they are just like two, like they have both US branch and UK branch, so they can like take you over. Um, but also there are just people who are deal who who are used to deal with the situation in a cross country, uh, sense. Uh, so they can do the planning part and they have people they can work with after you’re on the other side to um, do the implementation if needed. Um, but not necessarily have to redo your entire planning part. So it depends on, um, the type of professional you engage with, obviously there’s, you know, Canada and UK is the two most common places, you know, us uh, residents go for international students you can like that. It opens up the range quite bit. Um, especially I know a lot of, uh, people, um, come back to Asia where I am at right now. So for my company, what we do is, that’s why I started the CIGA network where there are people who p practice in different jurisdictions that can pull into, do a collaborative, um, type of consultation or um, project. So that’s kind of a short way of saying, you know, well maybe not too short <laugh>, you know, a a sort of a generalized way of saying like there are different options. So you can do find, try to find one person can do both or you can find one person who knows the scene that can collaborate with other people. But either way, um, make sure you’ve talked to someone who knows at least about the exit or the inbound because people who are only dealing with US tax residents, they don’t even know what you need to look out for when you leave. ’cause they’re not expecting to work with people who are ever, you know, renounce their US citizenship for example. So they don’t know what the exit entails. That’s the one big, um, drawback of working with someone who’s never dealt with exit or inbound.

Emily (39:01): For sure. And the CIGA network, which I believe you said you started, um, is that something that advisors use to find each other or is that something individuals could use to find an, an advisor or an advisor pair?

Hui-chin (39:14): So it’s sort of like how, it’s not like a technically a client facing thing, although we have our advisors listed. Um, it’s more for advisors to kind of collaborate with each other.

Emily (39:28): So then how does an individual go about finding someone to help them with this?

Hui-chin (39:34): Um, you can find our members on the website so that you can tell like what countries they have worked, um, listed has worked before, uh, the situation. So you don’t all have to come to me for me to do, make a referral. Like they, they are listed, um, but obviously it’s, if you’re thinking about a more complex situation, it takes a little bit digging. It won’t be able to say, oh, this, if you’re talking to talking, um, with me, then I can probably give you some solutions like who you can talk to. But it’s diff i, I understand it is difficult for someone who doesn’t know the playing field and try to find the right person to, to answer a question, especially when a lot of them do still work with high net worth individuals.

Emily (40:24): Hmm. Yes. Yeah, I was actually just going to ask, so I think the reason this question comes up is because graduate students especially, and also postdocs have been low income for so long that the idea of hiring a financial professional might be kind of daunting. Um, but I, I think what you said earlier emphasizes that it’s really necessary, um, because it’s, it’s, it’s an investment <laugh> like so that you don’t lose out on a bunch of, you know, tax advantages. You could have, you could have used had you known about them. So it sounds like a worthwhile cost.

Hui-chin (40:57): Correct. And also it has to do with how much, um, general income or asset you are thinking, thinking about planning for, right? So if you have only made one contribution to your account and you’re leaving, so it’s a very small amount in your account and you just want to know what to do with it, it might be slightly higher cost <laugh> than if that’s your only question and you need to find someone to answer that question, it might feel to you that, you know, the cost is more than the benefit that you’re gonna get from it. So listen to Emily <laugh> and whatever, you know, information you can get and make a decision if you don’t think the cost is worth it. I think for everything it is a cost benefit, but obviously for people who’ve lived here for 10 years, you accumulate it enough, you might even have a home, you might have to sell your home. All of those things have implication whether you’re a resident or non-resident before you do it. So definitely talk to, even if it’s not a investment advisor, if you feel like, oh, I know my investment, I just want tax help. Um, find a person who understands, um, the tax transition from resident to non-resident and do a consultation with them.

Managing the Fear of Making Mistakes on Your Taxes as a Non-Resident

Emily (42:18): Mm, very good. And going back to what we talked about at the top of the episode, hey, just start investing <laugh> right when you get here if you can. So you’ll have a lot of, uh, years of, of contributing behind you and hopefully it’s a significant sum that you’re then, um, getting some advice on. Okay, down to our last question, also submitted by a subscriber. This person says, I’m terrified of messing something up with my taxes. How do I make sure that I do everything correctly? I don’t wanna have mistakes on my record. How would you respond to this person?

Hui-chin (42:51): It’s a common fear, unfortunately for even for us tax residents or people who grew up here and need to file their own tax returns, it’s the US tax return is complex. It’s how, how it’s, you know, laid out for taxpayers. It just feels like it’s a form that people shouldn’t know how to fill out. That if you need to read through all the instructions, but I would say be like, I, I can understand being an immigrant myself, you feel like anything you messed up will become something that mess up your chance of saying or, you know, have other implications. So beyond talking, like beyond working with someone who knows what they’re doing, um, I don’t have like a really good, um, solution for that. But I would say, and I i, given the current political climate, I don’t wanna come out and say, oh, you don’t have to be afraid. You know, it’s a simple mistake and you know, it cannot be used to, you know, in other aspects of life, I cannot feel, I, I feel like I cannot say that ’cause I don’t know what the future will bring, but the, the main thing is make a good effort of understanding your tax return. Even if you, after you hire someone to do it, don’t just assume that, oh, I hire someone they know what they’re doing and just sign whatever giv- they give in front of you. If you, if it is the first time or the first few years you’re doing your tax return, um, it should be fairly simple. Like there should be like three, four lines with actual numbers, right? Like on your tax return, make sure you understand why they’re reporting. Make sure you, it matches whatever tax form you have gotten before. Whether it is W2, 1099, you know, I’ve seen people, you know, like professional tax preparers enter the wrong number because, just because, um, so I would say the only thing to combat the fear is actually knowing, um, not just thinking about it as, oh, I will never understand it. I’m just afraid it will get messed up and there’s no solution. It will, I think the, the, the more it get, the more events you are like into your career and things like that, the tax return will only become more complicated. So start from the very beginning, understand when it was really easy <laugh>, right? Like when you only have one W2, like, oh, this is what it does and oh, like at the first year you become a tax resident. Oh, I need to report all my foreign accounts. You know, I hope everybody already know at this point. If you’re reporting as a tax resident or the foreign accounts or the foreign income interest dividend from your bank account from when you were a child overseas starting the day, you become tax residents. You need to start reporting them. So make sure like that, that first year you really know what you’re reporting and if you feel like you don’t want to take on the burden of doing it alone, obviously then you hire someone. But kind of being a partner with that, someone to make sure everything is correct.

Emily (46:16): I I agree with you, no surprise there. I don’t think this person should be terrified. Um, like you said, just make that good faith effort to either prepare the return. Most people are using software, right? They’re using sprintax or something similar. Um, make the good faith effort to prepare it accurately to understand everything, to double check it. Like you said, if you’re working with someone else or software, double check it. Don’t assume they did everything perfectly because sometimes there are errors in communication and so forth. Um, not to be too self-promotional, but I do have a workshop called, um, how to complete your PhD trainee tax return and understand it too. Emphasis on that part. It’s like a big explainer, not just about getting through the process, but about, um, understanding what, what everything means and, and verifying and checking that that it’s, it’s done properly. It makes sense. Um, maybe you can corroborate this, but I know on, at least on the citizen resident side, our obligation is to faithfully report our income. And if you don’t take every single deduction you are eligible for or don’t take every single credit, they’re not too worried about that. What you really need to report is your income accurately. Is that the same on the non-resident side?

Hui-chin (47:27): Correct. So if you report all of your income and you don’t report deduction and you pay more tax, the government would be, you know, unhappy about you wanting to pay more tax, right? But from my experience, there are like simple checks, even though IRS system is still a bit arcane, there are checks that they do automatically. For example, the first year I did my own, um, when I had my first paycheck W2 paycheck and as a US resident tax resident, I didn’t take the correct personal exemption when there was still a personal exemption when before they were taken out. Um, I remember, uh, getting a kind of like IRS notice saying, oh, you didn’t take the exemption, we adjusted it, we’re giving you a refund. So that happens too, right? As long as you put all your income on there, um, and tax at whatever the ordinary tax rate, right? So don’t put your dividend, ordinary dividend into capital gains, right? Then that’s, you know, you’re trying to avoid tax. So as long as you’re putting all the income in the correct category, then it should yeah, be good.

Emily (48:39): I too have made mistakes on my tax returns over the years, some of which the IRS caught right away, some of which they didn’t. But like you said there, there are very simple checks that are automatically done. And so I’ve done the same as you. I’ve messed something up both in my favor and the IRS’s favor. It’s happened both ways and they’ve caught it both ways. <laugh>. So, you know, do your best. <laugh> is all we’re saying. Please don’t panic about this. 

Hui-chin (49:01): Yeah, and the, I think a lot, a lot of the, the thing is people may not a hundred percent understand what is income. I encounter people, a lot of people asking can I, you know, my, my mom’s giving me this gift $5,000. Do I have to report it on a tax return? Right? So that’s a, that, that is a gift that is not income. So when in doubt, I’m not saying just put the 5,000 gift as income so you can pay more taxes. But if you feel like, okay, it’s, I don’t know whether this is income or not, that’s when you need to talk to a tax professional.

Best Financial Advice for Another Early-Career PhD

Emily (49:42): Yeah. That’s really great. Hui-chin, thank you so much for another fantastic interview. I wanna leave with the question that I ask all of my guests, which is, what is your best financial advice for an early career PhD? A grad student, a postdoc, someone who’s recently finished their PhD training. Um, can you give us any insight there?

Hui-chin (50:00): I think we’ll, um, come back to the first point we made, um, in this podcast is just, um, decision fatigue is real. And I think in the academia especially, people are used to doing research. So even when the personal finance side, we, we tend to want to do it, you know, understand everything and we’re just talking about you need to understand your tax return, right? So we all have the research mindset of like really understand what we’re doing doing, but at some point you need to, you know, make a decision and not just a decision. You need to actually carry out your decision. So if you’ve been thinking about investing, coming back to the same point, if you think about investing for a year and you’ve met your, you know, emergency fund, you’ve met your cash cushion, you’ve met all your other goals, you know, you need to invest for the long term now and you are just getting bogged down on, I don’t know which account to open <laugh>, I don’t know which investment to buy. You know, just use a normal taxable brokerage account that you can open and then look up the most common target date fund, see like Vanguard ones and see how they’re breaking down their stock and you know, bond allocation based on your risk tolerance and just buy it,

Emily (51:15): Buy a couple of ETFs and you’re good to go. You’re on your way. Um, Hui-chin, thank you again for coming on the podcast. It’s been a pleasure to have you back.

Hui-chin (51:25): You are welcome. Thank you for having me.

Outro

Emily (51:37): Listeners, thank you for joining me for this episode! I have a gift for you! You know that final question I ask of all my guests regarding their best financial advice? My team has collected short summaries of all the answers ever given on the podcast into a document that is updated with each new episode release. You can gain access to it by registering for my mailing list at PFforPhDs.com/advice/. Would you like to access transcripts or videos of each episode? I link the show notes for each episode from PFforPhDs.com/podcast/. See you in the next episode, and remember: You don’t have to have a PhD to succeed with personal finance… but it helps! Nothing you hear on this podcast should be taken as financial, tax, or legal advice for any individual. The music is “Stages of Awakening” by Podington Bear from the Free Music Archive and is shared under CC by NC. Podcast editing by me and show notes creation by Dr. Jill Hoffman.

Financial Questions from an International Graduate Student

January 27, 2025 by Emily

In this episode, Emily interviews Gauri Patel, a first-year grad student in biomedical engineering at the University of Texas at Austin. Gauri is on an F-1 visa, but she has lived in the US for over 10 years. The financial questions Gauri has encountered are different from those typically asked by both US citizens and new international students. Gauri and Emily discuss bank accounts, retirement accounts, tax reporting, and the cost of immigrating to the US.

Links mentioned in the Episode

  • Host a PF for PhDs Tax Seminar at Your Institution
  • PF for PhDs Tax Center for PhDs-in-Training
  • PF for PhDs S4E17: Can and Should an International Student, Scholar, or Worker Invest in the US? 
  • PF for PhDs Subscribe to Mailing List
  • PF for PhDs Podcast Hub

Teaser

Gauri (00:00): I’m the type of person to gather all the information before doing things, but that can hinder progress if you just keep adding more bits of information rather than like acting on what you already know. I spent a little too long deciding like, oh, which, which company to go with. But yes, I I was able to open up the Roth IRA.

Introduction

Emily (00:28): Welcome to the Personal Finance for PhDs Podcast: A Higher Education in Personal Finance. This podcast is for PhDs and PhDs-to-be who want to explore the hidden curriculum of finances to learn the best practices for money management, career advancement, and advocacy for yourself and others. I’m your host, Dr. Emily Roberts, a financial educator specializing in early-career PhDs and founder of Personal Finance for PhDs.

Emily (00:59): This is Season 20, Episode 2, and today my guest is Gauri Patel, a first-year grad student in biomedical engineering at the University of Texas at Austin. Gauri is on an F-1 visa, but she has lived in the US for over 10 years. The financial questions Gauri has encountered are different from those typically asked by both US citizens and new international students. Gauri and I discuss bank accounts, retirement accounts, tax reporting, and the cost of immigrating to the US.

Emily (01:30): The tax year 2024 version of my tax return preparation workshop, How to Complete Your PhD Trainee Tax Return (and Understand It, Too!), is now available! This pre-recorded educational workshop explains how to identify, calculate, and report your higher education-related income and expenses on your federal tax return. Whether you are a graduate student, postdoc, or postbac, domestic or international, there is a version of this workshop designed just for you. While I do sell these workshops to individuals, I prefer to license them to universities so that the graduate students, postdocs, and postbacs can access them for free. Would you please reach out to your graduate school, graduate student government, postdoc office, international house, fellowship coordinator, etc. to request that they sponsor this workshop for you and your peers? You can find more information about licensing these workshops at P F f o r P h D s dot com slash tax dash workshops. Please pass that page on to the potential sponsor. Thank you so, so much for doing so! You can find the show notes for this episode at PFforPhDs.com/s20e2/. Without further ado, here’s my interview with Gauri Patel.

Will You Please Introduce Yourself Further?

Emily (03:06): I am delighted to have joining me on the podcast today, Gauri Patel, a first year PhD student in biomedical engineering at UT Austin, and today Gauri and I are going to discuss being an international graduate student, but one who has been in the US for a significant amount of time and how the financial questions that you have at that stage are different than either you know, domestic graduate students or people who are international students and brand new to the US. So I’m really excited to learn from Gauri about this. So Gauri, will you please introduce yourself a little bit further for the audience.

Gauri (03:37): Thank you so much Dr. Roberts. So I, as you mentioned, I am a first year graduate student at the University of Texas at Austin and I’m studying biomedical engineering, uh, specifically in biomedical imaging. So my start in this field was during my master’s thesis where I studied a particular image analysis technique to understand how a tumor microenvironment could influence outcomes to therapy. And so I want to continue studying this and so here I am, uh, doing more research at, uh, in a PhD program.

Emily (04:14): Excellent. Well, let’s kind of rewind the clock and take us back to, uh, maybe when you first, uh, entered the US and tell us about how that happened.

Gauri (04:23): I first moved to the US pretty much exactly 11 years ago. Uh, and it was because my dad had found a job in Michigan and so at at that age you don’t really have much of a say in where you’re going. And so my family moved to the states and I’ve been in Michigan ever since.

Visa Status: H-1B, H-4, F-1

Emily (04:46): So tell me how that works visa wise. ’cause I know, I’m gonna guess your father was on an H-1B, but I don’t know how the family aspect of that works.

Gauri (04:55): He eventually got to an H-1B, so we moved from Canada to the US and so Canada, there’s a different visa category that my dad could also work under. So he first started on a TN visa and I was on whatever dependent version of the TN there is. I’m not sure what the name of that is exactly, it was quite a while ago, but then eventually he did get moved over onto an H-1B, after which I was on an H-4 visa, which is a dependent of the H-1B. And I basically stayed on that, um, from middle school through high school and then my first year of my undergrad.

Emily (05:34): Okay. And then from your second year of undergrad, did you start on F1 visa at that time?

Gauri (05:40): I switched to an F1 during my second year of my undergrad and that was because I wanted an opportunity to do internships or paid research on campus. Uh, so the H-4 visa, you require some type of worth work auth- authorization and that there’s a different timeline about when you’d be able to work. It has to go through a different approval process and it’s kind of like up in the air when that, uh, work authorization would come through. And so if I was on an F1 visa, it would be rather immediate. I would do a year of school and during that time I would be permitted to work in a research capacity on campus. And also it’s pretty immediate you can get authorization for CPT or OPT and so that’s why I switched to the F1.

Emily (06:34): That certainly seems like a reasonable reason to, to, you know, make that switch. I’m wondering were there any downsides, like anything that you were foregoing or giving up by making that switch?

Gauri (06:44): Yeah, for sure. So since my family was on an H-1 was under the H-1B visa category, there’s also the option to apply, have your employer sponsor for a green card. And so that’s like the main perk of the H-1B visa. It can eventually lead to a green card. However children, they age out at 21 and so I was like really getting close to that point of aging out. And so the question remained, do we still hang on to this H4 dependent visa and not be able to work in the hopes that before I turned 21 I would, that green card would, you know, go through or do I switch immediately and you know, cut my losses. And so, uh, we just decided that the green card was probably not gonna happen before I turned 21. And so I might as well switch to the h uh, sorry, excuse me. F1 visa at this time.

Emily (07:53): Well I wanna kind of pick up with the green card process maybe a little bit later in our conversation, but let’s kind of go back with um, your experience, you know, doing research and everything through your undergrad. Um, it totally makes sense to me that you would want to have those potentially paid research experiences where you already thinking at that time that you wanted to pursue, uh, your field or science generally or like did this basically the switch to allow you these experiences. Were you thinking ahead to graduate school, I guess is what I’m asking?

Gauri (08:24): Yeah, for sure. So I first started off, um, my first year I was pretty set on pre-med. I wanted to go to medical school, um, and pre-med the curriculum makes you jump through like a lot of hoops, like oh, do shadowing and do research hours and all that. And so that’s how I got into research in the first place. But I ended up liking it so much that I abandoned the pre-med track and I’m like, I think this is the research is just what I’m interested in general. And so the F1 visa definitely helped. It also would’ve been helpful for pre-med purposes as well to get like clinical hours maybe, you know, work in some, some sort of, um, healthcare setting. So working somewhere was like whether I wanted to go to graduate school in research, in a research capacity or to medical school working somewhere had to have happened.

Family and Personal Finances

Emily (09:21): Yeah, that makes sense. Um, since we’re talking about work then and paid work and so forth, can you tell me a little bit about, doesn’t necessarily have to be your family’s finances, but like what was going on for you financially during that time and especially if there were any tie-ins then with like your visa status or your choices around that.

