Taxes

Your Side Hustle Really Is a Business and Other Tax Insights with Hannah Cole of Sunlight Tax

September 23, 2024 by Jill Hoffman

In this episode, Emily interviews Hannah Cole, an artist and the founder of Sunlight Tax. Sunlight Tax primarily serves artists and creatives in their business tax needs, but there are many overlaps between artists and the academic community. Hannah and Emily discuss the best practices and insights that graduate students, postdocs, and PhDs with side businesses need to stay on the IRS’s good side. Hannah clarifies exactly when a business starts, the first step you must take with your finances, and how to calculate and pay your additional tax liability.

Links mentioned in the Episode

Your Side Hustle Really Is a Business and Other Tax Insights with Hannah Cole of Sunlight Tax

Teaser

Hannah (00:00): You know, we have a whole tax industry out there trying to, you know, its marketing is based around making us all hate and fear our taxes and actually kind of implicitly training us not to even look at it, to just feel so fearful. And so, like, hands off that we don’t even look at it. And I’m just here to say I hate that. I disagree with it.

Introduction

Emily (00:29): Welcome to the Personal Finance for PhDs Podcast: A Higher Education in Personal Finance. This podcast is for PhDs and PhDs-to-be who want to explore the hidden curriculum of finances to learn the best practices for money management, career advancement, and advocacy for yourself and others. I’m your host, Dr. Emily Roberts, a financial educator specializing in early-career PhDs and founder of Personal Finance for PhDs.

Emily (00:58): This is Season 19, Episode 3, and today my guest is Hannah Cole, an artist and the founder of Sunlight Tax. Sunlight Tax primarily serves artists and creatives in their business tax needs, but there are many overlaps between artists and the academic community. Hannah and I discuss the best practices and insights that graduate students, postdocs, and PhDs with side businesses need to stay on the IRS’s good side. Hannah clarifies exactly when a business starts, the first step you must take with your finances, and how to calculate and pay your additional tax liability. This whole episode is devoted to business taxes, but before we get started I want to ask you if you or your peers need help figuring out taxes on your academic income, your graduate student stipend or postdoc salary and the attendant benefits. Now is actually the best time to start the conversation with your graduate school, postdoc office, graduate student association, etc. about bringing my tax content to your university in the upcoming tax season—so that they have time to plan their budgets. In this upcoming tax season I’m offering live workshops that I will tailor to your university and state and also pre-recorded workshops that are widely applicable. I would be very grateful if you would issue a recommendation to a potentially appropriate host at your university. You can find links to more information from PFforPhDs.com/financial-education/. Thank you! You can find the show notes for this episode at PFforPhDs.com/s19e3/. Without further ado, here’s my interview with Hannah Cole of Sunlight Tax.

Will You Please Introduce Yourself Further?

Emily (02:56): I have a really special guest on the podcast today, Hannah Cole of Sunlight Tax. I have been listening to Hannah’s podcast, Sunlight, the Sunlight podcast for, I don’t know, definitely more than a year now, maybe closer to two. And she is an amazing, uh, podcaster and practitioner in her field because she teaches about taxes to her community. I’m gonna have her introduce her community to you, but I see a lot of overlap between Hannah’s community and our community of academics and PhDs and graduate students and so forth. So Hannah is really gonna be able to bring her insight into taxes and specifically self-employment taxes to our conversation today. Um, which is going to focus on self-employment situations that grad students and postdocs are typically in, which is like a self-employment side hustle. So Hannah, thank you so much for agreeing to come on the podcast. I’m really excited. Will you please introduce yourself a little bit further for our audience.