Gauri (09:39): Finances were never really a struggle for my family, which I’m very grateful for. Um, because I, as an international student, I didn’t get any financial aid or qualified for federal student loans, so everything did have to come out of pocket. So more about having paid work, it was more about, um, finding a sense of autonomy and not having to rely on, you know, my family being my safety net all the time. And so that’s why I was interested in the paid work.

Emily (10:14): And you told me during our, um, pre-interview chat that you started listening to financial podcasts even as an undergrad, including this podcast. And so what led you in that direction of like being interested in finances even at that stage?

Gauri (10:28): Oh yeah, it was pretty much, so I worked in this, um, lab as a volunteer for two semesters and then that summer after I asked them like, Hey, can I stay for the summer and work here full time and also get paid perhaps? And they were like, yeah, sure we can make that happen. Um, in hindsight I didn’t realize how like, oh wow, that actually happened <laugh>. Um, now that I know more about the research space like that, that was kind of incredible that that happened. But anyway, so I, I’m like, oh, I’m about to get money for the first time. Um, and unlike some of my peers that I went to high school with, they all worked like, you know, jobs, um, at like the local ice cream shop or they were, you know, hosts at, you know, some type of diner or they tutored on the side. I couldn’t do that on the H-4 visa. And so up until this point I’d just been volunteering. This was quite literally like my first paycheck. And so I was like, what do I do with this? What could I possibly do with this? And I’m just the type of person to go poking and prodding for answers. And so I went to finance podcasts.

Emily (11:49): Yeah, that’s great to hear. Um, I think when I had a similar like transition, you know, coming out of undergrad and getting like my first stipend paychecks, like after that I was asking the same questions like, oh, uh, never had this control over money before. Like, what exactly do I do with this? I went to books because podcasting was barely a thing back then, but that’s awesome that we have so many different like avenues you can go to now. Um, okay. So anything else you’d like to share with us? Maybe about the transition from, you know, finishing up undergrad and your master’s into graduate school in terms of your finances and then we can kind of dig into the, um, specific questions or concerns that like someone in your position has?

Gauri (12:29): I think the only big difference between my undergrad and master’s and then grad school now is that in undergrad and Master’s, the amount I was making was like, it, it couldn’t sustain all of me. Um, my family was helping out with tuition entirely and then now it’s a, a different ball game. Like I, I can more or less like take care of myself on this stipend. And so that autonomy I was like really searching for. Um, I I feel like it’s like finally coming to fruition like, oh, it’s happened.

Emily (13:06): So when you kind of approached me about doing this episode, you were saying, okay, yes, I’m an international student but I don’t have the same concerns of a brand new to the US international student and I also have different concerns going on than someone who is already a citizen or resident. So just like point by point like let’s talk through like what you’ve encountered and sort of what you’d like to share with other, other listeners who might be in a similar situation.

Choosing a Bank as an International Student in the US

Gauri (13:30): Yeah, for sure. So the first thing, um, you do is when when you get some type of money in your hands, it’s like I have to put this somewhere. And so it’s the first question is like, oh, what bank do I choose? And so I was consuming this financial content and it was like, oh, you should start saving up for an emergency fund and moreover you should put it in a high yield savings account, but for international students there are only a certain number of banks that will offer their services to you. And so the first bank account I had was, um, a Chase bank account. Um, I don’t know if it’s okay to name names.

Emily (14:07): Oh yeah, go ahead.

Gauri (14:07): For banks. Okay. So it was a Chase bank account and it had some like stipulations on the minimum balance that should be in there. It didn’t offer any interest at all. And so in terms of all the different banks you could choose from, you’re limited to a very set few. Um, so I had that bank account first, but then finally after I got the work authorization to work on campus in this uh, lab and then after I got the social security number associated with it, it was after all that that I could open this bank account. And so anytime you hear like, oh, do this, do X, y, and z, like a pretty actionable step, that seems easy enough. Um, I always seem to find like, oh I need to have this before I can do this thing.

Emily (15:05): Yeah, it is, it is really hard at like as a podcaster, someone who does one to many communications, it’s really hard <laugh> to keep all audiences in mind and speak to like all audiences. So you’re absolutely right. Like if you’re listening to a US based, you know, personal finance podcast or like reading a book or something else, like you definitely have to put another filter on that and say like, okay, <laugh>, is this actually going to be possible for me? And the answer is like, just like you said, yeah, there are banks that will work with you, it’s just not necessarily every bank and not everyone’s gonna make it easy and some people need the SSN and some don’t and so forth. So like you just have to be, there’s just another selection criteria on that. Absolutely. Have you, so since like having that Chase bank at first, have you subsequently opened or been able to open any other types of like higher yield savings or something like that?

Gauri (15:51): Yeah, for sure. I primarily use uh, my SoFi bank account now and it was pretty easy to like get the account, but it’s only after you’ve got some type of job lined up and you’re getting paid for it and you’ve got like all the things that come with the job first, like you need to have that SSN which um, is not like a oh I’ll just like apply for it type of thing. They’re finding the job is not like the easiest thing in the world. So you could hear the fi- finance advice but know that there are steps before steps you must take before you can, you know, enact those. Um, yeah, in general it’s like a thing I have to Google, like, oh open up a Roth IRA, can I open up a Roth IRA is something I have to Google.

Commercial

Emily (16:42): Emily here for a brief interlude! Tax season is in full swing, and the best place to go for information tailored to you as a grad student, postdoc, or postbac, is PFforPhDs.com/tax/. From that page I have linked to all of my free tax resources, many of which I have updated for this tax year. On that page you will find podcast episodes, videos, and articles on all kinds of tax topics relevant to PhDs and PhDs-to-be. There are also opportunities to join the Personal Finance for PhDs mailing list to receive PDF summaries and spreadsheets that you can work with. Again, you can find all of these free resources linked from PFforPhDs.com/tax/. Now back to the interview.

Opening a Roth IRA as an International Student in the US

Emily (17:34): Yeah, let’s talk about that question. Um, so you heard about Roth IRAs, I’m sure through all the content that you were consuming and uh, tell me what year that was when you like first learned about a Roth IRA,

Gauri (17:46): I actually learned about a Roth IRA back in high school and so my high school offered a finance class and so they tried to teach us about, um, saving for retirement and 401Ks and Roth IRAs and whatnot, but I don’t think it like fully sunk into our minds yet about how significant those things were. So I heard about a Roth IRA before, um, I didn’t fully grasp its like importance until I started listening to like finance content a few years later.

Emily (18:21): Yeah. So when did you like start googling that question? When did you feel like, okay, as an imminent step I would like to open this kind of account and I really need to figure out if I’m able to? When did that happen?

Gauri (18:31): I think that was two years ago. I was like, I’ve listened to all this advice. Um, so I’m the type of person to gather all the information before doing things, but that can hinder progress if you just keep adding more bits of information rather than like acting on what you already know. So I knew that I needed the Roth IRA and I was like, you know what, fine, let’s, let’s just start googling. Um, can I, can I open this and who’s willing to offer this to me?

Emily (19:01): Yeah. And what did you find?

Gauri (19:04): I think it was from your podcast, like some interview a while back, um, and there was like a snippet. I remember watching like as an international student you can open a Roth IRA and I’m like, oh check. Fabulous. Um, now I spent a little too long deciding like, oh, which, which uh, investment bank or like, which, which company to go with. But yes, I I was able to open up the Roth IRA <laugh>.

Emily (19:31): Yeah, that I think you’re referring to the interview I did with Hui-chin Chen who’s a CFP. And I think that we recorded that back in like maybe 2018 or 2019. And even by then I had been getting regularly questions in my like, live seminars from international students, can I open a Roth ira? Should I open one? You know, is it allowed? Is it a good idea? And so I was really, really glad to get an expert on the podcast who could help us with all those questions. But the, the gen, I mean people who are interested should listen to that full episode. But yeah, the, the general, uh, takeaway was like, yep, <laugh>, if you want to invest like while you’re an international student or postdoc in the US go ahead and do it now with a Roth IRA specifically, you still need to fulfill the, um, taxable compensation requirement to be able to make those contributions. Did you have to like, I don’t know if you were receiving W2, you know, employee type income at that time, maybe it wasn’t so much a question for you or is that, is that taxable compensation question something you also had to investigate?

Gauri (20:30): I don’t think I investigated it that much because at the time I really wasn’t earning all that to put anything into the Roth IRA, so it was just open for a while and it, my income definitely wasn’t a W2, it was actually a 1099, but I think from another series of, not another series, but like another episode or couple of episodes of yours, um, I think you went over the old guidance before 2020 and then after 2020 and it was like, yes, 1099 income can be uh, put into a Roth IRA. And so I was like, oh great. So I I could have done it all along. Um, not that there was anything left <laugh>.

Emily (21:16): Yeah, that definitely did change to have fellowship income not reported on W2 eligible to be contributed starting in um, 2020. But you still had that added wrinkle of like as an international student, as a non-resident in the us um, we’ve settled like the compensation term in, in taxable compensation, but you also had to know that your income was taxable in the US and I don’t know, would you like to share like what is your technical country of residence? It seems so silly to say that ’cause you’ve been here for so long, but like what is your country of residence?

Gauri (21:47): I think right now for tax purposes, it is not the US I think it switches to the US in a year. I think it’s like five years. Mm-hmm <affirmative>. Yeah, that I can say I’m on my tax. I’m like, not from here, but after five years of saying that you are from here now for as far as taxes are concerned.

Emily (22:09): Yes. So I don’t know the Canadian US tax treaty intimately, but I’m pretty confident that your income was then taxable in the US at least to some extent. So you did have that eligibility mm-hmm <affirmative>. Yep. So yeah, that’s great. But like you said, like, you know, US citizens, residents and so forth, they have this one bar of like questions they have to ask about the Roth IRA and then there’s that further bar that, you know, international non-residents have to ask. So I’m really glad that we kind of reviewed that to like, you know, point people back to that other resource and like get that all out there because like it is such an amazing tool. Um, and it’s really a shame to miss out on it if you’re ready to contribute to one just because you might have some outstanding questions that, you know, they can take a little bit of time to resolve those. So hopefully we resolved a few for the listeners. Um, is there anything else that you’d like to add on that? Like Roth IRA question?

Gauri (23:03): I think that’s about all. Just, uh, don’t let the tail wag the dog as, as they say. So I had the account open but I wasn’t like too worried about what could go in there. Um, it all worked out in the end for me, but I think if I got too caught up in the weeds, I I don’t think the account would’ve ever been opened or I would’ve ever put anything in there <laugh>.

Emily (23:25): Yeah, I totally agree. And it’s, and it’s this area of investing where people that in my observation seem to have the most like analysis paralysis. Um, and I, maybe you’ve heard me say this on podcast before, I’ve probably told the story, but like I made like a huge mistake when I first opened my Roth IRA, which is that I didn’t actually invest the money that I was putting in and yet it’s really good that I started it and started contributing even though I made like a huge mistake with it. Like, I mean we have a decades, decades long investing journey ahead of us, so like it’s better to just get started even imperfectly than to just like wait and wait and wait and wait and not do anything. It’s totally okay to make relatively minor mistakes. You can overcome them along, along the journey. What was your third uh, point that you wanted to bring up?

Opening a 403B as an International Student in the US

Gauri (24:08): So I figured out the bank account, I figured out the Roth IRA and then now my question is, hmm, I still have some more left to save. Can I open a 403B? Which the answer is yes, but then all of this additional money that I have, it’s coming from a fellowship which according to my university, it’ll be reported on a 1042s form, which I’ve never encountered before. Um, from my searches on Google, I don’t see that much guidance for graduate students with this form. It’s more about US citizens that have moved abroad that, that received this form and I’m like, I’m, I’m not that <laugh>. I’m very much the opposite. I’m a non-citizen within the US so the jury is still out. I’ve emailed like the tax folk at my university regarding like, Hey, would you happen to know if this can be put in a 403B or a Roth IRA or like any tax advantaged account and they’re like, sorry, we can’t give tax advice.

Post-Interview 403B Contribution Follow-Up

Emily (25:19): Hi y’all, this is Emily breaking in during the editing process. Gauri and I talked for a bit here about her 403(b) and her tax situation, but I wasn’t quite asking the right questions, so we ended up exchanging several emails after the interview to sort it out. Here’s what we figured out: Gauri has two types of income. She’s an employee throughout the year and also receives supplemental fellowship income. Her employee income exceeds $10,000 per year and therefore is not subject to the US-Canada tax treaty, so it is fully taxable and reported on a Form W-2. As a nonresident, her fellowship income is reported on a Form 1042-S with income code 16, and it is also fully taxable. Gauri’s question was whether or not she could contribute her Form 1042-S income to her 403(b), and the answer to that is no because it is fellowship income and only employee income can be contributed to a 403(b). But she does have employee income, and that’s why her university allowed her to open the account and she could contribute to it from her employee, i.e., W-2, income if she chose to. The reason she particularly was asking if she could contribute the fellowship i.e., Form 1042-S, income to her 403(b) is because of the automatic 14% income tax withholding rate, which is rather high compared to her effective tax rate. So our conclusion is that she can contribute to the 403(b), but not from the particular pot of money that she wanted to, and even though she has that annoyingly high income tax withholding rate, it’s all going to come out in the wash at tax time, likely in the form of a tax refund. OK now back to the interview!

Building a Financially Stable Life in the US as an International Student

Emily (26:52): Was there any other, another point that you’d like to bring up in this sort of question about having been in the US for like a very long time yet still being on this F1 status?

Gauri (27:03): The main goal of consuming all the finance content is, so answering the question of like how do I build a financially stable or good life for myself years in the future if I’m in the US but because of my visa I also have to, it’s like vacillating between yes, think long term, but also what if you’re not here long term? What then? Um, so of course that opens a can of worms, like what if this, what if that? But I just have to work with, let’s just assume I’m gonna be here for some indefinite amount of time and then if the day that I have to go back to Canada comes, um, I will deal with extricating myself from all of this money that’s invested in these US-based, um, accounts at that point. Um, I think it would, it would be like a hindrance if I constantly worried about it right now.

Emily (28:09): Yeah. And I I’m really not sure what steps you would that would be practical to take, um, to, you know, think about this possible future where you would be living in Canada, um, I don’t know, open a Canadian bank account. Like I’m not even sure what would be like a reasonable thing to do, um, like you said for an outcome that you’re hoping is not going to come about and has a probably a low chance of actually coming about. I think you’re exactly right. Just to say like, I’m gonna build what I can here and if the day comes when I have to make a change, I’ll make a change then, but you don’t need to anticipate that. Yeah, and I think that was the answer too from that podcast episode with, um, with Hui-chin Chen. She was just saying like, yeah, if you end up leaving the US later whether because you wanted to or because you had to or whatever the reason, you can sort of cross that bridge when you come to it. Like don’t let that be a reason for you to not build wealth and build your financial life in the US. So I think you’re taking exactly the right path.

Gauri (29:08): That’s fabulous to hear.

Current Financial Goals

Emily (29:09): <laugh> Do you have any current financial goals?

Gauri (29:14): Current financial goals? So the immediate thing would be to restore my emergency fund. So my emergency savings, I had to draw out of that for moving to Austin from Michigan. And so the moving costs and then furnishing, you know, the apartment, the first few months of, you know, rent before the, uh, the stipend payments came in. I used my savings to tide me over during that time. And so right now I, I need to work on restoring that amount. Um, so that’s my immediate goal. And then once that’s done, I think that should take up to a year, depending on how aggressive I’d like to be at. After that point, I will have to decide where to redirect those extra funds that were going into my, um, emergency savings, like should I put that into a taxable brokerage account or finally answer that 403B question. And so send that, send those funds over there. Where should those go would be the next question.

Emily (30:25): And are you also thinking about a potential green card in the near future and like what are the, because I know there’s sometimes hefty financial costs associated with that transition.

Gauri (30:34): Oh yeah, for sure. So the past, I think two or three years, uh, my Visa has cost about $500 a year in different work authorization fees or different petition fees. So I already have that in the back of my mind. Like, oh, every time I need to do something with my visa, it’ll be a couple hundred dollars. But for a green card application for someone that is seeking a PhD, there is a employment based visa that I myself could petition for if I demonstrate that I’ve done outstanding research in my field and I’m a person worthy of staying in the us. Um, and so just for that, just for two forms relating to that, I think it’s um, called, it’s called Immigration for Alien Worker or Petition for an Alien Worker, something along those lines. The fee for that is around $700 and then the adjustment of status. So to adjust my status from an F1 to this employment based visa, that would be around $1,400. And so just for those two forms, if I were to go about it without the help of any sort of immigration lawyers, whatnot, that’s already over two grand. So I definitely need to have some sort of bucket larger than a couple hundred dollars ready to go for when that day comes about. And also I have to decide like, do I even wanna pursue that path or would I prefer to just go the more routine route, which is employment based, um, visa. So like pursuing an H-1B track, so up in the air.

Emily (32:31): How will you make that decision? Or I guess I’m also asking like you mentioned earlier about, you know, the number of years you’d been in the US and having to make a decision about F1 versus staying on the previous status. Um, is there an amount of time that you’re looking at where you’ll, that you’ve been in the US where you or been on the F1 visa where you’ll need to make this decision? Or is it really kind of up to you? You can do it at any point?

Gauri (32:53): The sooner it happens, the sooner like a weight would be lifted off my shoulders about like this always, you know, you have to keep in the back of your mind that like you’re not necessarily here forever, whether you choose to be or not to be here forever. So it would be like a mental weight, you know, relieved. Um, the F1, since I’m in a STEM field, I could have my OPT go for I think up to three years with the extension. And so within those like three years, I’d have to make some type of decision about whether my employer can sponsor for an H-1B visa or I’m going to go about it on my own. So it’s within the next eight years I have to come up with an, an exact plan about what would be the fastest, um, most efficient way to go about this process. Mm-hmm <affirmative>

Emily (33:53): And if you decide you wanna do it on your own and you have those fees that you’re looking at, plus maybe you, you might wanna pay a lawyer, um, to help you as well, are the finances going to hold you back or do you think you’ll be able to save up the requisite amount of money by the time you want to go about this process?

Gauri (34:10): I think I am well informed enough about how much this is going to cost me, and so I’d be able to plan for that regardless. It would still be a stretch, but it’s not like this is happening six months from now or you know, this is happening in just in a very short amount of time. Like I have the time to prepare for this type of scenario.

Traveling Back to Your Home Country as an International Student

Emily (34:36): I don’t know if this applies for you at all, but something I’ve seen happen with other international students, um, is that they need to go back to their home country every so often to deal with their visas. Has that ever come up for you and, and if not, is it ’cause you’ve been in the US under all these different statuses for so long? Or is it because of the relationship between US and Canada or like how does that work?