Hannah (03:48): Sure. Um, thank you so much, Emily. I appreciate it. Um, yeah, so I am an artist first. I, I went and got my MFA in painting. Um, and I have a degree in art history and, uh, started my life as a professional artist and was so upset at how I was treated by the world of accounting <laugh> by my dad’s accountant that eventually I, you know, went out to get the information on my own. I went all the way back to school for accounting and studied taxes. Um, ’cause I live with a, you know, artists are solitary creatures. You know, you, when you’re a painter like me, you’re in the studio for long, long hours alone. And the only way to build your career is through a network. So, you know, we are like, uh, super networkers and my community of artists was deeply in need of the same information that I was. And I, I like, knew there was a need out there, and I was like, I’m so upset by the way that this has been delivered to me, if at all. Um, there’s, there’s a market here. Um, so I started my business Sunlight Tax. Um, and that’s my mission is to, it’s much, it’s much bigger of an audience than just creative people, but it is really kind of for people who maybe where money is not the sole interest that they have when they do the thing they do. Right. And I think as academics, you can probably relate to that because most people who go into academics have a passion for their field. Right. They’re trying to do some research, and that probably is a little bit primary over money. And so, you know, that’s very similar to artists that’s very similar to sort of mission-driven people. So it’s kind of a big group of people where money is not the only thing, but these people need to do their taxes too.

Similarities Between Academics and Creatives

Emily (05:37): Yes. I see so much of an overlap between how you described your journey to what you do today, uh, in the tax world, at any rate, and what I do with, uh, as being a financial educator. Yeah. Um, I love you sort of got started comparing the community that you come from the artist community with the academic community. I totally agree about those, um, overlaps. Are there any, would you like to elaborate on that in any way? Specifically? I’m thinking of are there like mindsets or like skills that you’ve observed or perhaps lack of skills among your community, um, perhaps that overlap with ours that either are, um, helpful or not so helpful when it comes to running a business, which some academics end up doing.

Hannah (06:16): Yeah. Well, I’m, the, the world of academia is not foreign to me. I mean, I taught, I was a professor, uh, at Boston University for a brief moment, <laugh> before I realized that I, I, uh, the, the strictures of academia were not, not for me. I think for people like us, when you’re, when your identity is formed around a passion for a thing, um, money can become the enemy by accident. Not really on purpose usually. But I think, um, I see a parallel between people in creative fields where, you know, there’s no artist in the world who’s gonna tell you that they do anything except make the best possible art they can. Right. And I think the same is true in academia. You’re gonna do the best, highest quality research you possibly can. You’re gonna, you know, whether that’s the most innovative or, you know, you’ve got the best ideas, the best protocols, whatever, however you’re doing it. And I think when that’s the case, you can kind of lose, you know, what you focus on is what does well, and if your focus comes off of money, too much money can get, uh, it can atrophy, right? Your skills in it can atrophy. Um, when your attention is not there, you just, uh, it can kind of get away from you. Right? And so I think that that is a sort of similar issue that, um, people in academia have to people in the creative world. Um, and I think just, you know, we’re busy, right? We’re busy doing the thing, we’re doing <laugh>, and this is one of the reasons I didn’t wanna be in academia ’cause of how busy you get <laugh>. Like, I was like, I, I’m never gonna be in the studio again if I do this. Um, and, and you just, it’s hard to check like, you know, self-employment, you know, when you’re talking about like grant income or the types of income that, that we’re talking about here, like track doing, doing, setting up bookkeeping, paying estimated quarterly taxes, like things like that. You know, they are a little bit complex and they do require some ongoing attention. So that’s, that’s a challenge.

Emily (08:23): Totally agree with everything you just said. Underline that. Um, in addition, I wonder if you could speak to, because I think another commonality between these communities is a percep- a perception among ourselves that our work is undervalued by other people and then we end up undervaluing ourselves in some cases, um, which is really dangerous when it comes to business ownership

Hannah (08:45): Very much. Yeah. And I think it’s, it, it’s easy to get into a mindset like that, especially if people around you in your daily life have a mindset like that. You tend to absorb the attitudes of the people you are with all day. Um, and so yeah, if you have people around you who feel like, uh, you know, the good ideas are over here and the money is over here and they’re in opposite directions, you’re gonna start getting outta balance where with, where money is in your life, like, I, I like to think of it this way, that money is neutral, right? Money is a tool. It’s like a hammer. You can do good things with it. You can do bad things with it, right? Like it’s amplifying the power of the person who has it. So if you’re doing good work, if you’re an ethical person, you can do amazing things and you can do more of them when you have more money. I don’t know. Think, um, think Oprah, think, um, Dolly Parton, you know, these are people who have great amounts of wealth and who do truly world changing wonderful things with their money, right? Uh, we could also probably think of quite a few examples of people who do not so great things with their money <laugh>. But I think the problem is when you go from thinking of money as neutral, right? Money as just being an amplifier of your agency to being negative, that that’s where you start getting problems. You start getting in a sort of stuck space around it. Because if you think of money as negative, or if you think that somehow your motives or ethics will be corrupted, if you simply have money more of this tool, you won’t advocate for yourself properly, right? Um, you cannot walk into a job interview and really nail it, um, nail the salary negotiation part of it specifically. Um, you’re not gonna advocate the way with the fierceness in that interview that you would if you believed that money was good, right? Or, or money in your hands was a good thing. If you fundamentally think, you know, having a fully funded retirement is makes you kind of a yucky person, you’re not gonna ever fund your retirement. You know, these things are related.