Gauri (34:57): It’s a US and Canada thing, so it’s a special caveat in this regard as well. So most students need to go through a Visa interview and actually receive approval to study in the US however, I’m Canadian and so I simply have to be accepted into a US university and show that I have some method of paying for my stay here and that’s all the evidence I have to give to study. I don’t have to continue to go back to Canada to renew my visa or even have any documentation for the exact visa.

Emily (35:41): I see. I’m just throwing that out. There’s another potential cost that I’ve seen international students bear uniquely these like high fees of international travel every, you know, few years to deal with that like particular issue. Um, yeah, I mean the more that obviously I, I was not an international student, so like, but the more I learned about the financial aspects of having this status in the US like it just, there’s just kind of more that burdens that kind of get thrown on the pile. Like, okay, no access to student loans, can’t side hustle, have to pay fees for visa related items, maybe for travel as well. Like just, it it emphasizes um, very deeply for me the importance of paying a living wage and not just a living wage more than a living wage to graduate students, especially international students because there’s just no, there’s no ways to pivot. Um, if you are financially on your own, if you’re financially independent from your family, then you have to make it work on the stipend like you’ve been talking about and you have all these additional, um, fees that can, that can pile up as well that domestic students don’t have to, don’t have to worry about. So yeah. Yeah. I’m really glad that, you know, you brought this up and that we got to have this conversation. Um, is there anything else that you wanna add about yeah, um, being an international student, having been in the US for so long? Or about your current financial goals or anything else?

OPT Application Tip for International Students in the US

Gauri (36:59): Pro tip for international students, um, when it comes time to send in your OPT application, do it the day you’re allowed to submit that application. So first you need all those signatures or you know, green lights from your advisor about like, yep, you’re ready to graduate and whatnot. That should be done before the 90 days. You have like a 90 day window before your last day of classes to apply for OPT. Have those ready to go. And on that like very first day of the 90 days apply for OPT then ’cause I did it right the first year after I grad, graduated from my undergrad and the second year I waited a few weeks and my OPT was delayed, I think over a month.

Emily (37:55): So it’s just for processing time, like you’re just saying like be the first one, like be first in line mm-hmm <affirmative>. Because if you delay then these applications are like piling up behind it and just pushes like the timeout. Is that right?

Gauri (38:06): Yeah, exactly. So when I was first in line, my OPT, like the EAD card arrived within three weeks. And so I had it well in advance of any start date and the second year round I was like, oh, it arrived in three weeks. I’ve got time.

Emily (38:26): You were complacent. Yeah, <laugh>.

Gauri (38:27): I was, I didn’t think I’d be so off base. Um, but yeah, don’t, don’t, don’t do what I did. <laugh>.

Best Financial Advice for Another Early-Career PhD

Emily (38:37): <laugh> Yeah, don’t do it <laugh>. Um, okay. Well thank you so much for that tip. And I’d like to end by asking you the question that I ask all of my guests, which is, what is your best financial advice for another early career PhD? And it can be something that we’ve touched on in the interview already, or it could be something completely new.

Gauri (38:53): I’ve learned that you need two savings buckets at least. So there’s the emergency when truly it’s an emergency and you have no sources of income whatsoever, and then a second bucket for yearly, like one off expenses, like, oh, there’s that vacation you’ve really been wanting to take or you have to travel for whatever reason. For me it’s like, you know, oh, here’s a couple hundred dollars for some visa related thing or I’m working in a STEM field. But I think all grad students in this day and age need a laptop or some type of technology of some sorts, and that’s pretty costly as well. And so, you know, your phone falls apart or your laptop needs to be replaced or you gotta go to a conference or whatnot. Um, there has to be like a separate bucket <laugh>, aside from the emergency savings. Um, and that, that having that separate bucket really relieves like a lot of stress, at least for me.

Emily (39:55): Yeah, this is like a major component of my teaching. I would say that’s different from like you mentioned listening to like financial feminists, for example, Tori Dunlap’s podcast, Her First 100K. Um, what I see in like the more general personal finance space is people talking to other people who have higher incomes high, you know, moderate to high incomes, which is just not the case for graduate students. And so things like having to pay for a plane ticket, well, you know, if your income’s high enough and you’re doing a great job with your personal finances, you know, keeping your rent low and all that stuff, like that’s not gonna be an issue for you, but it’s an issue for almost all graduate students to pay for those types of expenses. So like that is definitely an area that I have of much greater emphasis than other like personal finance teachers do because I totally agree with you. It takes so much stress off to have planned and prepared for those expenses in advance so that you’re not having to, I don’t know, like go to the food bank and like not, you know, put gas in your car and like all the stuff that you would have to do on the short term basis to sacrifice, to come up with money that you really needed if you, if you didn’t have that savings. So I love that tip. Thank you so much for sharing that. Um, and this was, it was wonderful to talk to you and thank you so much for teaching me and you know, asking the questions and you know, sharing the conclusions that you’ve come to along the way. And I wish you all the best in getting your, you know, status in the US secured in the way that you would like it in the near future.

Gauri (41:15): Thank you so much. It was great talking to you

Outtro

Emily (41:27): Listeners, thank you for joining me for this episode! I have a gift for you! You know that final question I ask of all my guests regarding their best financial advice? My team has collected short summaries of all the answers ever given on the podcast into a document that is updated with each new episode release. You can gain access to it by registering for my mailing list at PFforPhDs.com/advice/. Would you like to access transcripts or videos of each episode? I link the show notes for each episode from PFforPhDs.com/podcast/. See you in the next episode, and remember: You don’t have to have a PhD to succeed with personal finance… but it helps! Nothing you hear on this podcast should be taken as financial, tax, or legal advice for any individual. The music is “Stages of Awakening” by Podington Bear from the Free Music Archive and is shared under CC by NC. Podcast editing by me and show notes creation by Dr. Jill Hoffman.

How This International Graduate Student Grew His Career and Social Wealth Alongside His Net Worth

June 17, 2024 by Jill Hoffman

In this episode, Emily interviews Dr. Cyrus Liu, a postdoctoral fellow in computer science at Grinnell College. Cyrus came to the US from China as a graduate student without any knowledge of how the US financial system works. Over the course of his PhD, Cyrus found ways to minimize his expenses and increase his income so that he could meet his goal of investing $500 per month into a Roth IRA and a taxable brokerage account. He also invested in his physical and mental health and grew his career and social wealth in a frugal manner. Cyrus ends the interview with incredible insights into why he was motivated to work on his finances during graduate school and in what ways academics are truly wealthy.

Links mentioned in the Episode

  • Dr. Cyrus Liu’s Twitter
  • Dr. Cyrus Liu’s Website
  • Host a PF for PhDs Seminar at Your Institution
  • Emily’s E-mail Address
  • PF for PhDs Subscribe to Mailing List
  • PF for PhDs Podcast Hub
How This International Graduate Student Grew His Career and Social Wealth Alongside His Net Worth

Teaser

Cyrus (00:00): Don’t underestimate yourself because you are a PhD student and you definitely have the knowledge base and then sharing those knowledge with the community, and you are passing to the knowledge. This is the wealth we possess, right? Normally people think we are poor, but actually, and a wider definition of the wealth here we have this part to share with someone else.

Introduction

Emily (00:33): Welcome to the Personal Finance for PhDs Podcast: A Higher Education in Personal Finance. This podcast is for PhDs and PhDs-to-be who want to explore the hidden curriculum of finances to learn the best practices for money management, career advancement, and advocacy for yourself and others. I’m your host, Dr. Emily Roberts, a financial educator specializing in early-career PhDs and founder of Personal Finance for PhDs.

Emily (01:01): This is Season 18, Episode 2, and today my guest is Dr. Cyrus Liu, a postdoctoral fellow in computer science at Grinnell College. Cyrus came to the US from China as a graduate student without any knowledge of how the US financial system works. Over the course of his PhD, Cyrus found ways to minimize his expenses and increase his income so that he could meet his goal of investing $500 per month into a Roth IRA and a taxable brokerage account. He also invested in his physical and mental health and grew his career and social wealth in a frugal manner. Cyrus ends the interview with incredible insights into why he was motivated to work on his finances during graduate school and in what ways academics are truly wealthy.

Emily (01:45): I’m offering a new slate of workshops for my university clients this fall, and over the summer I’m practicing delivering these workshops for free to a limited number of graduate students and postdocs on the Personal Finance for PhDs mailing list. Last month, we did “Seven Steps to Start Investing as a Graduate Student or Postdoc,” and later in the summer we’ll do “Your Financial Orientation to Graduate School” and “Tax Season Preparation Starts Now for Graduate Students” and possibly more. If you’re not currently on my mailing list but want to receive notice about the upcoming pilot sessions once they are scheduled, please join now! The best way to get on the mailing list as a podcast listener is to sign up through PFforPhDs.com/advice/; you’ll receive a document that summarizes all of my interviewees’ responses regarding their best financial advice. You can find the show notes for this episode at PFforPhDs.com/s18e2/. Without further ado, here’s my interview with Dr. Cyrus Liu.

Will You Please Introduce Yourself Further?

Emily (02:56): I am delighted to have joining me on the podcast today, Dr. Cyrus Liu. He’s currently a postdoctoral fellow in computer science at Grinnell College, and we are going to be talking about his fascinating financial journey, um, as a graduate student and now a postdoc in the US as an international student. And so, Cyrus, I’m so happy that you’ve decided to join me on the podcast today, and will you please introduce yourself a little bit further?

Cyrus (03:19): Yes. Hi, Emily. Thank you for having me here. So I graduated in December, 2022 from computer science degree. Um, after that I landed this, uh, postdoc, um, fellow in computer science. And the current position, I’m do- mostly doing research in the area of programming languages and security.

Money Mindset After Arriving in the US

Emily (03:45): Excellent. So let’s go kind of all the way back to when you first arrived in the US. I assume that was at the start of graduate school, but you can correct me if that’s wrong. Um, tell me like about what your money mindset was at that point and how, if at all, how familiar you were with the US financial system.

Cyrus (04:01): Also, this is my first time before I come to US. It’s actually, I’ve never been to us before my PhD and I’m from China, so I grew up in a poor family, in fact, there. So with that in mind that I’m kind of sort of inherently frugal. But what’s interesting is back then, like I never feel poor in terms of any financials. In general, I have no idea about in credit card scores, uh, credit cards and investing or retirement. And, and that’s later on. I discovered after I entered the US that I do have, uh, a saving and spending mindfully and because how my parents raised me. Right.

Grad School Stipend vs. Local Cost of Living

Emily (04:50): I see. And so when you arrived for, um, graduate school here, can you tell me about, um, what your stipend was and how that struck you, maybe versus like the local cost of living?

Cyrus (05:02): I was living in Hoboken for, um, two years and a half, and also Stevens Institute with the university. I finished my PhD is located in this really beautiful city and it, it is, the local cost is like 60% higher than the national average. I would just say and put in the number that means like I think if you got two bedroom apartments that you might need to spend, um, at least 1700 for one bedroom, that means you need a a roommate. And back then the stipends, uh, I would say it’s like a 28 thousandish and it’s roughly, I remember we got paid like a biweekly, it’s like 2000 a hundred per month after tax.

Increasing Income During Grad School

Emily (05:55): Okay. Well, I really wanna dig into this, uh, with that, you know, relatively expensive cost of living and the relatively low stipend. Um, and the listeners don’t know yet, but this is a financial success story that we’re about to talk about <laugh>. So we’re gonna see how, you know, I wanted to see that starting point and now let’s see how you got to the end point that you got to. Um, so let’s kind of break this down, um, systematically. So during the course of your time in graduate school, how did you, what did you do to increase your income?

Cyrus (06:24): Yeah, so there are a couple things. Um, like I said that before I entering, uh, US, I have, I really have no idea what’s the, uh, um, investment, investment investing or credit cards, and that’s a totally different systems, but I do have a mindset that I need to save, right? And it is how I grew up. Um, but it’s not too much. So most of the case, um, I start to reaching out, um, all the resources I can, I, I think I start with reading the book first and then also I love reading. And then the first book I get to know is basically, uh, it is called I Will Teach Rich by the Ramit. And, and he, he actually kind of introduced me to the whole US financial system from credit card, from the, uh, uh, Roth IRA and then how you would you, uh, increase, uh, your finance and manage your, your spending habits and to how would you invest if you have extra money, even though if you don’t have extra money, just put maybe one, uh, 100 or $50 you can squeeze out. Just experience how things work. Uh, at the beginning it was a little bit overwhelming, but I, I enjoyed read his book. I I think this is also helps me to manage my life, uh, here in a completely, uh, foreign nation. Right?

Emily (08:04): Yeah, that’s a wonderful first book to get started with. I will teach you to be rich by Ramit Sethi. Um, yeah, great, great introduction. He’s very firm about how to tell if someone, someone, you know, an institution is trying to take advantage of you. Like he’s really helping you, like recognize that and push back against it. So I can definitely see how that would be useful when you’re entering a new system, um, entirely. So awesome recommendation, you started there, you read that book,

Cyrus (08:28): And then I start to act <laugh>.

Emily (08:31): Mm-Hmm. <affirmative>.

Cyrus (08:31): And then I open the credit card and then I, I, I take the, the same strategy that I recommended by the, by the book. It, it’s not promotion for the book, but it’s more like, I think around nothing to think of that it is really like you try to minimize all the possible interest, right? Rates I would have and then, or a lot of promotions provided by the credit card and then try to take advantage of that because now we think about that credit cards more like the more you expense and then the more you can potentially save and also they encourage you to spend. So, but I personally very mindful with my expense, but the same times I think they do, credit cards do offer a lot of discounts in terms of purchasing. So that’s the first step.

Emily (09:24): So are you saying that you pursued credit card rewards, like points and cash back and stuff after? Of course, you initially need to establish credit and get started there.

Cyrus (09:32): Yes, exactly.

Emily (09:32): But is that where this led eventually?

Cyrus (09:34): The, the signing bonus and also the cashback reward, that’s also something new to me that I never did, uh, touch before. And then also we do have, uh, I think the first one is the discovery. I think most of international students would get to discovery first because we don’t have any, uh, credit score history here. And so they also have these online stores that will give you 10% or 5% discount. And then when I go out to buy clothes in, or I was living in New York City area, so there’s a lot of department store that can use with this discount opportunities.

Emily (10:16): Mm-Hmm, <affirmative>. Okay. So both increasing income through credit card, um, bonuses and cash back and so forth. Also finding a way to be even more frugal in saving certain percent, percentages on the purchases that you do make.

Cyrus (10:28): After that, um, uh, I started to opening a investment account that was also a little bit struggling because I, first of all, as an international student, I do not know if I was allowed to do that. So I, that’s kind of for research myself. But in the end, after like, um, as long as we are considering as a tax payer resident, and then, so you should have the same opportunity to open all those investment account. And then I, I remembered I started with, uh, uh, 500 ish, um, over the month for the first month. So I just put, I think I, I, I was not expecting to gain anything. I just, uh, put 500 to get to understanding, uh, how the investments work and buying individual stocks. And I think I bought, that was 2018. I bought a Tesla <laugh> because I really like, uh, Elon Musk.

Cyrus (11:30): Um, but that was another story. It was really funny. And so that’s one part. And then, uh, after that, uh, I get to know the, Roth IRA and then the retirement account. Um, it’s also be, uh, I, I get to understand how the tax work here and then the tax deferred account. And I think that’s whether in long term if, uh, I am staying here or not. I, for me, it’s like, I think it’s, uh, uh, beneficial to open this account as soon as possible because I do pay a lot of taxes. I mean, it’s, uh, in terms of graduate students. Uh, so I think, uh, that’s one way you should take benefit of that. And then I did that, but um, although I didn’t have much money to put on that, and then, uh, in the end, I would, my, my goal was, uh, try to save like, uh, 500 and put into other way to the Roth IRA or the personal, um, uh, investment brokerage and yeah. But this all comes with the risk. So with the mind that you, the money you put in, in the investment account, like it’s possible to lose all of them. Right. But I was fine with that.

Contributing to a Retirement Account as an International Student

Emily (12:47): Couple things there, uh, because I get so many questions from international students and postdocs, um, yeah, maybe they know, they, you know, in theory could contribute money to a Roth ira for example. They, they understand the eligibility, but they’re more questioning like, is this a good idea? And it sounds like you came down on Yep. As soon as possible, whether I end up in the US long term or not, this is a good idea. Can you tell us a little bit more about that thought process and how you made that decision?

Cyrus (13:15): Uh, I think that this decision is very personal for me. Um, because that, that’s all really depends, um, where you going to stay, where are you going to retire in, in the future, right? Um, for me, I didn’t really think that too long. Um, I can in, in the long run, I, I prefer this. I might not stay in United States. Uh, but, uh, I, but uh, for me, you, you got to understand what, what, what’s your, uh, long-term goal. Uh, if you are not going to come back to us at all, or even this is the case, but it is still helpful that because, uh, you are kind of tax deferred assuming you grow your money over there, right? Um, and it just take some penalties if you break the, the rules that you’re taking out the money before your retirement age. But if you can stand with that, it is nothing comparing that if you in your future that you might want to settle down in US or you go want you coming back in us in a later life, it, it, it, it can benefit you a lot, but without risk balance you got assessment, what’s your goal, it is. And then for me, I would like to take that even though maybe a few years I have to, uh, uh, leave or, or for, or I have to withdraw the money, but I need to take a 20% or I don’t know exactly number the penalty for that.

Emily (14:53): Mm-Hmm, <affirmative>, yeah, if I’m remembering correctly, it’s, I think it’s only 10% and it’s only on the gains. And if we’re talking about the Roth IRA, right, because you can withdraw the contribution. So it’s, as you said, you know, there’s a, um, a, a risk there in a sense. Okay, well maybe I will need to remove this money early for some reason. Well, this is the penalty. Am I willing to accept that? Do you know, I’m, and the penalty again, is only on the growth. So it’s only if, yeah, if there things have actually gone well with that investment account, um, in the intervening years. So thank you for giving us a little bit more insight there.

Investing as a Graduate Student

Emily (15:24): And then I also wanted to ask about the taxable brokerage account. Um, you mentioned you bought Tesla. Yeah. Were you, um, cashing out, like making trades and actually taking income from this money over the years? Or is it more been like just sitting there for like, for the long term and you’re not taking income from it?

Cyrus (15:40): So for me, it’s more like a, um, a personal habit. Like, um, uh, I do, I don’t, I didn’t, I did not have much money to invest, and I think I was just bought two or three, few five shares of Tesla, but in 2018, and, but after that, Tesla was like a, like a high rocket, and I do, I did sold a couple share, but those number I really like comparing it, it’s not much. And so no, it, it, it’s more like, uh, a habit. That one is a habit. The another one is I, I did not really have much extra money to invest in this account.

Emily (16:24): Yeah. And I, you said the number of $500 earlier, was that your, was it your goal to invest $500 per month or is that over a different period of time?

Cyrus (16:32): Uh, yeah, I was, uh, uh, a month.