How Do You Know When You’ve Actually Started a Business?

Emily (10:55): Mm-Hmm. That is so interesting. I’m really, I really like the way you put that. I haven’t thought about it quite that way before. So thank you so much. Um, okay. I wanna narrow down to talking about like business ownership for, again, my community, which has many similarities with yours. Uh, they’re gonna be doing this as a, we’re gonna say a side income though, right? They have their primary thing as being a graduate student or being a postdoc, and they’re pursuing that, but they have a self-employment side hustle as well. Oftentimes what I see is people acting as like consultants, for example. Um, or maybe they’re a writer or an editor in, in this kind of world. So these, these kinds of side hustles, whether maybe, or data science. They’re employing some skills perhaps that they have developed as an academic, but outside of that academic context as a business owner. So, and I love that you’ve talked about this extensively on your podcast, but the question to you is how does someone know when they’ve actually started a business? Because especially when it’s something on the side, it may be a little vague at first.

Hannah (11:50): Yeah. This gets really confusing if you start thinking of the other organizations that think of your business start time as different. Um, and I, I do have a whole podcast episode about specifically when each one thinks you start. Um, so if you want me to, you know, link to that in your show notes, I would be happy to send that link. Um, but, you know, that’s on the Sunlight podcast. So to the IRS and this, you know, I’m a tax person, so I’m orienting towards that. When it comes to when you report the income, when you report the expenses, um, to the IRS, your, your business begins the moment you advertise. And that actually makes a lot of sense if you understand what makes you a business. The IRS says that you’re a business versus being a hobby. Um, so your side hustle is a business and not a hobby. If you have a profit motive, if you are trying to make money with it, right? It doesn’t mean that money has to be, you know, you worship at the altar of money and there’s nothing else in your life and you throw all your ethics and your, you know, value and, and your amazing work out the window. Not that, but it has to be in there, has to be in the mix, and it has to be, you know, strong. Um, and so if you think about that, having an intent to make a profit, which is the IRS definition of you being a business that happens before you make a profit, that happens before you make money. And I think this is where people get confused. They think, I I, I, I only get to report it once I’m making money, but actually no, because you start that business with expenses, right? You have expenses first. Then once you’ve built something, um, let’s use an example of like a pizzeria. ’cause it’s very tangible and we’ve all been to one. Um, you don’t start generating income from that pizzeria day one, right? The pizzeria has to exist first. Like, you can’t sell a slice of pizza if you don’t have an oven <laugh>. You have to install the oven, you have to have a bakery, you have to have flour, right? So you’re gonna have a lot of expenses before you ever can even bring a dollar in the door. And I think it’s really important to get your head around that concept. You are not broken because that’s how your business is working. That’s actually normal, right? And we have in business school, they teach this concept called the break even point. Well, what is that? The break even point is the magical moment when you go from negative income, AKA, AKA spending <laugh> and, and, um, it’s that magical moment when you go from negative income to zero, right? And then over the zero, then the number starts getting positive. That’s the moment you become profitable, right? When your, when your income rises above the amount of your expenses for the first time, and you know what, there is no guarantee or promise that that will ever happen or that it will happen on a certain timeline. That’s all within your control and your profit motive should be driving that bus. But, uh, it’s, it’s good to know that it’s normal to have expenses first. And in fact, you’re entitled to file a Schedule C that is where you put this stuff on your tax return. You’re entitled to file one before you have a profit. So the title of the Schedule C is profit or loss from business. So one, you have to be a business, it’s in the title, but also you don’t have to have a profit that’s also in the title. So that’s kind of a good baseline. So remember, the moment you advertise, and if you think about it is, is the moment that you start that your business starts. And if you think about it, that makes sense. ’cause advertising says hello world, hello clients, I’m open, I have this thing available. If you’re the right person, if this will work for you, come and get it. Right? But also, you know, to somebody who is, let’s say, doing some freelance editing on the side, advertising is not gonna look the way it does for Coca-Cola, right? Advertising for you is probably gonna be an email to a couple of friends and family. You’re still advertising. You probably aren’t thinking of that as advertising, but whatever you do that’s signaling, Hey, hey, I do this thing, are you interested? So maybe that’s an Instagram post. Maybe it’s an email to friends and family. Um, maybe it’s a website going live. Those are all your moment when you started advertising.

Emily (16:14): I’m so glad you gave that example because as I said earlier, I see a lot of like service-based businesses as side hustles, um, for this community. And so just when you were describing that, I was like, yeah, if you put something up on LinkedIn, if you put your services out there on, um, whatever the current version of Upwork is, um, or like you said, an email to a friend putting up a website, Hey, it costs money to host a website. So like, you’re probably having your first expense when you do that. Um, or maybe you’re starting to pay for software to like get client scheduling set up or whatever it might be. Um, I think part of the confusion when people are asking this question is they think somehow it’s like a, a bad or like an onerous thing to be considered a business and have the attendant tax filing, uh, requirements along with it.

Emily (16:57): But what I really learned from your podcast and your attitude around it is no, this is a great thing to be considered a business, especially as you were just saying, when it takes some time to get to that turning point where you actually have profit. So like, if you have a whole year when you have some, some loss, even though you’ve started advertising, maybe you have some expenses, the income isn’t there yet. Um, you can use that to reduce your tax liability, actually. And so it’s not, it’s not a bad thing to be considered a business earlier. It does have some complications, but it’s, it’s, it’s actually a very positive thing to realize that you have a business

Hannah (17:29): Very much. I mean, and it, it tangibly lowers your taxes. <laugh>. I mean, we in this country are supporting business not out of a charitable purpose, but because it’s good for the u- US economy, right? Like when we support us small businesses and, and we count, you and me, Emily, we count <laugh>. Um, when you support a small business, you are, you are helping the US GDP grow, right? That’s in the interest of the nation we live in. Um, ultimately, you know, you’re gonna spend a lot of money, you get business deduction, you get business expenses, they are deductible on your tax return. That’s a incredible benefit given to you by Uncle Sam. I mean, I, I don’t think we all appreciate that quite as much as we should. Um, but that’s, that’s huge. Um, and yeah, and so you’re, you’re getting this subsidy <laugh> and it’s nice to take advantage of. It’s nice to know what your rights are and take advantage of it. Um, and of course, if you weren’t a business, if you were operating as a hobby, instead you wouldn’t get those deductions. So there’s a real difference.

Emily (18:38): Yeah. Thank you.

Commercial

Emily (18:41): Emily here for a brief interlude. Would you like to learn directly from me on a personal finance topic, such as taxes, budgeting, investing, and goal-setting, each tailored specifically for graduate students and postdocs? I offer workshops on these topics and more in a variety of formats, and I’m now booking for the 2024-2025 academic year. If you would like to bring my content to your institution, would you please recommend me as a speaker or facilitator to your university, graduate school, graduate student association, or postdoc office? My seminars are usually slated as professional development or personal wellness. Ask the potential host to go to PFforPhDs.com/financial-education/ or simply email me at [email protected] to start the process. I really appreciate these recommendations, which are the best way for me to start a conversation with a potential host. The paid work I do with universities and institutes enables me to keep producing this podcast and all my other free resources. Thank you in advance if you decide to issue a recommendation! Now back to our interview.

Best Financial Practices for Early Career Academics With Businesses

Emily (19:59): Okay. So I’m thinking still about this grad student or postdoc or early career PhD who’s, has this business now they know they’re starting it on the side. What are some best practices that they should implement in their finances from day one to make things easier or like totally above board going forward?