Minimizing Expenses as a Graduate Student

Emily (16:34): Let’s talk about keeping a lid on expenses or decreasing expenses then, because we’ve already heard that the cost of living is very challenging on your grad student stipend. So you already mentioned having multiple roommates. I think you said you were sharing a bedroom, right? So like maybe four people in a two bedroom apartment, is that right?

Cyrus (16:49): Um, um, no, that, that was like, uh, we do have five bedrooms in, uh, a big house, but we, we have our own bedroom. But the things like, uh, in that case we did cutting down a lot of expenses. We share everything.

Emily (17:05): Mm-Hmm, <affirmative>. Okay. So kind of the, the frugal tip there is like larger residents, more roommates, more people to split everything among, right?

Cyrus (17:15): Yeah. Not many PhD students actually live in Hoboken. I was lucky to find this place. Uh, but the same times, like I personally, I don’t think roommates are bad. And because I, I get a chance to know different people and, uh, in my case, uh, there’s a, a little, uh, uh, that, but I can stand with because we do sharing, uh, things, uh, and then sometimes can getting busy, but most of the case are fine with that. So we, I have four other roommates, but they are working in a different area. So basically we would have a different schedule. So in this case, uh, it’s doable and especially, uh, given the resources I have, I don’t commute that much. And then I enjoy in the on campus resource, I like to do it to gym. So it’s like a 10 minutes away from my, uh, my, my lab and then also the, to the gym. So the, I spend most of the time in the lab. And then after that, I go to the gym really just, uh, over the night, come back. And then sometimes we have the good parties, you have roommates, and you can have some little party on the weekends and watch a movie together. That was pretty nice.

Emily (18:30): Mm-Hmm. <affirmative>. Yeah. I actually really like the setup of a single family home that’s shared among multiple different, multiple, you know, people at their own bedrooms. I feel like that’s a pretty, in most areas of the country, that’s a pretty economical way to live if that type of housing is available to you as opposed to like the apartments or, you know, the townhouses or whatever. Yeah. Um, yeah. So what other ways did you find to decrease or minimize your expenses?

Cyrus (18:55): So at the same time, um, we, we do have, uh, uh, so I try to, uh, take a break from my research sometimes. And another way is like, um, travel. When, when it comes to travel, um, I prefer to go with my friends or in a group, and in, in generally I do meal prep. I do, uh, regularly do, uh, exercise and eat healthy. Um, the meal prep myself, it’s also cost less. So I think it is a, it is beneficial in two ways. Um, also in long run, I do value work workout regularly and keep your mental health checked. This would’ve, uh, stopped me going to hospital that often. Like I remember when the seasoning transitions during the transition seasonings and you catch flu isn’t sometimes it’s not just going to the hospital suffering. It’s more like you take at least one week to recover and then you get behind with my research and then that kind of padding up. It’s a lot of stress. So I, I, I wouldn’t, so I, I realized that like, and I, the good way is like take, do more exercise and then to, to keep your immune system robust, <laugh> against that. Um, another thing is like, it, it’s very funny, like when we pay in taxes, right? We, we considering as a, a tax resident. And, uh, but at the same time, I really appreciate my student id. I was living in New York City area and then using student id, you got a lot of free, uh, tickets and also discount tickets to the art gallery and museums and, and gardens. So although I, I, I was, uh, frugal, but I didn’t miss out any fun things over there. I, I still go to museums, gardens, and sometimes, uh, uh, uh, meetups and, and, and local, uh, parties. I, I was, was really fun. And it didn’t really cost you much.

Emily (21:10): Mm-Hmm. <affirmative>. So your entertainment was also satisfactory to you, but you found a way to do it in a frugal manner.

Cyrus (21:16): Yeah. Yeah.

Emily (21:18): Anything else on your list of, of expenses that you managed to minimize?

Cyrus (21:22): I don’t drive, right? So it is also, I was living in the city. It’s really, uh, so those expenses not really, uh, a thing for me. I personally, I do not really purchase too much clothing for me. I’m very minimal. Like, uh, as long I have, uh, uh, a clean fit clothing, that’s enough for me. And for shoes, like, uh, I don’t like to switch too much, and also maybe I have two or three, two, uh, three pair of shoes that one for winter and one or two I can switch during the summer or something like that. So, uh, wearing the things like to the, to the most, um, I think this is preco- probably also because the way that I, how I raised that I am fine with that. And I think that’s kind of, uh, one part, uh, that can cut off the cost in my case.

Emily (22:26): Yeah, definitely.

Commercial

Emily (22:29): Emily here for a brief interlude. Would you like to learn directly from me on a personal finance topic, such as taxes, goal-setting, investing, frugality, increasing income, or student loans, each tailored specifically for graduate students and postdocs? I offer seminars and workshops on these topics and more in a variety of formats, and I’m now booking for the 2024-2025 academic year. If you would like to bring my content to your institution, would you please recommend me as a speaker or facilitator to your university, graduate school, graduate student association, or postdoc office? My seminars are usually slated as professional development or personal wellness. Orientations or very close to the start of the academic year would be a perfect time for tax education or general personal finance content. Ask the potential host to go to PFforPhDs.com/financial-education/ or simply email me at [email protected] to start the process. I really appreciate these recommendations, which are the best way for me to start a conversation with a potential host. The paid work I do with universities and institutions enables me to keep producing this podcast and all my other free resources. Thank you in advance if you decide to issue a recommendation! Now back to our interview.

Increasing Social Wealth

Emily (23:56): Is there anything else that you would like to add about overall how you increased your net worth during graduate school? We talked about investing in the Roth, IRA and also in the taxable brokerage account. Anything else in that category?

Cyrus (24:09): Uh, I think one thing that is more intangible, the the wealth and the finance that, uh, the, it is kind of the, the social wealth, the, which I, I, I, I was not really proud of that, um, and try to, uh, take advantage of the local resources, right? And then I was lucky to live in New York City area, and then that’s, and also Hoboken locally and is very nice community, but I think no matter where you live, the local community more often, have more resources that you can imagine and you might not be aware, just try to reach out. And for example, I was attending almost like every weekend I go out and then join the meetup and conference, and most of, of the time they provide you these free meals, lunch or dinner, and then it, it, it’s a, it’s a nice way you can social and also you don’t need to cook your meal yourself. So these things are very subtle and the same things happening on campus that, um, in, in your department, uh, no matter which major you are, um, try to join the, uh, the, if you have any habit, right, join the club and then your peers, and those are most likely have this, uh, social events that can help you, uh, to reduce sometimes if you don’t want to cook or for breakfast meal. And then those are all great ways to, to do

Emily (25:59): Classic grad student strategy. Um, but I like that your focus here and kind of your spin on it is both like, yeah, you can get some free meals from time to time, but also you get, you get your entertainment and your social interaction. Um, and so it fills your, your calendar and helps you again with your work life balance and your wellness overall. And I like that you mentioned not just doing this on campus, but in the community too. And the thing is that if people are putting on events and they’re giving food and all those things, they really want you there. They really want people to come. So like you’re also, you know, you’re contributing to their community as well.

Cyrus (26:32): Yeah. Yeah. I, I think, um, one of the things not just about the meals, and another thing is about the, the, the social wealth. I would say it’s all, uh, it’s also the concept I learned from the books that, uh, it’s more how would you connect to the people? And then that was, uh, kind of potentially, and the connection may or may not be lead you to in the future when you are in the job market, you could have used these connections, but, uh, I wouldn’t say put this in more like a transactional way, but you should try genuinely more just enjoying the life. But at the same times, you might not realize by doing that, you kind of gain the social wealth.

Freedom as the Ultimate Goal

Emily (27:20): You were obviously putting in a lot of effort with your finances, right? All the things we went through, ways that you keep your lifestyle to a minimum ways you figured out how to increase your income, you know, self-education, and then that turned into more investing and so forth. Um, why, why weren’t you just satisfied with getting by day to day and saving all of that for after you finish graduate school?

Cyrus (27:45): I, I think that’s awesome. One role of the reason is due to my personality, I guess. Um, I think the, the ultimate goal is the freedom to achieve the freedom and to be confident. W- with the any decisions I’m going to make. So I would like to, we are talking about freedom and confidence. It’s more like in the sense that I was, I can make decisions based on my own personal demand, not really subject to any resources surrounding me, right? Like, like I said, like before I entering us, I never felt I’m, I’m poor <laugh> because I don’t really have, have much need and I was spending most of my life and time with school. And then after you explore the world, I have this dream, and then now the time’s moving on, and then I start to realize that I really, it’s not what you think, like ideas are great, but you have these obstacles that related to this, uh, money topic, and then you actually making decisions based on what the resources are available for you. So the final goal, then I would start to thinking like, yeah, this comes so natural, you save more, but saving is just one of those strategies. So, and then that’s why I end up start to find out the other opportunities and yeah. So I, I would say the ultimate goal is to be freedom.

Emily (29:30): Do you feel like, you know, you are, I don’t know, five, six or so years into this now, um, do you feel like you’ve attained that to a degree? Obviously you’re not, maybe, you know, complete financial independence is still, still some time away, but, um, I guess I’m, I’m wondering about, yeah, like does it feel like you are a percentage ways, like towards that at this point?

Cyrus (29:53): Uh, in terms of the net worth, obvious, No, that is a far away, but I think in terms of mindset and the knowledge, and then I am preparing myself and then I’m being mindful with my personal life. It’s called personal finance, right? And then you, I i, I was now I’m able to figuring out in the big picture and then what’s the come in flow, what’s the outflow? And I’m, I’m very mindful of that. And then in the end, it, it’s really also, it’s another pro- a question for myself. Do I really want to be retired early or not, or, so the, the, the, the freedom for me is in a more, in a wider definition that it’s more about the resource management and the organize myself, and it, it, it, it includes material and, but also my mind. I think this kind of, uh, uh, knowledge and skills over these past five to six years that I develop, it’s very helpful. Um, in the long term. I, I think if I stick to that and then keep this growth mindset and in the future, the net worth is just a number, whether you choose retire 40 at 40 or 50 a a it is, can is this is the freedom that I, I’m talking about. I can decide, doesn’t matter if, if I have to work or not, right?

Emily (31:33): Absolutely. I love that. Thank you much for pointing that out. I similarly, I think I came to this similar kinds of reflections after I had finished graduate school, after I’d been on that path for a few years, like recognizing how, um, having not only some money in terms of the net worth, but also those mindsets and the habits and the skills and everything that it took to start down that path really afforded me more, uh, choices even at that relatively early stage, um, in life. So thank you so much for sharing that. Exactly.

Personal Finance Resources for Grad Students

Emily (32:07): Um, do you have any additional resources that you’d like to recommend, either to specifically the international graduate student population or maybe graduate students and postdocs more widely? I mean, your first recommendation, I will teach you to be rich by Ramit Sethi was an excellent one. Were there any other books or I don’t know, podcasts or YouTube channels or anything else that you, uh, that you felt was really helpful along the way?

Cyrus (32:27): Yeah, I think, um, so I, I think books are really, uh, good to start with. And in terms of which books you should read, uh, um, uh, I would recommend if you use Reddit, and that there’s a personal finance Reddit channel, uh, you can join that one. There’s a lot of resources about personal finance and what books you’re getting started. And if you like a podcast, and I think this one is very nice since, uh, at the beginning I, I couldn’t find much resources. That’s also how I get to know this podcast. And I was very excited that actually someone thanks to you <laugh>, um, so you, you, you can get, keep get informed to make a good decision, right? Um, and this, uh, this, this is, uh, complete within your reach if you want to do that. And then I would suggest you do that.

Cyrus (33:28): And in terms of, uh, um, tangible resources, be mindful for the, uh, reach out to your university resources. Like, um, especially I was using this, uh, psycho, uh, psychological services therapy and be open-minded. And for those like, um, we are PhD students, we are graduate students, and then it’s can definitely be very lonely. And then even you are in a relationship, so, and those resources are really just find somewhere to talk. And this I think is the part that can easily be ignored by the students, especially international students thinking I’m really, because I’m alien here and then I feel constrained. But actually, uh, uh, in us, you can definitely, especially in your university, you have a lot of resources, uh, uh, to help you out. And then when you graduated, and actually the careers, uh, service is also very helpful, but you need to know that and you need to reach out for yourself.

Cyrus (34:41): And in terms of local community, no matter where you live, try to find a city. And what I did is like get engaged with the locals and I like running and then I go to 5K races. So those are, you can, um, reach out without any cost, right? And also you can, uh, remain your, uh, healthy mind, mind, uh, mental health. So yeah, I, I think overall just be open-minded. We are living in this, uh, information liberal age is really, you don’t feel missing out, and then you have the access to other information you can figure out yourself. And what’s, one thing I, I learned is, um, what makes you, uh, anxious is mostly the things that you actually didn’t do right? And then if you act on it, it, it, it doesn’t matter how challenging the, the things itself, and then you will be fine. But sitting there <laugh> doing nothing, that that’s the big problem.

Emily (35:54): Mm-Hmm, <affirmative>, I’ve absolutely seen that in, I mean, it, it applies widely, but certainly in the case of finances, um, it’s better to just face it and engage. Yeah. And try something. Um, yeah, instead of, as you said, kind of avoiding or spending a long time in analysis paralysis, not sure which direction you should go, just try something. And you’ve tried a lot of things and I love that we got through all of that in this interview.

Best Financial Advice for Another Early-Career PhD

Emily (36:16): Let’s wrap up with our last question that I ask all of my guests. What is your best financial advice for another early career PhD? And it could be something that we’ve touched on already in the interview, or it could be something completely new.

Cyrus (36:28): Yeah, so, um, I think everyone has a very unique experience, uh, in terms of giving. Otherwise, I would just say I wish what I have done or done more to in my PhD. Um, so one thing I think, like I mentioned couple times, um, value social wealth. And that means that, uh, try to, uh, go out and in, in your spare time, sometimes you might think you don’t have time, especially as a PhD student. And, but I tried, I have the similar mindset, uh, at a certain amount of time. But the thing is like you stick in the lab and the home, you might, you become less productive and then it might take more time than comparing that you just go out and do some activities and then come back with, uh, more energy and fresh mind. So this is the thing that I, I think I did, uh, less, uh, whether it, if you are in a relationship or not, it is the similar thing sometimes, like go out with friends and, and to the meetups and or more importantly, um, it’s also more, uh, career wise or professionally. Like we, we as a graduate student, we don’t really have money to give out, but the same, uh, idea applies. The more you give the, the, the, the, the better. So, but as a scholar, that means that volunteer to giving talks in the meetups, workshops, seminars in your neighboring institutions, I think, uh, don’t underestimate yourself because you are a PhD student and you definitely have the knowledge base and then sharing those knowledge with the community, and you are passing to the knowledge. This is the wealth we possess, right? Normally people think we are poor, but actually, um, a wider definition of the wealth here, we have this part to share with someone else. And then the same times you will get rewarding back, right? Because you, you go out and people get your idea, you get a chance to talk about your research, and the same times you build this genuine connections with the community, and in the future, this connections might help you to navigate your, your future career path.

Cyrus (38:58): So this is the thing that I, I think I missed out a lot also because we was in the covid times, and that’s really dark age. Um, on the other side, as I, I would like to share is I think what I did to contribute the success of my PhD is one thing is really be open-minded. I considering myself a very open-minded person, I, I, at the same time, very minimal for me. And then, but I do exercise more and then, and try new things at the beginning. All those investment accounts really scares me because every time I open the account, that’s a whole for legal documents I have to read. And I, as an international, I’m concerned that I fly-, am I breaking the law or something like that. But if, if you are looking into it and it’s really not that scary, right?

Cyrus (39:56): So I think, I think I, I stand with myself and then I, I try all those things. And then the, the, the, the idea is you need to realize that if you don’t do that, and it’s actually you are paying that, you are not doing that, right? Because the inflations and the interest rates, rates all the things that you have to, you kind of, everyone should open their investment account and, and, and do the investment and manage that to beat the, at least the inflation. So another thing I think I value, uh, more is the people itself, whether it be your significant others or friends. I do valuable value those things. Um, uh, that means that if, if there’s a chance I can spend more time with my friends, like, uh, we go out for a nice, a night, a fancy dinner. Sometimes we go out for, to New York, Manhattan to try different restaurants. I, I, I, I really not at that moment, I value more with the time with my friends. And even though the meal is expensive sometimes, I remember one time we spent almost a hundred each of us for one meal <laugh> was like, but I think that was really, uh, um, uh, valuable for me.

Emily (41:15): Yeah, so insightful. Thank you so much for sharing that with us. Thank you for this entire interview Cyrus, for volunteering to come on the podcast. Um, it’s been absolute pleasure to have you.

Cyrus (41:24): Thank you. And thank you for having me and it is great to sharing the stories with everyone. Thank you so much.

Outtro

Emily (41:41): Listeners, thank you for joining me for this episode! I have a gift for you! You know that final question I ask of all my guests regarding their best financial advice? My team has collected short summaries of all the answers ever given on the podcast into a document that is updated with each new episode release. You can gain access to it by registering for my mailing list at PFforPhDs.com/advice/. Would you like to access transcripts or videos of each episode? I link the show notes for each episode from PFforPhDs.com/podcast/. See you in the next episode, and remember: You don’t have to have a PhD to succeed with personal finance… but it helps! Nothing you hear on this podcast should be taken as financial, tax, or legal advice for any individual. The music is “Stages of Awakening” by Podington Bear from the Free Music Archive and is shared under CC by NC. Podcast editing by Dr. Lourdes Bobbio and show notes creation by Dr. Jill Hoffman.

How to Financially Transition to Grad School as an Underprivileged Student

May 17, 2021 by Meryem Ok

In this episode, Emily interviews Rutendo Chabikwa, a first-year PhD student from Zimbabwe at the University of Oxford and the host of the podcast So, You Got A Scholarship? The topic is the financial aspects of transitioning to graduate school. Emily and Rutendo list start-up costs, explore the financial “hidden curriculum” of grad school, and discuss financial habits to establish and how to do so. This episode has a particular focus on underprivileged and/or international students.

Links Mentioned in This Episode

  • @rutendochabikwa (Rutendo’s Twitter)
  • PF for PhDs: Fellowship Orientation (Webinar on May 23rd, 2021)
  • Bad with Money: The Imperfect Art of Getting Your Financial Sh*t Together  (Book by Gaby Dunn)
  • Bad with Money (Podcast) 
  • Emily’s E-mail (for Book Giveaway Contest)
  • PF for PhDs: Podcast Hub (Instructions for Book Giveaway)
  • Episode 3.01 of So, You Got a Scholarship? (Rutendo’s Podcast, feat. Emily) 
  • Council Tax in the UK
  • PF for PhDs: Tax Center
  • Notion (Organizational Workspace)
  • Mint (U.S. Budgeting App)
  • Money Dashboard (UK Budgeting App)
  • Moneybox App (Round up your expenses to save)
  • TopCashback (UK App)
  • Rakuten (US savings app)
  • PF for PhDs Episode: Can I Make Extra Money as a Funded Grad Student on an F-1 Visa? (Money Story with Frank Alvillar) 
  • PF for PhDs: Subscribe to Mailing List

Teaser

00:00 Rutendo: If there’s something that you think somebody might cover, even if you don’t think somebody might go cover it, just ask. That’s definitely something I think underprivileged students can fall behind on simply because some of us have to cover a lot of gaps, not coming from families with people that have done PhDs or some of us who will be first-generation graduates to even begin with.