Hannah (20:16): Sure. Um, the first is to open a separate bank account. Um, you wanna keep your business income and expenses separated from your personal bank account and personal expenses. Um, there’s many reasons why this is a good idea. All of it is a good idea. <laugh>, there is no negative, um, except that you have to go through the effort of opening an account. Um, but the magic that that separation does is now when you have that business bank account and you deposit all the money you earn from that freelance side hustle, you know, that gig, whatever it is, now you are creating a record of everything into and out of your business. That record becomes the backbone of your bookkeeping. So now from there, setting up bookkeeping, setting up tracking becomes far simpler. Um, Emily, when I started out as a professional artist, before I knew to do all this stuff, I was printing out bank statements going through, you know, like three days before tax time, going through my bank statement, line by line with a highlighter, trying to, trying to recall if that trip I made back in February last year to Lowe’s was for business or for my home, right? <laugh>, Like we don’t want that <laugh>. If you have a dedicated business account and you keep a mindset of I only spend this money on business expenses, then everything in there is deductible. You just have to sort out what category of deduction it goes into. So man, it makes your life simple. And then, you know, once your business grows, this is a thing that grows with you. Um, you can automate that bank feed into bookkeeping software. That’s a next step thing. You don’t have to do that day one, but it gives you the, you know, the easy option. Um, also if you one day create an LLC for liability protection, your LLC will be instantly invalidated if you don’t have a separate business bank account, you, when you have a liability, uh, limited liability corporation, the whole thing you’ve done legally is to separate your business and personal selves. And if you then don’t actually do it in the background, a court of law can say you don’t have an LLC, you don’t have any liability protection, and basically your LLC is thrown out, you’ve wasted all that money. Um, so <laugh>, there’s no downside, in other words, to a business bank account. PS it doesn’t actually have to be technically a business account according to your bank’s rules. It can just be a personal account. That’s another separate account. It’s the separation that’s important. So it can be, you know, technically a personal account according to the bank. That’s fine. Just use it like it’s your business account.

Emily (23:05): Thank you so much for that. Um, that clarification, and actually you threw out a couple of terms there. So I just want to, this is partially some things I’ve learned from you, clarify for the listener. Um, this, this term LLC, the limited liability company, this is a legal status and it’s not, it doesn’t necessarily confer a specific tax status. So when you’re first starting out out, when you’re first starting out with a, a side business or something, you’re likely gonna be operating as a sole proprietor. Then maybe for the entire lifetime of the business, you’ll be a sole proprietor. Whether or not you open an LLC as well, your tax status will stay a sole proprietor. That is, unless you decide that you want to grow your business to the point where becoming a different kind of tax status would make sense, like an S selection, et cetera. But for people who keep businesses on the side, I would imagine many of them continue to operate as sole proprietors indefinitely.

Hannah (23:55): Yep. I would say that’s probably true. Yeah.

Preparing for Tax Season as a Business Owner

Emily (23:58): So you just mentioned this core first step, which is to open a separate bank account, and I totally agree with it. You know, when I first started out my very first side hustle, I didn’t have that, but I knew by the time I started this business that it was important. So that was the first thing that I did when I started this, um, this business, even though I’ve been a sole proprietor the whole time as we were just talking about. So is there anything else that someone should do, um, like at this point in the year, you know, we’re sitting in September when we’re recording this. Is there anyone, anything that, uh, business owners should do outside of their actions during tax season to set themselves up to, you know, prepare a tax to return easily to minimize their tax liability beyond this core, as you said, the backbone of having a separate account?

Hannah (24:39): I mean, there’s a whole world of year-end tax planning. I would say independent of year-end tax planning, which is coming up, we are coming upon that time of year. But independent of that, I would say from your separate business bank account, just setting up some basic bookkeeping is a good idea. Having the separate bank account isn’t bookkeeping itself, though. It forms a basis for it. So if you don’t love the idea of like sitting with your bank statements and pulling everything into a category, you know, before tax time, doing that in advance is quite nice and quite helpful. <laugh>. And I actually think if it’s at the level of a gig or a side hustle, I actually think you don’t need bookkeeping software at all. I think bookkeeping software, if I’m just being totally honest with you, it’s very easy to make very expensive mistakes that compound and, uh, that you can only get undone with very expensive accounting help. Um, so I actually don’t really think people with very, very small like side hustle level businesses maybe even should have software for bookkeeping at all. Um, but that doesn’t mean you do bookkeeping. You can just do it on a spreadsheet. So have a spreadsheet, lay out your expense categories, track your income, and just do the tallies. Um, because knowing if that will help, you know, in an ongoing way if you’re profitable or not, which is a, a big deal, it’s also what your taxes are based on. So, um, paying estimated quarterly taxes, for example, if you need to, is only going to be possible when you know what the number is, <laugh>. Um, so you wanna be able to know what your profit was for the quarter. So you can do a little calculation about what percentage of that you need to pay to the IRS and to your state for taxes.

Side Hustles and Estimated Tax

Emily (26:29): This is a little bit nuanced. Um, what I’d like to specifically talk about is how to like sort of add the estimated tax process on top of an existing salary, right? Because this is a side hustle business, so. What would you tell someone who’s, uh, who has that situation, how they should handle their estimated tax?

Hannah (26:50): Yeah, I might tell them to avoid it altogether. Um, honestly, because human behavior being what it is, estimated taxes are manual. You have to do the calculation, you have to make the payment. And we just know from data, you know, from behavioral science that people don’t do things like the, they do the default more often than not. So if you can default your taxes, that’s what you wanna do. So if you’re in the side hustle zone, the thing you wanna understand is that your taxes are holistic. They are all of your income lumped together and your spouses lumped all together and put onto one tax return with one number of what you owe, or you know, what you got a refund for if you overpaid. So if three quarters of your income comes from a job, you know, where you’re an employee and you have payroll withholding your taxes throughout the year, and one quarter of your income is coming from this gig or side hustle, you have enough proportionally money that you could take out of your W2 to never have to pay quarterly taxes. But what you need to do, the action you do need to take is to file a new W four with your employer to adjust your withholding at your day job to over withhold. In other words, you don’t wanna withhold only enough taxes to cover the tax obligation formed by the employment. You wanna overdo it and go into taking enough taxes to account for your self-employment. Um, your gig, your side hustle income that is considered self-employment income. FYI, um, and the taxes on that are always higher than you think because self-employment tax applies to self-employed income. So your employer is paying one half of that amount. It’s one of your wonderful benefits as an employee. You pay both halves when you’re self-employed because you legit are the boss <laugh>. You pay the employee and the boss half of Medicare and social security. And we call that self-employment tax. So my tip there is pull a W 4 off the internet, go to irs.gov, grab yourself a W 4, fill it out. You might need some old pay stubs. You might want last year’s tax return. If you have any bookkeeping from your business year to date, that’s great. Um, or just last year’s tax return. Um, hopefully if that gig was going already last year. And then you just wanna fill out the little, um, paycheck checkup tool on the IRS website that will help you, um, adjust your withholding to essentially give you, you know, the refund level that you wanna have. Um, I recommend zero <laugh>

Emily (29:34): I, it’s the same way I would approach things. That’s how I also teach. Um, anyone, anyone who has a fellowship income, which does not have withholding on it, but who also has W2 income, their spouse or them, that’s the same thing. I say, make this easier on yourself, just fill out a new W 4. But let’s add the added wrinkle of they don’t have the W2 position. Let’s say they’re receiving a fellowship, it already doesn’t have tax withholding on it. Maybe they’re already doing estimated tax because they have that fellowship. Um mm-Hmm. How should they incorporate the self, the self-employed income and, and the income and the self-employment tax from that, um, in with their ongoing like fellowship type income, uh, calculations?