Book Giveaway Contest

02:19 Emily: Now, onto the book giveaway contest. In May 2021, I’m giving away one copy of Bad with Money: The Imperfect Art of Getting Your Financial Sh*t Together by Gaby Dunn, which is the Personal Finance for PhDs Community book club selection for July 2021. Everyone who enters the contest during May will have a chance to win a copy of this book. I’ve listened to a few episodes of the Bad with Money podcast, and I’m looking forward to reading and discussing this book because Gaby has such a different perspective and approach to personal finance than I do. If you’d like to enter the giveaway contest, please rate and review this podcast on Apple Podcasts, take a screenshot of your review, and email it to me at [email protected]. I’ll choose a winner at the end of May from all the entries. You can find full instructions pfforphds.com/podcast. Without further ado, here’s my interview with Rutendo Chabikwa.

Will You Please Introduce Yourself Further?

03:24 Emily: I’m delighted to have joining me on the podcast today Rutendo Chabikwa. She is a first-year PhD student at the University of Oxford. She’s from Zimbabwe. So we are going to discuss in this episode the transition into graduate school, some of the financial stuff that goes on in that time, especially for underprivileged students. This is going to be really great episode. Rutendo and I have actually spoken before because I was on her podcast. She has a podcast called, So, You Got a Scholarship? and my episode of season three, episode one. So we’re doing a swap here. I’m so glad, Rutendo, to have you on my podcast. Welcome. Will you please tell the listeners a little bit more about yourself?

03:58 Rutendo: Thank you so much, Emily. Glad to be here. Glad we could do this. My name is Rutendo. Yes, I am a first-year PhD student, or DPhil as it is called, at the University of Oxford. I’m from Zimbabwe. But basically I have been an international student for the past about 10 years, starting with my two years of high school. Did that in Canada. My undergrad was at upstate New York at St. Lawrence University. So I have a bit of U.S. experience in there with also a couple of study abroads. And then my master’s was in London at the LSE and then now I’m here for my PhD. So it’s a bit, quite of a long trajectory over there, and I am studying information communication and the social sciences. So basically things to do with the internet, digital media, and political participation.

Costs for Anyone Starting Grad School

04:42 Emily: Wow. Okay. Yeah. Fascinating. Thank you so much. So we’re going to jump right in with talking about the financial startup costs for entering graduate students. And obviously you’ve done this before at minimum for your master’s and now again for your PhD. So you’re quite familiar. Let’s talk about this in three layers. One would be for just anyone who’s starting graduate school that didn’t require a move. Two, someone who did need to move to get to graduate school. And then three, someone who had to move internationally to start graduate school. So we’ll layer those on. So what are some costs in that first layer of just anyone who’s starting graduate school?

05:16 Rutendo: Yeah, absolutely. So anybody that is starting, I mean, there’s the obvious in terms of just generally your life in grad school, household items. I know that sounds very minimal, but it can be actually something that builds up and that we underestimate as well as, you know, your working equipment, your laptop. Right now, we’re in a pandemic, so everybody’s sort of working from home, but even outside of pandemic, generally grad students need to have really well stationed, you know, workspaces for your work. Books, and not just books that are not just textbooks as well, because you might have costs to do with like your research topics. Sometimes you might prepare having your own book to highlight or write in, things like that. And obviously we can talk about ways of minimizing those costs later, but definitely anybody going there, your stationary, books. Definitely.

06:07 Emily: Yeah. Well, I’ll add, you know, in the U.S., and you can tell me if you’ve experienced this at LSE and Oxford, but a lot of graduate programs in the U.S. seem to require some fees to be paid upfront. Like even before you ever get your first paycheck as a graduate student, you owe hundreds, maybe a thousand dollars of some kind of fee, which is just, I wish they set the system up differently. But it is that way in many places.

06:33 Rutendo: Absolutely. This is actually, I mean, even before actually getting accepted, right? So these fees, even for applications alone, so there’s that, and then getting accepted, the deposit fees. Sometimes you might be lucky enough to get a waiver. Sometimes not so lucky. They could, you’re right, go from a few hundred dollars to a large sum of your tuition as well. And then I think there are also, depending on your institution, fees, such as for student association fees as well. Those are definitely something to consider and look up how your institution works on that.

07:09 Emily: Yeah, those are the kinds of fees that I was referring to, like a recreation fee or an activity fee, or even sometimes the health insurance premium here, you know, it needs to be paid upfront. That can happen. So that could add up to a sum. The thing about that is that you can know in advance, right? So as soon as you figure out which school you’re going to go to in April, or whenever you do that, you can start asking what is the amount of money that I need to give you before I get my first paycheck? Now, I don’t want to say that everywhere is that way, because it’s not. But it’s definitely something worth figuring out as early as you can.

07:44 Rutendo: Absolutely. And also to find out from the different sort of stages, right. There’s fees, your department might have some type of fee or, I mean, if you come into something, I guess like the Oxford system, you might also try to talk to your college, see if they have any kind of fees or which is a different sort of department or different area. So to make sure that you’re checking boxes with different offices and different levels of the institution to make sure that you have that. Always definitely ask for that.

Startup Costs Associated with a Move for Grad School

08:09 Emily: Hmm. Yes. Okay. So let’s add a move on top of that. If you are moving, what kinds of, you know, startup costs are associated with that?

08:17 Rutendo: Oh, absolutely. Transport for sure. However way you’re getting there. Moving costs, shipping costs. In order to save money, you might have to use money. So in order to save money on buying all new items, for example, let’s say for your house, your desk, it might be cheaper to move with them, but that’s also a cost. So there’s, you know, you need to juggle that and, you know, do your tallies and do your trackings and write that out and see what’s cheaper and what’s easier for you and most convenient. So those moving costs are definitely a thing. Some people, I mean, I guess if you’re moving, then you’d have to consider things such as deposits on rent, rental fees. There might be costs as well for even finding a place to stay if your institution doesn’t provide that. Some people might work through agents. If that’s easier and safer for you, obviously different cities, different countries have different rules and regulations.

09:10 Rutendo: But I’d say that’s definitely a big thing to consider. So, and then the different taxes. Council tax in some places. I know in the UK, council tax is sort of like a big thing, which is one of the bills to do with, you know, your household that you need to consider and that you need to kind of look up at if you know, what’s easier and cheaper for you. If you’re a student, generally, depending on what household you’re living in, you can get a waiver for that. The process on that also requires research. I think the biggest expense is definitely if anybody moving, let’s say cities right now, would be things to do with, with living, added on to what we talked about before.

Different Scales of Moves

09:47 Emily: Yeah. I’m actually thinking back because there are different like scales of moves, right? So I’m thinking back to when I started graduate school, which I was living within a long drive, it was like a four-hour drive from where I was living before to my new graduate student city. So I was just able to drive with my stuff in the back of my car, did not bring any furniture. You know, it was pretty like low-key in terms of the actual transit costs. And then also I got into an apartment complex where they were doing, they didn’t require like a massive upfront deposit. It was some kind of like student special, you know, kind of thing. Like, so I feel like my move, which I did with no savings. I had like my last paycheck that was going to get me through two months, you know, to my first graduate student paycheck.

10:29 Emily: I did that without, you know, any real strain. I didn’t really buy furniture. I kind of lived without furniture for awhile, but that was a really, really low-key, low-scale kind of move. And like there can be, and we haven’t even talked about moving countries yet, but you can go way, way up on that scale. If you have an entire, you know, household, if you have stuffed move, if you’re flying and you have to ship your car, like plus as you just said, you know, I’m thinking about like Boston, where many people go through brokers and have to pay some kind of fee. Like, I don’t know if it’s a month’s rent like upfront just for that plus like the deposit, which could be large. Like, moves can vary so much from, I would say maybe a couple hundred dollars up to like thousands of dollars easily without even going, again, international. So like, that was my experience. I somehow like skated by with very little like actual outlay of money. What was your experience in this most recent move?

Rutendo’s Recent Move: 3 Suitcases

11:20 Rutendo: The most recent move? I could only fly with three suitcases. Somehow Emirates had a really great deal. So I could fly with three suitcases. In that, I made sure that I had my coffee pot because that’s always an essential, I had my bedding and my clothing, including my winter clothes. I knew winter clothes would be actually quite a big expense. So made sure that I had that over here. And then I didn’t have to buy furniture, thankfully, because I’m living in a student flat. So my apartment is actually furnished, so that’s great. But the biggest expenses now came into trying to, I guess, kind of make it feel like a home. Pots and pans, that that was not provided. The couple of basics. So it was a bit costly, but honestly, I guess not as costly as my master’s move, which is a whole different situation because I was not in student accommodation, which we could talk about later, the advantages and disadvantages of that.

12:13 Rutendo: So, this move was definitely slightly easier. But I did have quite some costs. And I did want to say there’s another cost that I think people, not even just internationals, might have to consider. If you’re changing things like your different insurances that you have, your health insurances. If you’re switching, you might need to do a bit more. So that’s also a cost that you need to consider, I guess, talk to your family about, or if you’re by yourself, figure that out how are you going to deal with those.

International Moves for Grad School

12:39 Emily: Yeah, absolutely. Okay. Let’s add that third layer on of now the move is an international move. Anything else you want to add about that particular cost?

12:47 Rutendo: Absolutely. Visa expenses. Sounds like just this one thing that you have to pay for, but then you need to consider the medical expenses within those. You need to consider health insurance within that. Some visas, like for example, the UK visa you have to pay, I think now it’s up to 500 pounds for every year of your visa. And so if you’re getting a five-year visa, it’s quite expensive. So you need to consider that. And then consider obviously things, things like flights you need to consider expenses to do with opening up a new bank account. You can get free bank accounts thankfully, but navigating that system. So, and if you’re going to a new country that you’ve never been to, I would say always make sure that you are able to have money to move around. So transport, to be able to do a couple of things in the first few weeks that you’re there. Add this to everything else that was mentioned before deposits: first month’s rent, household items, textbooks, and all the good stuff.

Challenges for Underprivileged Students Starting Grad School

13:46 Emily: Yeah. Wow. It can be quite a list here. So let’s now focus in particular on underprivileged students. What are the, you know, particular challenges that they’re going to have when they start up grad school?

Challenge #1: Funding

13:57 Rutendo: I’d like to talk about this in four different groups. So the first one is funding. I think this is the biggest thing to even begin with. Sometimes you can have funding for a year. Make sure you understand what your funding structure is as an underprivileged student. You want to know what is included and what is not included. Make sure that when they say it’s just tuition, you’re aware that it’s just tuition and you need to consider how you’re going to live and where that money is going to come from, what opportunities there are for RA ships, TA ships, how much they pay. And so to navigate that, before even I think I would say accepting and finalizing your offer. The different reasons why underprivileged students, you know, can have more difficulty navigating the funding structure, especially if you’re international, there’s that added layer. One of the things is that if you’re from certain countries, for example, I’ll give you the example of myself as a Zimbabwean. I am from a country that was formerly the Commonwealth and is no longer slash officially in the Commonwealth. So there are a lot of funding things that I could qualify for, but I don’t qualify for anymore. And so I needed to understand what I could get and what I couldn’t get. The offer I got, right now it covers tuition. My tuition is covered by the lab that I’m a part of. I’m a part of the computational propaganda lab here. However, there is no stipend. So for me to get a stipend, I need to work my maximum number of hours as an RA. And so that’s something I had to think about. Do I want to not have 20 hours a week to do my research, but to be an RA?

15:21 Rutendo: And so you need to be able to think about the time factor and how that is affecting or adding onto your work. Fortunately, my RA actually allows me to do the work in my research field. So it’s not like I’m spending 20 hours a week doing something that has nothing to do with my research, just so I can pay bills. However, I do need to do this so that I can pay bills. And so there’s that aspect as well of funding. And then one of the things I am consistently aware of is that my funding is pretty much dependent on grants that the lab has. And so that might be perceived as somewhat of a risk. However, it’s a bit of a new situation, not a new situation. It’s something that the lab has done for years. And so this is just how a lot of students in my lab are funded. But just me understanding that it’s not coming from a specific fund, is very useful for me to know what I can do and what I can’t do. So to ask those questions for funding.

16:14 Emily: Yeah, I totally agree. And I think this is, how funding works. It actually varies quite a lot by where you are the field that you’re in the type of university that you’re at. And so like, I am just thinking, Oh wow, I should really create a resource that’s like all just how funding grad school works. And I’m thinking to myself, do I know the full picture? Because I know things very well for certain fields that I’m close to, but like to know the full picture I think is very difficult. So for anyone, really, you do need to understand how funding works in your field, in that school, in that specific situation, where it’s coming from, what you have to do to get it, like you were just saying, how reliable it is, who it’s depending on? You know, if there’s a downturn in enrollment, are TA positions going to go away?

17:01 Emily: If your lab doesn’t get that next grant is like, that, you know, sector of your funding going to go away? Are there any guarantees? You know, guarantees at least in the U.S., they vary quite a lot. Some people get them. Some people don’t. Depends on the field. Depends on the school. Not getting one is not necessarily a bad sign. Although certainly getting one is a great sign. So there’s just a lot of layers to this. And yeah, I think the less versed you are in it, the more, yeah, you’re kind of flying by the seat of your pants, and it’s worth investigating for sure. Probably at an earlier stage than we’re talking about right now, we’re talking to basically rising or matriculating graduate students. And this is something you should ideally try to figure out kind of before you even apply so that you can, you know, know that you’re applying to the right places that have the right funding structure for you.

Challenge #2: Research

17:45 Rutendo: Then the next piece for me is research. Your actual research, but also I do need to say maybe this is in my field as a social scientist. I do not know how things work for sciences or humanities. But generally funding in terms of money and personal finances, there are things that your department, you know, some people can self-fund for a lot of things. So for example, some software that we use, some people in my department will say, Oh yeah, the software is fairly cheap. And I just subscribe this much a year. For me, that takes quite a bit out of my budget, you know? And it is part of research. It is actually part of a research cost. So things like that. However, I guess the best way to go about it is to talk to your department about it and understand what you need for your research.

18:27 Rutendo: If anything, if you think anything at all is tied to your research, talk to your department about it because they should be able to support you through that. But definitely I think as an underprivileged student, if I hadn’t spoken to other people who have navigated the system before, I would be worried about buying such software, for example, or I would be worried about managing the cap on the research fund that I have to be able to do field work and get those needs met as well. And so I think that’s definitely something that, you know, you kind of learn as you navigate the system. Yeah.

19:02 Emily: Yeah. Absolutely totally agree. Ideally, get someone else to pay for everything. And if not, at least you ask and then, you know, well, this is not something that we cover. And then you get to decide, you have to decide if it’s something that you’re willing to do out of your personal funds. But just apply, apply, apply, I would say, for funding. You know, extra grants. A lot of times travel in U.S. institutions sometimes comes down to the student to fund. Like, you know, summer trips to here or there to do their research. Basically, you’re going to get a grant for it, or you’re not going to go. I don’t think that too many people fund those things by themselves, but the smaller costs, like you were saying, like software or some kinds of equipment. Yeah. You should definitely be asking, at least, that your department will do it.

Challenge #3: Professional Development

19:44 Rutendo: For sure. The third one is professional development, and these are things that are not necessarily tied to your work or your research, but you need to do to begin to build up your CV or your presence in the field. And so some of the things might include, some courses offered through either online courses offered through either organizations or sometimes schools do actually offer these, but you still have to pay for them. So I know my library offers different professional development courses and, you know, each of them cost like about 15 pounds, a course. And so imagine taking about, you know, four or five of those a year. For some people, that could add up quite a bit. There could be things like attending conferences as well, that are not necessarily hosted by your school. It could be things like attending events.

20:37 Rutendo: I mean, I know I’m saying attending now, they’re all on online. Some thankfully are free, some still aren’t, which is still a cost for a lot of people. And so even though these things aren’t necessarily tied to your research, these are expenses that some students have actually footed themselves, but I don’t think it’s necessary for you to always do that. And this is, once again, when we talk about applying for assistance. But when it comes to applying, I do want to point out that the information isn’t always out there explicitly to say, Hey, there’s money. You can apply for this. So if there is something that you think somebody might cover, even if you don’t think somebody might cover it, just ask. The chances are that somebody will know where the answer is. Even if it’s not, you know, on the website that says, Hey, we offer professional development funds. But that’s definitely something I think underprivileged students can fall behind on simply because some of us have to cover a lot of gaps, not coming from families with people that have done PhDs, or some of us will be first-generation graduates to even begin with. And so we might have a lot more things and a lot more sessions or professional development work that we need to do but not enough money to actually pay for those things. And so there are a couple of costs entailed in that.

21:52 Emily: Yeah. And when you say ask, I just wanted to point out, who? Who should the people ask?

21:59 Rutendo: A supervisor, I would say start with your supervisor as the first port of call is your supervisor. Your department might have somebody that’s in charge of your program as well. I don’t know how different institutions work, but generally there’s someone that’s not necessarily your supervisor, but oversees your actual program. Those are the people to talk to you. And then if it’s things that are very just professional development focused, career services. I know a lot of schools have career services departments.

22:24 Rutendo: Those places are actually really great, whether you’re an undergrad or a PhD student. They know a lot about what’s going on. And so definitely those three, start off with those three. One of them will be able to assist.

22:36 Emily: Yeah, I would also add older students, students ahead of you. If they’ve done a conference that you want to go to, just ask them if they had it funded from somewhere. If they say, no, that’s not necessarily the final word, but if they say yes, then you’ve gotten a really good lead. And I would say also, you know, the person in charge of the program at my school that was called the Director of Graduate Studies, DGS. That person has an assistant. That is the person who knows everything going on everywhere. So that is the person to befriend to get on your side to advocate for you. That person is going to be an amazing resource just generally, but specifically with respect to funding and knowing how everything works behind the scenes.

23:17 Rutendo: That is definitely true. There is always that one person in administration who’s a great person to know. And I agree with that. Finding those people is very useful.