Hannah (30:12): Yeah, well they’re gonna, you’re gonna need to do some degree of bookkeeping or else it’s gonna be a very stressful moment before the tax deadline. Um, and you will, you know, you’ll need to pay quarterly taxes every single quarter that that’s your legal obligation. So under US tax law, if on last year’s tax return you owed more than a thousand dollars, then you have to pay quarterly taxes this year or else you’ll get penalties and interest. Um, and you can pull out last year’s tax return and you can check if you’re in this category. So line 37 of your 1040 personal income tax return is gonna tell you what you owed last year. And if you see a number on there and it’s greater than a thousand, you gotta be paying quarterly taxes this year. Um, PS line 38, the line just below that is your estimated tax penalty <laugh>. So you can look at that line to see if you’re already being punished for not doing this. Um, I think that people, you know, we have a whole tax industry out there trying to, you know, its marketing is based around making us all hate and fear our taxes and actually kind of implicitly training us not to even look at it to just feel so fearful. And so, like hands off that we don’t even look at it. And I’m just here to say, I hate that I disagree with it. Your taxes are yours. Your 1040 is your information and you can, you know, the first two pages of it summarize every single thing that is in that big tax packet. And if you just look at every line on the first two pages, you have massive power. You know what’s happening. Um, and I just told you two lines, the power in those two lines, line 37 and line 38 and that, you know, that will, that will help you kind of get your head around <laugh> whether you have to pay quarterly or not. If you do, um, you know, if you think about what line 37 tax, you know, what you owe, like owing something at tax time is not supposed to happen, right? It does happen. It’s okay. It’s a reconciliation document where we reconcile the actual amount paid versus the expected amount, um, and we settle up the difference. But essentially owing anything means you underpaid your taxes throughout the year. ’cause we live in a pay as you go tax system. You’re supposed to pay your taxes as you go through the year, not all on April 15th.

Emily (32:40): I think what I would say, in addition to what you just said, um, the, the form form 1040, ES, the estimated tax worksheet is a very helpful document in calculating your estimated tax due. Um, people in the audience listening may already be familiar with this for their fellowship income, but you just have to add in a few more lines relevant to the business income and so forth. But if they don’t wanna do more calculations, I think I would tell them just to kind of, as a rule of thumb, set aside an additional 15.3% of their business profit. If there is a profit for that self-employment tax pay, that plus whatever their marginal tax rate is, let’s say it’s 12% usually for graduate students, maybe 22% for some postdocs. Um, if they’re single and just doing that much, if you don’t wanna do like a full calculation is gonna get you, that’s an 80 20 <laugh> on that is to add mm-hmm, that additional amount of money in with either your W 4 or your estimated tax payments if you’re doing it on your fellowship already. Um, but doing the detailed calculation is always gonna be the most, uh, thorough and the most accurate way to go. But Hannah, uh, when you were.

Hannah (33:46): Sure, although keep in, keep in mind ’cause it’s stressful for people. I think like especially if you’re coming to this and you’ve not learned about how estimated quarterly taxes work, um, it’s really important to remember the first word. It is an estimate and you’re not gonna know, like fundamentally you can look at your tax rate from last year, but last year’s tax rate does not guarantee this year’s tax rate, right? So even if you do it in good faith and you did the best possible job, you could, you can still be wrong. And so really, I just encourage you like 80 20 is a good attitude on this because it is called an estimate because you don’t have a crystal ball, like the law cannot compel you to accurately predict a future. So we can all just breathe a sigh of relief and just estimate and that’s okay.

Emily (34:35): The other good thing about paying those quarterly taxes, um, as you go, as you were saying is that, um, there’s never gonna be such a huge balance built up. Like something that often happens in our community with fellowship income is that people get to tax season and they realize they owe three, four, $5,000 because they never paid estimated tax or had tax withholding during the year. And that is a huge shock on like this level of income that we’re talking about. And it can happen with business income too, um, especially if you’re taking distributions from your business and then you’re spending that money. Um, so either keep the money in your business account and don’t take the distributions or as you take the distributions, make sure you’re putting aside something for either your quarterly or your annual tax bill so it doesn’t, doesn’t get away from you <laugh>.

Hannah (35:17): Absolutely. Yeah.

Sunlight Tax and the Sunlight Podcast

Emily (35:19): So just a few minutes ago when you were talking about how, um, you know, our, our system, mostly the tax industry that’s built up around our regulations, they want you to feel a certain way about taxes and in fact you should be empowered about this, et cetera, et cetera. This is a taste of what people can get on your podcast. So I would love you to take a minute and just tell everybody where they can find you, what you put out there, what you do in your business, and if they want to learn more from you or work with you in some way, how they can do that.

Hannah (35:46): Sure. Thanks Emily. Um