Commercial

23:28 Emily: Emily here for a brief interlude. Taxes are weirdly, unexpectedly difficult for funded grad students and fellowship recipients at any level of PhD training. Your university might send you strange tax forms or no tax forms at all. They might not withhold your income tax from your paychecks, even though you owe it. It’s a mess. I’ve created a ton of free resources to assist you with understanding and preparing your 2020 tax return, which are available at pfforphds.com/tax. I hope you’ll check them out to ease much of the stress of tax season. If you want to go deeper with the material or have a question for me, please join one of my tax workshops, which you can find links to from P F F O R P H D S.com/T A X. It would be my pleasure to help you save time and potentially money this tax season. So don’t hesitate to reach out. Now, back to our interview.

Challenge #4: Emergencies

24:34 Emily: Okay. And we had a fourth one, right?

24:38 Rutendo: Now, the last one has nothing to do with all of these other things, but it’s emergencies. These happen. And sometimes, especially as a student, as an underprivileged student, if you’re moving somewhere new, you might have used most of your money for moving in and getting settled, but emergencies do happen. And this actually recently happened to me whereby I needed to go to an emergency room. Thankfully, it was not COVID-related. So just have to say that in a pandemic, just to make sure. However, you know, I ended up being able to talk to my welfare team here at the college and they covered a lot of the costs for a lot of things that I didn’t even know they could be covered for that are emergencies simply because I wasn’t ready then when that happened.

25:25 Rutendo: And so I think it’s really important that we understand that whatever emergencies we face to be able to be open about them, to the best of our abilities and you know, and obviously balance keeping your privacy and your private information private, but also letting letting the right people know to give you assistance. Because while some people might be able to just write their families and, you know, call up home and say, Hey, look, I need an extra, this amount of money. Some people might not be able to. And so to know that most universities will be, there will be some funds somewhere. I know my university has something called hardship funds for things like that. And different levels of it that you can apply for, but definitely the understand that emergencies for underprivileged students can be something difficult to navigate and challenging as well.

26:13 Emily: Absolutely. Absolutely. Could not agree more. I think in the U.S. it’s becoming more common, but I wouldn’t say it’s totally common, that universities or graduate schools have either emergency grants or emergency loans available. It’s not everywhere, but it’s definitely, definitely worth inquiring about because it’s, yeah, it’s becoming more and more popular to set up those kinds of things. As we understand, not everyone has the means to cover an emergency in cash or has access to debt even to finance an emergency or has family to fall back on or whatever the case may be. Yeah, not everywhere, but definitely worth asking about.

People are Your Best Resource: Talk to Them 

26:53 Emily: Okay. Yeah. Anything else you wanted to add about sort of helping, you know, underprivileged graduate students prepare for starting graduate school or, you know, make it to the end? Because finances are a big reasons that people leave PhD programs.

27:08 Rutendo: I mean, I would say that, you know, the most important thing in terms of getting a hold of your finances is also just, you gave the advice of talking to older students in one of the specific categories for professional development. But in general, talking to as many students as you can, once you accept it, try to connect. If there are any people that you see online, if you’re on Twitter, for example, you know, when somebody says I’m doing this program, try to connect with them. I set up a couple of Zoom calls with third years and second years and even people that had just finished their PhDs in my department, just to talk to them, just to hear about their experiences and, you know, students, you know, not just underprivileged students, but everyone just to know about the experiences outside and inside to know what I need to prepare.

27:51 Rutendo: And so I think that’s part of your research and getting so that you really understand your finances. Especially if you’re going to be doing some form of RAing or TAing, it’s important to talk to somebody that has done it so that you understand such as the salary structures as well. Because, you know, sometimes they tell you, this is how much you get paid pro rata, but you don’t even understand what pro rata is, for example. And so it would be useful to talk to people. So I’d say, that your best resource is people that have been through the very same system as well. And just understand the general lifestyle that helps you understand the costs, you know. So just asking them what they do in general, how much things cost, ask people where they go shopping, what things they had to buy, things like that would be very useful as you are preparing to go, and helps you definitely understand your finances, even before you start.

Establishing Good Financial Habits in Grad School

28:40 Emily: So the last thing we wanted to talk about was establishing good financial habits at the start of graduate school. Both what those habits might be, and how to actually go about establishing them, which is really the key. So let’s talk about what habits are great to establish at the beginning of graduate school, and for each one, how people can do that.

Habit #1: Track Your Expenses

28:57 Rutendo: Okay. I think the first habit is to track your expenses.

29:02 Emily: I always say that number one as well.

29:03 Rutendo: Which is, I must actually say, something I got from your podcast. So I listened to this podcast before doing my PhD and honestly like it’s, I went on a binge and it has been very useful for me. And I learned to track, just track. So what I did was I had the first month of not knowing, you know, what is needed or no projections, not knowing how much I might be able to save, just to track everything I bought. It sounds tedious, but you do need to track. And so the how, I think there are different ways of doing this. The way I did it was I used Notion. So I made a table and this sort of like budget looking thing in Notion, even though it wasn’t a budget, it was what I was spending.

29:50 Rutendo: And I had categories for each thing. So groceries and toiletries. So I knew that week one, this is what I spent. Week two, this is what I spent. So that helped me also see an average about on average per week, what am I spending on this? And then I kept my subscriptions. So knowing what subscriptions, you know, I have, and then during that month also making sure am I actually using them, like I have Spotify premium. Do I actually use it? How important is this feature for me? And then there were miscellaneous as well. Things that I, you know, that I’m spending on this month that I won’t necessarily be spending on next month, but just to understand that how much cushion and move room do I have in my budget for that? So I wasn’t going to be buying pots and pans every month, for example. But I kept that in there. That helped me understand an average. Because there will be some things that I will need to pick up throughout the month that are not in necessary, you know?

30:40 Rutendo: So having all of that. The other way you could do your tracking is to use the budget apps, you know, the ones that you connect your bank accounts to an app. I think in the U.S. it might be mint that most people use. In the UK, I use money dashboard. Personally, I find that to be really good. It has, you know, web interface and app interface, and it’s fairly automatic. And so habit number one is track. Just, you know, just to understand exactly what you’re spending. Don’t try to, and don’t lie about anything. If you spend, if you spend money, I spend money on sparkling water because I love sparkling water and I don’t have a soda stream. I wrote that down just so that I actually understand how much money I’m spending on sparkling water. Things like that.

31:32 Emily: Yeah. Completely could not agree more. And I would say when you’re choosing like this manual method, which as you said, can be tedious. I think there’s a lot of power there in the tedium and staying close to the expenses. But if you know yourself and you know that you’re not going to do it, you know, you’re not going to do this daily or multi times per day or whatever it is, and you decide to use mint or you need a budget or something similar, that’s okay. Know yourself, know what’s sustainable for you. And just choose something that, as you said, can become a habit and it is, you know, less maintenance to use one of these automated systems, yeah. But whatever can become easiest for you to sustain. I know for example, I kind of fall on this manual tracking side of things. My husband will not do that. So for us keeping a joint budget together, it has to be software, or it’s not going to get done. But it is a habit. And when we use software, we do check it. So whatever you think is sustainable for you in the longterm.

Habit #2: Understand Your Expenses

32:22 Rutendo: Right. Absolutely. And then the second habit would be connected to the tracking. So after the tracking comes the budgeting. And that’s something that I have found to be very useful. So I then moved, after understanding my expenses, I then, you know, created like a, okay, so per month here’s how much I want. Here’s, you know, on average how much I think I need for groceries, how much I need, I think, for this and this and that. And then I then moved it into the automated system. The automated system for me was easier simply because there were things that I could grab, let’s say, and sometimes forget to enter. I was afraid I’d forget to enter manually because I was no longer in the tracking phase. I was now in, you know, I’m technically still the tracking phase, but you know what I mean?

33:04 Rutendo: Like in the actual making sure I understand how much I spent of what phase. And so I moved that understanding to money dashboard and had all the different categories. And, you know, it’s been very useful, but like you said, even if you do automate something, it’s a habit. So I do check my money dashboard just to make sure that an expense has gone into the correct category or into the category I want it to go into by the categories I’ve set in my budget. So, and also just to see how far I have, how much do I have left this month for this specific thing?

33:35 Emily: One thing that I think is really valuable about tracking, and also budgeting to an extent, is even if you don’t really think you need to do it right now, you may, six months from now, want to look back at that data and, you know, get some insights from it because of a decision or something you have to make at that point. So, it’s just a good thing to make a habit, you know, make as low maintenance as you possibly can, just so you may want to use that data in the future you’ll have it.

34:03 Rutendo: Absolutely. Yeah, one thing I do understand that because of, I do regret not having had a budget during my master’s degree because it was in the same country, so I really have no excuse. So, I couldn’t actually say how much I spent on groceries on average. You know, now I can say that and now I can. And so I do agree. It is nice to just have that data at some point. You never know what you might do next in a couple of months or a couple of years even.

Habit #3: Save

34:30 Emily: Yeah. What’s the next habit on your list?

34:33 Rutendo: The next habit on my list is to save. This one is a bit, I think people, people go about it different ways. I know that the advice generally is pay yourself first, which I understand is great advice. As somebody who’s not that wealthy, not even, let me not even put a “that.” Who is not wealthy, who is mostly just doing enough to get by, paying myself first is actually quite, quite difficult, even on my budget categories. What I always do know is that I always have some little leftover. So I do this thing that I actually learned again from another guest on this podcast, which is at the end of the month, whatever I have leftover in my checking account, I put into my saving and I start from zero with my new paycheck. That is my saving. And then there’s also the other way that I save, technically kind of like save/invest, is through this app called Moneybox.

35:31 Rutendo: I think the U.S. equivalent might be Acorn. I don’t know if that’s what they do, they round up your expenses and sort of, kind of like quote unquote invest it for you. It’s not like you’re investing in big, very risky, you know, things. You’re not making like $5,000 worth of investments, but it is quite nice to just see that number go up. You know, if I buy something and then there’s 20 pence left, knowing that that 20 pence is going to do something. Because also, at the end of the day, in my head, in my budget, anyway, that was a round figure, right? That was not necessarily 0.8. you know. And so, that sort of save and invest model, I find it to be very useful, to always try and save. And it’s useful to save, even if you’re saving very little, because once again, emergencies do happen.

36:19 Rutendo: And then it also is useful to try and strive towards getting to that three to six months worth of expenses, which is something you don’t always start with. Especially if you’re somebody that’s not coming from a wealthy background. You don’t always start out with being able to have three to six months worth of expenses in your savings account. But that little bit counts. Just that little bit counts, and hoping that emergencies don’t happen. Knock on wood. You will get there through I guess some of the other things we’ll talk about.

36:44 Emily: What I really like about that articulation. Now, of course I am an advocate of pay yourself first. I definitely am. But what I like about how you’ve set things up is that saving is not, even though it’s the last thing you do with your money each month, it’s not the last thing on your mind. You know throughout the month that you have that intention of doing it at the end. And so I’m sure it affects your behavior. Oh, well, I want to be able to save a little bit more this month. So I’m going to really try to come in under budget on this category, because I know that’s going to enable me to save this much more. And so what I like about that is that it’s still an intentional thing that you have throughout the entire month, even though you do the action at the end.

37:20 Emily: And I think that, you know, sometimes that’s just how you need to start. And when you’re living essentially paycheck to paycheck, you know, there’s a possibility you might spend your entire paycheck that month, if something odd came up and you can’t, you really can’t, you know, set anything aside in advance. It’s okay to do that system. As long as it’s working for you most of the time, most of the time that you’re able to save something at the end of the month and increase that savings as you were just talking about. I think, you know, it’s, it’s a way it’s a way to start. It’s a way to start saving,

37:47 Rutendo: Right. Also, just to actually say that that’s what I’m doing now, because I’m just starting out. So my intention right now is, because technically I’m still settling in. So there are still odd expenses that are coming up here and there since I’ve been here for a couple of months, but I don’t think that’s what I’ll be doing, let’s say, next year, this time. By then I will have, you know, very few things that come up and I will now know exactly what I can save, even if I’m still living paycheck to paycheck, which then just becomes something I do first. And so this is definitely something transitionary, but yeah.

38:18 Emily: I think it’s also easier as you learn a new city to become more frugal with time. You know, you mentioned earlier, well, where do you shop? That’s a very key question. Maybe when you first move to a city, you don’t know the least expensive places to shop, or the places that have the sales at this particular day of the week. You don’t have that insight. And so, you know what you’re spending on groceries, for example, in month one, you might be able to spend much less by month 13 because you figured out a few of those tricks. And so don’t think that just because you’re starting out completely paycheck to paycheck, that you’re going to be that way forever, because you will learn over time if you’re, you know, if you’re minded in that way.

38:53 Rutendo: Absolutely.

Habit #4: Learn How to Be Frugal

38:54 Emily: Okay. So do you have another habit on your list?

38:56 Rutendo: Yes. Which you actually kind of got to, which is understanding the best way you can be frugal. I put it in a different category than saving because the saving is something very technical, but the other habit you can do is try to find out how best you can reduce costs. It doesn’t matter how little it sounds. You know, for example, Spotify premium, normal is 9.99 pounds, student is 4.99. You might think, okay, that’s not much, but it is, it sort of adds up. So if you know what, just that extra amount of time it takes for you to sign up to student, if you need that. If you use that. Or knowing exactly where to shop, right? And if you go to the store and we’re like, here, we have reduced shelves where you can get fruits and vegetables that are technically about to go bad, kind of like the shelf date really, saves a bit more, you know, I could buy an avocado for 40 P or I could buy it for two pounds 70.

39:47 Rutendo: So then I get two avocados, instead. You know, something like that, just, just being as frugal as you can. If there are books that you want to buy, trying to get them second hand, instead of getting them new. You know, or if it’s something that you actually don’t need to be writing in and that you just want to browse, consider getting it from your library instead. If you’re fortunate enough to be living in, you know, even in a pandemic, some libraries are doing, you know, click and collects or things like that. So try to do that. So just finding ways to be frugal, no matter how small the amount seems, definitely adds up. And the other technique, and this is cash backs as well. I know that some banks do different cashback things with, you know, different retailers or you could actually sign up for like I think in the UK there’s TopCashback or something I think is also a U.S. thing online.

40:44 Emily: I use Rakuten.

40:46 Rutendo: They do have that. Yes. Yes. So things like that definitely, you know, for things that you’re going to buy anyway, might as well get a percentage of it back it’s really useful. And these things I know they seem very minimal when you think about you’re like, Oh, it’s 5%. It adds up. It adds up, and that 5% could be something that goes into your savings, for example. Fine. If you don’t want to spend it on something new, that’s how you end up getting to your three to six months worth of, you know, expenses of savings. So.

41:16 Emily: I was just going to say, tie any little frugal, you know, tactic that you implement to directly increasing your savings rate. If that’s your top goal at the moment, right? So if you, as you were just saying with Spotify, for example, you know, you reduce it by $5, whatever it is, Hey, why don’t you pay yourself first $5? Because you were spending that anyway. So that’s the way you can kind of transition between these two systems, or save at the end of the month. Hey, my grocery budget was this, but I came in, you know, $10 lower because I’ve learned all these frugal things to do. Okay. Your $10 at the end of the month gets to go into your savings. Yes. I love that idea. Yeah. Did you have another habit?

A Note on Side Hustling

41:52 Rutendo: Well, technically it’s not a habit, I guess, because a habit would have to be things that you do consistently, but then to try and be on, this is the last thing under this question, to try and do like side hustle type of things. I don’t know if I could classify that as a habit or a thing. But also, I mean, obviously you have to consider how much time it takes away from your work, because, you know, first and foremost, you are a student. But if possible, you know, there are different ways. Some people do short-term consulting things. I know for me, the thing that has helped me right now is a short-term consulting gig which I know, you know, at the end of that will help me build up my savings so much faster than, you know, saving the little bits off of my paycheck and things like that.

42:34 Rutendo: And so to find out where your skills lie, if somebody wants help with like a couple of editing, copyrights, things like that, that you could take away just a couple of hours of your time to do. Not necessarily to make that become the focus, but only if possible. And this is something that sometimes is also really a sign of privilege as well, actually, rather than something I’d advise underprivileged students to do, because sometimes you have more things to deal with, honestly, than side hustling. So this is why I’m not saying this is necessarily a habit, but if you feel that you do have that privilege of time and space and mental capacity to do that, then do so. But don’t necessarily, please, if there’s something you can’t do feel obligated to.

43:16 Emily: Yeah, absolutely. I mean, you’re primarily in your degree program to get that degree. So I always say about side hustling, like, don’t do anything that’s going to jeopardize your progress toward that end goal. But if you have the capacity, it can be a really great supplement. And like you were saying, I think that sometimes graduate students you know, they end up devaluing what they’re capable of doing because they’re being paid such a low, you know, rate through their stipend or whatever. If you can do consulting, as you were just saying, or employ your skills in another non-academic capacity, especially, you might be able to command a fairly high pay rate, at least compared to what you’re getting through your primary work as a graduate student. And so don’t think that a side hustle is going to be 20 hours a week or 10 hours a week.

44:03 Emily: It could be, as you said, two hours a week and still make a really big impact on your budget. If you select it very carefully, really employing what makes you unique in the marketplace. Now I will say, because we’ve been talking a lot about international students in this interview, in the U.S., international students are extraordinarily limited in what they’re permitted to do in terms of making money outside of their primary position. That is, they really can’t do anything unless it’s been approved through like CPT, like OPT kind of situation. So I’m not encouraging international students to side hustle to work for money, but there might be ways that you can set up passive income sources that it’s not actually exchanging work for money, but other ways you might be able to make money. You mentioned cash back earlier. Credit card rewards are a thing.

44:51 Emily: They can be fairly lucrative. I’ve had a couple episodes in the past on that. So I’ll link them from the show notes. International students would not be able to do that day one arriving in the U.S. because you have to work on your credit score first. But after a year or two, that might be a possibility as like a passive income source. So you are going to have to be a little bit more creative in your thinking about side generating side income as an international student, but it is still possible. Maybe it’s worth looking into again, if you have the time and the energy to do so.

45:19 Rutendo: Precisely. Yes.

Best Financial Advice for Another Early-Career PhD

45:22 Emily: Okay. Rutendo, thank you so much for this wonderful interview. I think we’ve gotten so many insights out of it. I will ask you for one last one, which is what is your best financial advice for another early-career PhD? And that can be something that we’ve already touched on in the interview, or it can be something completely new.

45:39 Rutendo: I would say, we’ve already talked about this. If there’s a chance that you don’t have to pay for it, don’t. It doesn’t matter what it is. Just ask if there’s a chance that you don’t. Because it doesn’t matter how many times you track something, how many times you budget something, if you can get it from somewhere else, all these other habits, all these other things will be better as a result of you not necessarily having to go out of your way to do this. So that’s the biggest thing for me.

46:04 Emily: Absolutely. I think, you know, maybe a more broad category of term for this is just negotiation. Like you can kind of think about it that way, because you’re just sort of ferreting out, you’re feeling out, is there a possibility that someone else can foot this bill for me? Is there another creative way that I can get this paid for by someone else? I know in the U.S. we don’t have a strong culture of negotiation at all in terms of like sales or anything, but I know that other countries, it’s more of a common thing that you learn in your childhood. And so if that’s your, you know, personality, maybe you can think of it that way as just feeling out what are the possibilities here, financially? What are the parameters of this space? Yeah. And oftentimes that’ll be to your advantage. I mean, you’re not going to get anywhere by not asking. That’s for sure.

46:46 Rutendo: Definitely. And I mean, I do just want to say that, especially for underprivileged students, the one thing I do want to say about the reason I’m giving this advice and I put it, so plainly is because a lot of us it’s about our mindset. A lot of us were, you know, I mean, let me not say a lot of us, but then for me, the problem I had to get over was knowing that I had to work for certain things and then sort of feeling that I am not allowed to have certain things, just the social conditioning, right? That I’ve already come this far as like a Black African woman. Now I have to ask again, if they could pay for this conference. Now I have to ask again, but really just, there are people, you know, once I started talking to people that have been doing this for four years and some people for generations because the families had already navigated the system. This is actually what the system is the afford to support you, to become the best that you can be as a researcher, as a student, as whatever it is that you’re doing.

47:40 Rutendo: And so it’s not necessarily, I hope that a lot of people realize it’s not in sense of entitlement, but really just to understand that there are systems of support that might not be explicitly said, you know or stated that they are there, but they really are there for you. And to help you with your finances. And like you said, Emily, at the beginning of the interview, a lot of people are beginning to understand now that finances really impact underprivileged students’ experiences in these institutions. And they are open to that and open to discussion and negotiation. So.

48:12 Emily: That was so well put. Thank you so much for this interview, Rutendo. It was a pleasure to speak with you again.

48:16 Rutendo: Thank you so much. Thank you for having me. I appreciate it.

Outro

48:23 Emily: Listeners, thank you for joining me for this episode. Pfforphds.com/podcast is the hub for the Personal Finance for PhDs Podcast. On that page are links to all the episode show notes, which include full transcripts and videos of the interviews. There is also a form to volunteer to be interviewed on the podcast and instructions for entering the book giveaway contest and submitting a question for the Q&A segment. I’d love for you to check it out and get more involved. If you’ve been enjoying the podcast, here are four ways you can help it grow. One, subscribe to the podcast and rate and review it on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, or whatever platform you use. If you leave a review, be sure to send it to me to share an episode you found particularly valuable on social media with an email listserv, or as a link from your website. Three, recommend me as a speaker to your university or association. My seminars cover the personal finance topics PhDs are most interested in like investing, debt repayment, and taxes. Four, subscribe to my mailing list at pfforphds.com/subscribe. Through that list, you’ll keep up with all the new content and special opportunities for Personal Finance for PhDs. See you in the next episode! And remember, you don’t have to have a PhD to succeed with personal finance, but it helps. The music is Stages of Awakening by Podington Bear from the free music archive and is shared under CC by NC. Podcast editing and show notes creation by Meryem Ok.

This PhD Found Financial Peace through Pursuing FIRE

April 19, 2021 by Meryem Ok

In this episode, Emily interviews Dr. 50 of By 50 Journey, a federal employee who is pursuing financial independence and early retirement (FIRE). Dr. 50 came to the US after finishing college, but worked minimum wage jobs while she learned English until she could apply to PhD programs. She worked full-time to self-fund her PhD over six years. Ultimately the PhD was a game-changer for Dr. 50’s income, and within three or four years of finishing she was earning a six-figure salary. However, a higher salary was not the solution to her family’s financial problems. Dr. 50 describes her emotions at their financial low point, when they completed their debt repayment journey, and upon discovering the FIRE movement. Dr. 50 concludes the interview with an incredible insight regarding financial struggle and striving.

Links Mentioned in This Episode

  • PF for PhDs: Community
  • Walden on Wheels (Book by Ken Ilgunas)
  • E-mail Emily (for Book Giveaway Contest)
  • PF for PhDs: Podcast Hub
  • By 50 Journey Website
  • General Schedule (GS)
  • The Academic Society Website 
  • Toyin’s Free Masterclass (Emily’s Affiliate Link)
  • PF for PhDs: Subscribe to Mailing List
PhD FIRE

Teaser

00:00 Dr. 50: And one day I was like, okay, this is it. I am making a six-figure salary and I couldn’t even afford a lunch at the cafeteria. And it’s like a wake-up call. I need to do something. We need to do something.

Introduction

00:21 Emily: Welcome to the Personal Finance for PhDs Podcast: A Higher Education in Personal Finance. I’m your host, Dr. Emily Roberts. This is season eight, episode 16, and today my guest is Dr. 50 of By 50 Journey, a federal employee who is pursuing financial independence and early retirement: FIRE. Dr. 50 came to the U.S. after finishing college, but worked minimum wage jobs while she learned English until she could apply for PhD programs. She worked full-time to self-fund her PhD over six years. Ultimately, the PhD was a game-changer for Dr. 50’s income, and within three or four years of finishing, she was earning a six-figure salary. However, a higher salary was not the solution to her family’s financial problems. Dr. 50 describes her emotions at their financial low point when they completed their debt repayment journey. And upon discovering the FIRE movement. Listen through to the end for an incredible insight from Dr. 50 regarding financial struggle and striving.

01:28 Emily: We’ve just passed decision day, April 15th, so I’d like to extend a massive congratulations to everyone who committed to a graduate program for fall 2021. This is an incredibly exciting period of time. As you dream about and plan this new phase of your life, keep your finances top of mind. You’ve already made the biggest financial decision of your graduate career by one, choosing to attend graduate school, and two, committing to a specific stipend and location. The next biggest decisions are housing and transportation, which presumably you will lock in over the next few months. Before making those big commitments, I recommend that you sketch a budget to figure out how much you can afford while ideally maintaining some kind of savings rate. If you would like some help with that process, join the Personal Finance for PhDs Community at pfforphds.community. Inside the Community, you’ll find my How to Draft a Budget From a Distance webinar and custom spreadsheet. We also have a forum and monthly live calls where we can chat more about your specific situation. I would love to assist you with this process in any way that I can.

Book Giveaway Contest

02:44 Emily: Now, it’s time for the book giveaway contest. In April, 2021, I’m giving away one copy of Walden on Wheels by Ken Ilgunas, which is the Personal Finance for PhDs Community book club selection for June 2021. Everyone who enters the contest during April will have a chance to win a copy of this book. If you would like to enter the giveaway contest, please rate and review this podcast on Apple Podcasts, take a screenshot of your review, and email it to me at [email protected]. I’ll choose a winner at the end of April from all the entries. You can find full instructions at pfforphds.com/podcast. The podcast received a review recently titled exactly what I was looking for. Quote, having read a lot of scattered news articles and attending college workshops, I still felt a need for expert advice on investment strategies for international students. I stumbled upon this podcast while doing my weekly finance research, and I can say that Dr. Roberts does a phenomenal job at it. PF for PhDs is one of the few resources I could find which has got something for every grad student trying to figure out personal finances. Highly recommend it to incoming and current students alike. End quote. Thank you so much for this review. I am focusing more energy in 2021 on serving international students, postdocs, and workers, and I’m so glad that is coming across. Without further ado, here’s my interview with Dr. 50 from By 50 Journey.

Will You Please Introduce Yourself Further?

04:19 Emily: I am delighted to have joining me on the podcast today, Dr. 50. She actually goes by Mrs. 50 on her blog, By 50 Journey, which is a FIRE journey blog. However, she does have a PhD. So, we’re going to call her Dr. 50 today. She has an incredible story to tell us about coming to the U.S. As an immigrant, speaking no English, having no money, and you know, pursuing a PhD and ultimately being on this path to financial independence and early retirement. So, really delighted to get her story today. Dr. 50, welcome to the podcast. And will you please tell us a little bit more about yourself?

04:55 Dr. 50: Thank you so much. That was a really great introduction. Yes. That was a long time ago. I would say like over two decades, I came to this country and I had nothing. I mean, it’s nothing. So, I was trying to get a job, but I didn’t get any, because of course I didn’t speak any English. I couldn’t even answer a simple question like, how are you, what are you doing? Because I could understand, but I couldn’t express myself. So meaning trying to get a job, even a simple job. I couldn’t get it. So I was thinking, ah, this is, this is tougher than I thought it would be to start spending my life in a new country with my new husband. And I was trying, okay, let’s go back to grad school. That way I have friends. I have professor, I have, everybody so I can practice on my English. Because back in the day I didn’t have any friends, I don’t have anybody, except just for my husband. Right?

05:59 Dr. 50: And years later, I got accepted into grad school. I was so happy, but on the back of my mind, Oh well, okay, now here I am, I didn’t have any money. I didn’t have any financial support. And then I was trying to get funding, trying to get an assistantship, fellowship, whatever that was available. I didn’t get it. So, my first semester I used my credit card to pay for the tuition. I was, Oh, this is not going well. I have to do it better. So I was trying to find a job on campus. But as a student, we couldn’t work more than 20 hours. I said, this is not going to be enough to pay for everything. And not even the rent. Finally, in my second year of grad school, I got a full-time job which was wonderful. I was so grateful and I worked my way and then time flies.

07:07 Dr. 50: I got my master’s and PhD in six years because I was like, okay, let’s get this done as soon as possible so I can get a job and make real money. Right after I finished my PhD, I got a very great offer, even though I finished in the year 2008. So, everybody knows 2008 was the financial crisis. So I denied that job offer. I don’t know why, maybe because of the years, years, and the struggle of the grad school, I didn’t want to get that job because it was so stressful. So I accepted, I was a post-doc for a year and a half. During that time I was trying to find a real job. So I got a great job offer again. And then I got that job. And then my income was increased significantly. I would say, like triple. But unfortunately that job, it was in the city and I was traveling 90% of the time.

08:11 Dr. 50: And I just had a baby. I was happy with my job, but the work-life balance was not great. So I quit my dream job and then I had to find a job that’s not in the city. And then I got that with a negotiation that I negotiated with them. I managed to get the same salary that I had in the city, but I would live in the country. So, which is great. So, the struggle that was in grad school and a great job offer and determination and then patience. So I would say this is from, didn’t speak English to have a career that I wanted because of my PhD, and I was really happy. So, I’m ready to go on to the next level.

Pre-Grad School Finances

09:12 Emily: Yeah. I want to tease out a couple other pieces of that stories so that I understand it correctly. And thank you for giving us that like overarching view of how your career has evolved. So, it sounds like when you came to the U.S., it was a few years in between when you first arrived and when you were accepted to graduate school, is that right?

09:33 Dr. 50: That is correct.

09:35 Emily: And so, were you ultimately able to find some kind of job? I know that you said that you struggled at first, but how were the finances for you and your husband during that pre-grad school period?

09:46 Dr. 50: Yeah, I had odd jobs washing dishes. I answered the phone. I worked in a Chinese restaurant. I worked in a factory. I worked night shift. I did everything that I could do to earn money. And back in the day, it was the minimum wage. I believe it was $4.75 an hour. And yes, we were struggling before I got accepted into school. Even though after I accepted into grad school, we were still struggling because okay, now I spend my time studying during the day. I didn’t have time to earn money, so it was zero, but yeah. And using credit cards to pay for living expenses, even to pay for rent.

10:33 Emily: Yeah. So, it sounds like you very clearly identified the PhD, having that credential, as the path out of these minimum wage positions, is that correct?

10:44 Dr. 50: Yes. Yes. Definitely.

PhD as a Path to Professorship

10:47 Emily: If you had stayed in your home country, do you think you would have pursued a PhD?

10:53 Dr. 50: Yes, because before I met my husband I had a fellowship lined up for me, which they would pay for my school expenses, tuition, and living expenses. And yeah, I was about to go to doing my masters at the time, but decision between, okay, stay here and pursue my dream of becoming a professor or go there and be with my husband, and the love all my life. So, it’s a life-changing decision.

11:28 Emily: I am glad to hear, though, that you were already oriented in that direction. You were already planning on doing the PhD. It’s just, you decided to do it in a different country and had to take a couple steps back and learn the language and so forth. But you still got to, in terms of doing the PhD, you still got to that same goal.

11:44 Dr. 50: Yes. I always wanted to be a professor. A university professor.

Making Ends Meet in Grad School

11:49 Emily: And one other question I had about kind of the finances during graduate school. You said that you initially started out financing, you know, you weren’t funded, so you were financing it through consumer debt, and ultimately you got, I think you said a full-time job, right? So was it the case that your PhD was never funded? You didn’t have an assistantship or a fellowship, but you worked aside from doing the PhD?

12:10 Dr. 50: Yes. I worked 20 hours at the university dining hall in the morning from 3:30 to eight o’clock. And then during the day I worked as a lab technician for 40 hours. So yeah, my week was full. I would get up at three o’clock and then wouldn’t come home until 11 at night.

12:38 Emily: So you were working 60 hours at jobs plus the PhD work?

12:45 Dr. 50: Yes. And I enrolled full-time because if I did it part-time, it would drag me to eight or 10 years. I couldn’t afford that. That’s too long.

12:57 Emily: Wow. Incredible. I can’t, I can’t even fathom how you got through that. And you said it took six years, right?

13:07 Dr. 50: Yeah. It took six years, a master’s for two years and PhD for four years.

13:11 Emily: And you kept up that, I mean, I’m just like flabbergasted, you kept up that schedule the whole time?

13:16 Dr. 50: Yes. And finally, when I did my research, I quit my dining hall job because it was, Oh, it’s early. And I had that job because I got free meals. So, to save money, so I got free meals for five days. So, that’s awesome. Finally, I didn’t have time to do my research, so I quit that job and then I just kept my full-time job.

Post-PhD Finances

13:45 Emily: Yeah. I think we’re getting a real picture of how your finances were, but what it took, the work it took to keep yourself afloat, you and your husband afloat, during that time. And you know, clearly why you had the motivation to do the PhD. So, I’m really glad to hear that element of the story. Thank you. And so, you told us a little bit earlier about, you know, having the postdoc position and then, you know, taking a couple of different jobs, post-PhD. Did you want to add anything in there about how your income has been or anything like that?

14:20 Dr. 50: Yeah, sure. So, during my grad school years, the part-time one was the dining hall one. That was minimum paid. So, it was like, six or $7 an hour for 20 hours. So, that wasn’t that much. My full-time job, I worked as a lab technician that was $15 an hour. Back in the day, that was, I’d say 15 years ago, that was a lot for me. So, I’d say that I earned the most was $34,000 a year. That was awesome. That’s great money for us. That allowed us to buy a house, this would be our first house, and I didn’t have to worry much about my school tuition. And during that time I was able to talk to my boss, have them pay for a couple of classes. So, that was great. And so, post-PhD I had a postdoc and that doubled my income. I earned $63,000. That was in 2009. I graduated in 2008. So, it was double wage. Our finances were starting to get a lot, a lot better.

15:42 Emily: I just want to ask there, what kind of setting was that postdoc position in? Because that sounds like a pretty well-paid one, especially for that time.

15:52 Dr. 50: I was in the federal agency.

15:55 Emily: Okay. Gotcha.

Money Mindset: Salary Negotiation

Dr. 50 (15:56): And I, again, I negotiated my salary. I always had this mindset, even though with the federal, we have to follow rules and although certain staff follow certain salary level. Yeah. I negotiated. So, actually, it started at, I believe back in the day, was like $51,000 and I was able to get $63,000.

16:23 Emily: I think that’s a really great tip for anyone else who’s looking to apply for federal jobs because you have the, it’s the GS system, is that right?

16:31 Dr. 50: Yeah, it’s the GS system. Even though you’ve been told, okay, this position will give you the GS level this or accept this, you can always negotiate with them. Even though they have the fixed table to follow, you always can negotiate. Yeah. So, after the postdoc, I got a really great job offer in the city. This is in New York city. I was like, Oh my God, New York city, that’s a high cost of living. But it was a job of my dreams. So, I took it and my salary was doubled again. So, I made a six-figure salary. So I came from making minimum wage and then making a six-figure salary within, I would say, three or four years after I got my PhD. So, it was very quick.

17:28 Emily: Yeah. And then you said you maintained that salary even though you didn’t live in New York anymore.

17:33 Dr. 50: Yes.

17:33 Emily: Yeah. That’s fantastic.

17:35 Dr. 50: I came back to the federal, and I negotiated with them again. Different agency. And then they said, yes. I said, Oh my gosh. Yeah. It was so wonderful.

17:46 Emily: And do you still work for the federal government?

17:47 Dr. 50: Yes.

Overcoming a Large Financial Struggle

17:48 Emily: Okay. Yes. Thank you so much. It’s an incredible income trajectory. Also in this period post-PhD, I understand you overcame a large financial struggle. Can you tell us about that?

18:01 Dr. 50: Yes. So, during my graduate school years, I mean, as I already told you guys, we didn’t have much. Plus I supported myself and my family, husband, because he was still trying to finish his college also. So, I’d been using credit cards to pay for my tuition. And I was trying to pay it off every month. Some months I did, and some months I did not. So, it’s accumulated from there. And also, when I got my first real job in the New York City, we had our first child and then baby came and husband still couldn’t find any jobs. So, he was unemployed for a long time. Plus, the daycare cost was like so high. So, it’s better for him to be at home and take care of the baby. And then I’ll take care of the financial side of it.

19:04 Dr. 50: And yes, during this time we have surgeries, hospital, car wreck, and everything you can imagine. So, we accumulated a lot of debt. And one day I was like, okay, this is it. I am making a six-figure salary, and I couldn’t even afford a lunch at the cafeteria. And it’s like a wake up call. I need to do something. We need to do something. So, I say to myself, okay, no more excuses. I don’t want to wait until he got a job or I don’t want to wait until the baby leaves the daycare and goes to school. Let’s start now. Let’s do it. Yeah, all of the frustration. I just made our plan, trying to pay off the debt and made a budget and started doing my excel sheets. And then we go from there. And then in less than six years, all the debt was gone, including the mortgage.

20:04 Emily: Wow. What was the total debt balance then? Between the mortgage and the consumer debt that you were working on?

20:10 Dr. 50: Yeah, we had one car payment that was $18,000 and credit card debt was almost $80,000 and the mortgage was $114,000. So, I would say that 230 to $240,000.

20:26 Emily: Wow. So, within six years you paid off 230, $240,000 of debt on $120k ish, it sounds like, salary. Plus your husband was not working or maybe started working at some point during that period?

20:43 Dr. 50: No.

20:43 Emily: Not working during that period.

20:45 Dr. 50: He was not working yet.

20:45 Emily: Okay. Home with the baby.

20:48 Dr. 50: Yes, home with the baby.

A Shift in Money Mindset

20:48 Emily: Yes, plenty of work there. But it doesn’t sound to me, I want to ask you a little bit more about that transition about that day you couldn’t buy the lunch, you were so frustrated. Because the things that you mentioned, you know, that got you into the debt, the medical bills and the car wreck, none of that was frivolous spending. So, what did change actually at that point?

21:13 Dr. 50: It changed because, it’s kind of embarrassing to say, but I spent hours, hours just to pay a couple of bills. Because I have to think in advance, okay, if we have enough to pay for this and that before the next paycheck comes in. So, basically, we were living paycheck to paycheck. We stressed ourselves financially. Okay, the baby crying, I was trying to pay the bills. And I spent a lot to pay a couple of bills. This is, something’s wrong here. It’s not right. So I was, yeah. From there. Okay. Let’s make a decision to tackle this issue from the cause. Yeah. I was struggling and sad, and then I had nobody else to turn to. And I would say, let’s do this. I don’t want to wait any longer. Let’s do it. Our lifestyle will change, no more shopping, no more eating out. Let’s do this. If we do this, we can do this in under 10 years. In 10 years, we will be a whole new person, a new family, and then life will be much better.

22:29 Emily: And is that how you felt when you, you know, sent off the last payment?

22:33 Dr. 50: I felt relief. Okay, I don’t have to make all these calculations and then try to predict the future if my paycheck will be the same or if we will have any unexpected expenses. But I was like, Oh, well, okay, now we are definitely, the debt is gone. I still, so surprisingly, I still felt the same. It wasn’t the financial that I was looking for. I feel I miss something. We were missing something, but I couldn’t put a word to it until I found the FIRE movement.

Discovering the FIRE Movement

23:16 Emily: Yeah. So FIRE, acronym for financial independence and early retirement or retire early. Would you please explain for my audience, you know, your version of what FIRE is and why that spoke to you, and why you decided to pursue it?

23:31 Dr. 50: Yeah. So, before I knew it was a thing I always, Oh, wait, I don’t want to work. I don’t want to do this for the next 40 years. I mean, I only get one take on this planet. I want to do something that really matters, really matters to me and to my family, and really matters, that I am passionate about. I don’t want to spend my 40 years doing this. So, but I didn’t know what that feeling was until I met the FIRE movement, which you already said stands for financial independence, retire early. So, at this point, I want to be financially independent. The retire early can come back later. So, to me, FIRE means that you don’t have to worry about money anymore, meaning you don’t have to be worried about making a living, making money to support your lifestyle, your life. I mean, you can spend your time doing what really matters. To me, I really have a passion about helping animals in need, dogs and cats at the shelter. So, I really want to pursue that.

Commercial

24:50 Emily: Emily here for a brief interlude. This announcement is for prospective and first-year graduate students. My colleague, Dr. Toyin Alli of The Academic Society, offers a fantastic course just for you called Grad School Prep. The course teaches you Toyin’s four-step Grad Boss method, which is to uncover grad school secrets, transform your mindset, up-level your productivity, and master time management. I contributed a very comprehensive webinar to the course titled Set Yourself Up for Financial Success in Graduate School. It explores the financial norms of grad school and the financial secrets of grad school. I also give you a plan for what to focus on in your finances in each season of the year that you apply to and into your first year of grad school. If this all sounds great to you, please register at theacademicsociety.com/Emily for Toyin’s free masterclass on what to expect in your first semester of grad school, and the three big mistakes that keep grad students stuck in a cycle of anxiety, overwhelm, and procrastination. You’ll also learn more about how to join Grad School Prep, if you’d like to go a step further. Again, that’s theacademic society.com/E M I L Y for my affiliate link for the course. Now, back to our interview.

Striving for Financial Independence

26:18 Emily: It sounds like when you were heavily in consumer debt and you had your mortgage, you were stressed out and you thought that it was because you were playing this paycheck-to-paycheck game, right? Which is super common, that you have to really figure out, you know, when things can be paid so you have money in the bank to do it and all that. But then, once you got out of that level of stress, you said you still kind of felt the same. And so it sounds like you realized that it wasn’t just the paycheck to paycheck game. It was that you had to have a paycheck at all. You wanted to be freed of needing to work to support your lifestyle.

26:53 Dr. 50: Exactly. Yes. I still felt the same. I was surprised. Oh my gosh. I should just be, feel very happy. Definitely I felt relieved, but it wasn’t the happiness that I was looking for. And then, yeah, I just don’t want to have any paychecks at all. I just want to have my money working for me instead of working for the money. I had been working for the money for a long time, and I don’t want to work for the money anymore.

27:19 Emily: I see. Can you give us a little bit of more of the technicalities of how FIRE works, at least in your example? Like, do you have a number that you’re shooting for, and what are the strategies that you’re using to get to that point?

27:31 Dr. 50: Yes. I have several options. So, because my older child and my husband had a chronic disease that the health insurance is the other issue, but yeah, I have a couple options here. So, the first option would be, we accumulate enough money that we can live off the investments, mainly to live off the dividends or the 4% rules. If you Google 4% rules, you will know what it is.

FIRE: The 4% Rule

28:03 Emily: Yeah. I’ll just say for the listener that there’s kind of a rule of thumb in the FIRE movement, which is that if you are supporting yourself through paper assets, stocks and bonds and so forth, the rule is that you save up, invest, 25 times your expected spending level in your retirement, or if that’s what you’re doing, and that you can withdraw 4% per year from your portfolio over the long-term without endangering, you know, that you’re going to draw it down to zero. That’s a really brief explanation. There’s a lot more underneath that, but that’s the gist of the 4% rule.

28:40 Dr. 50: Yes. So, the first option would just live off the 4% rules and everybody will be staying home and taking care of the kids. So, I just had a baby this year, so yeah, the FIRE just came back to me again. And then the second option would be like my husband keeps working. So, we will have the health insurance that we desperately need. And I would be at home and taking care of the baby. And then the third option would be to move to another country that has the universal health insurance. So, we would get that issue covered, and then we’d just live off of the investment.

29:20 Emily: Yeah. So, which one is your plan A?

29:23 Dr. 50: My plan A is the option two. So, have him keep working so we don’t have to move. And then, because by that time they’d be about to get close to the number. The younger one was still be in elementary school. So, would be just like six or seven years old.

29:40 Emily: Okay. And I think this, you know, this health insurance thing that you brought up is something that is such a big conversation in the FIRE movement in the United States, not necessarily elsewhere. And there are plenty of people who are keeping jobs, not because they need the money, but just because health insurance or the risk that you take, if you went on certain kinds of health insurance plans, is so great here. So, it sounds like either your husband will keep working, or maybe at some point we will have a universal option and then that’ll give you a lot more flexibility.

30:11 Dr. 50: Yes, that’s true. Yeah. If you have that flexibility, that would be great. He doesn’t mind working at all. He loves working. So, I’m really grateful for that.

Federal Retirement Benefits

30:21 Emily: Since you’re a federal government employee, do you have a pension? Or do you have like defined contribution plans, or what’s the deal with your retirement?

30:30 Dr. 50: Yes, I do have a pension that is very, very small. So, let’s say if I worked for 30 years plus if you meet MRA, MRA stands for minimal retirement age, if you meet 30 years at your minimum retirement age, you will get 1% of your high three of your salary. The high three is your last three years of your salary. Let’s say, to make the math easier, if you make a hundred thousand a year for the last three years before you resign. So, 1% of that, and times 30 years, so it’s only $30,000 a year, plus tax and all the deduction, it wouldn’t be much. And we have a 401(k), like any other industry, but what we call it TSP. TSP stands for Thrift Savings Plans. So, it works just like 401(k), but it’s just called differently.

Investment Changes Toward  Achieving the FIRE Goal

31:39 Emily: And since you already went through that massive debt payoff journey before discovering the FIRE movement, was there anything that you actually started changing in your finances once you had that identified as your goal?

31:52 Dr. 50: Yes. I’m glad that you asked that question. So, it changed dramatically. So, I’ve always been maxing out my 401(k), or my TSP, every year. Okay. So, we agreed as a family that we’re going to pursue FIRE. Let’s do something different. Because if I keep my job, if I still continue trying to do a traditional retirement, I would work into my MRA at 57 or 60 years. And if you want to pursue FIRE, we need to fill a gap between that because I cannot take the money out until 59 and a half. So that gap, we cannot draw our 401(k) or any retirement account. So, we opened a broker’s account and instead of maxing out my 401(k) and his 401(k), we just contribute to the match just enough to get the match from our employer. And then divert all the money from that into the brokerage account, the taxable account.

33:00 Emily: So, that sounds like you felt like your post-60 retirement was well-funded enough. And I mean, you’re still going to get the match, so there’s still more growth and a little bit more contribution there, but it sounded like you thought that that was well-funded enough. So, now you’re going to focus on those years between whenever you do stop working and when you can start to access those retirement accounts.

33:21 Dr. 50: Yes. It would be about 10 years. So, the “50” came from, I would like to retire by the time I turn 50. Yeah, so, 10 years I calculated it. All the expenses in the future. I came up with the numbers that we have to have at least $600,000, or $600,000 to be okay, that’s the lean FIRE. If you want to get more comfortable, I say $750,000. That will get up to be better than lean FIRE. Lean FIRE is just like, minimal, barely enough to live on.

34:00 Emily: Anything else that you changed aside from the destination of your investments?

34:05 Dr. 50: Yeah, that’s the one thing. And then we also, any leftover money that we can save, any activity that we cannot pass by, like re-doing our budget, do the meal plan. Budget system number one and meal planning, not going out, basically just frugal living. And then I started a side business. Anything that I can sell. And as a family we like, talk, okay, this is the goal that we want to do. And everybody was on board and yeah. Every little thing, side hustles, living frugally, anything will go to the FIRE account.

Lifestyle and Money Mindset Pre- vs. Post-Grad School

34:54 Emily: How does, how you’re living now–you know, frugally and so forth, saving a lot, working hard–how does that compare to that pre-grad school period, or even the time when you were in graduate school, and you had that heavy workload? I guess I’m asking, how does your lifestyle compare, and also how do you feel about your finances now compared to back then?

35:18 Dr. 50: I would say I feel a little bit better. Because back in the day, we were struggling financially trying to put food on the table, trying to pay rent and then trying to pay the mortgage. Right now, we’ve comfortably more than enough to pay all the expenses, living expenses and mortgage, everything is on auto pay. I didn’t have to worry about if we have enough money. If the bill comes in, if we have a roof leak, if we have a broken pipe, we have emergency funds. So yes, my feeling was much better, but financially I was still trying to meet my financial goal, which is the financial independence. So it’s a different feeling, but I would say a different feeling kind of between struggle and the finish line, I would say.

36:14 Emily: So, sort of like struggling to get off the starting blocks. Right? To even make it, you know, to have a tiny bit of financial security, versus now, like you just said, you can see the finish line. You’re striving and you’re racing for that finish line. And yeah, I would imagine that, even if your lifestyle is pretty low, like you’ve tried to like be pretty frugal and stuff, having that financial security of the, you know, X, many hundreds of thousands of dollars, you know, in the bank and the investments, it has to be a massive, massive relief on your mind.

36:49 Dr. 50: Yes. Yeah. It would be a relief because right now we trying, I would say we are in an accumulation phase trying to get as much money into the FIRE as much as possible, as soon as possible. But at the same time, I just don’t want to stress myself out. Because one thing that I learned from our debt-free journey, our debt journey was like, because at the end of the day, you just want to be happy, right? The money doesn’t make you happy. You just need to learn to live in the moment, even though you are trying to achieve something or aim for something, but overall you just want to be happy and just trying to live in the day. I just don’t want to stress out too much because during our debt journey, I was so stressed out. I just wanted to be out of debt so badly. I just didn’t want to spend at all.

37:47 Dr. 50: And I wasn’t happy. And when we were debt-free, I still wasn’t happy. Now, we are on the FIRE path, FIRE journey. I just don’t want to be the same. I just want to enjoy a little bit more of my life. I just want to stop and breathe and enjoy every single day. I just don’t want to wait, because if you wait, you will feel depressed. And if you ever feel like it will never come. So yes, I take it easy and just live in the day. And that day will come before you know it.

Was the PhD Financially Worthwhile?

38:24 Emily: I’m really glad to hear you say that. That’s a message I need to hear. I need to hear that and be able to focus on living in the moment more and not striving. And I’m really glad to hear you say that because I know that some people in the FIRE movement do stay very caught up in the end goal. And even though sort of the philosophy around FIRE would be to be living in the moment both while you’re pursuing it and once you’ve achieved it, a lot of people do fall into just thinking about the future and living for the future and you know, not taking the time to enjoy the time they have at the moment, which is all we have. Right? Really. So, I’m really glad to hear that you’ve, based on your debt free journey, you’ve already learned that lesson. And you’re now, you know, beyond that and into still enjoying your life even while you’re pursuing FIRE. So, I’m really pleased to hear that. Do you think the PhD was financially worthwhile?

39:14 Dr. 50: Oh, yes. In my case, for me. For me, it was worthwhile. I am glad that I made the right decision to pursue a PhD because it’s opened so many doors for us. If I were working at my minimum wage job at a factory, or I was afraid to take the risk of not having any paycheck and then just went straight to grad school without any backup plan. We wouldn’t be here today. Yes. It was very worthwhile. Yeah.

Best Financial Advice for an Early-Career PhD

39:47 Emily: Yes. I can see that clearly from the story now. And so, Dr. 50, I conclude all my interviews by asking my guest what is your best financial advice for an early-career PhD? That could be something we’ve talked about already. It could be something completely different, but would you please share that with us?

40:04 Dr. 50: Yeah, sure. I say, from my past experience as a PhD graduate, you feel like, Oh my gosh, I have a PhD behind my name now. I make a ton of money. Even though it’s not a ton, I would say, it’s increased your income. My one piece of advice would be trying to live the same. Don’t let the life inflation get you. Because if you do that, it will be never enough. I mean, it’s how much you make, how advancing your career brings you. It will not be enough. You just, if you just keep inflating your lifestyle. I’m not saying that you should be conscious as a graduate student, but on the back of your mind, trying to do like other peers are doing. I’m not saying like, you should live this way, but yeah. Lifestyle inflation, it really hurts your financial life.

40:59 Emily: Yeah. And it definitely sounds like you were there, you did that for a little while. I like to say, don’t inflate your lifestyle, but increase your lifestyle. Increase it intentionally, mindfully. But don’t, yeah. Don’t just let it float up to, you know, whatever your salary is.

41:16 Dr. 50: Yes.

41:17 Emily: Yes. I love that advice. Thank you so much. Dr. 50, it’s been a real pleasure talking to you. Thank you so much for joining me on the podcast.

41:22 Dr. 50: Oh, thank you so much. I’m glad to be here. And I’m so honored to be on this podcast. I am. I hope that my life lesson and experience will be helpful to you guys in some way, some small way. Thank you so much for having me here.

Listener Q&A: Financial Independence

41:42 Emily: Now on to the listener question and answer segment. Today’s question was asked in advance of a live webinar I gave recently for a university client. So, it is anonymous. Here is the question. Quote, can you start a journey to financial independence in grad school. End quote. Wow. It is awesome that this person is already thinking about long-term financial independence as a graduate student. The answer is, unequivocally, yes. In fact, if you’d like to think about it this way, you have already started your journey to financial independence in grad school, because you are making a long-term investment in your career, and presumably, your earning potential. While FIRE is achievable in theory by anyone, it’s definitely an easier road if you have a good salary. So, in that sense, if getting a graduate degree is going to put you on a road to a good salary, you’re already pursuing financial independence. Now, what can you do while you’re actually in graduate school to pursue financial independence?

42:46 Emily: No matter what your income, you can work on your mindset. You can learn more about personal finance. You can put strong habits into place, which you’ll definitely need during graduate school, like budgeting and frugality. Your income is always going to be rather low during grad school, but that’s not the only side of the equation when it comes to financial independence. Your expenses matter a lot as well. I would say, during this period of time, when your income is suppressed, you should take the time to master the controlling expenses side of the equation. But that’s not all. Even with a lower income during grad school, you can work on increasing your net worth. This is what I put a lot of focus on when I was in graduate school. Tactically, once you have your budget set up and hopefully a bit of free cashflow, you can put that towards saving, debt repayment, or investing, following, like I’ve talked about in recent weeks, the financial framework that I developed for PhDs.

43:43 Emily: Now, here’s one key concept that might not have occurred to you yet. While you’re in graduate school and you have this lower income, you also have a lower tax rate. Graduate students tend to, unless they’re married to someone with a much higher income, top out in the 12% federal marginal tax bracket or lower. And that means that it is a perfect time to use a Roth IRA for your retirement investments. Especially, again, if you anticipate a large income increase postgraduate school, this is probably the most optimal time in your life to be using a Roth IRA. And presumably it’s also the earliest investing you’ll do, so it has the longest timeline to compound and grow. People are crazy for the Roth IRA, and they will contribute even when they’re in incredibly high tax bracket. So, you really have, if you think about it, a great opportunity to be able to contribute to the Roth IRA without paying a high tax rate. And five years or so investing in a Roth IRA and then decades compounding after that, this will be a very big portion of your portfolio, ultimately, even if you don’t contribute in absolute numbers a lot of money during grad school. Thank you so much for this question, Anonymous, and I’m so glad to learn that you are already on your journey to financial independence. If you’d like to submit a question to be answered in a future episode, please go to pfforphds.com/podcast and follow the instructions you find there. I love answering questions, so please submit yours.

Outtro

45:18 Emily: Listeners, thank you for joining me for this episode. Pfforphds.com/podcast is the hub for the Personal Finance for PhDs Podcast. On that page are links to all the episode show notes, which include full transcripts and videos of the interviews. There is also a form to volunteer to be interviewed on the podcast, and instructions for entering the book giveaway contest and submitting a question for the Q&A segment. I’d love for you to check it out and get more involved. If you’ve been enjoying the podcast, here are four ways you can help it grow. One, subscribe to the podcast and rate and review it on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, or whatever platform you use. If you leave a review, be sure to send it to me. Two, share an episode you found particularly valuable on social media, with an email listserv, or as a link from your website. Three, recommend me as a speaker to your university or association. My seminars cover the personal finance topics PhDs are most interested in, like investing, debt repayment, and taxes. Four, subscribe to my mailing list at pfforphds.com/subscribe. Through that list, you’ll keep up with all the new content and special opportunities for Personal Finance for PhDs. See you in the next episode! And remember you don’t have to have a PhD to succeed with personal finance, but it helps. The music is Stages of Awakening by Podington bear from the free music archive and is shared under CC by NC. Podcast editing and show notes creation by Meryem Ok.

  • Go to page 1
  • Go to page 2
  • Go to Next Page »

Footer

Sign Up for More Awesome Content

I'll send you my 2,500-word "Five Ways to Improve Your Finances TODAY as a Graduate Student or Postdoc."

Success! Now check your email to confirm your subscription.

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by Kit

Copyright © 2025 · Atmosphere Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

  • About Emily Roberts
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact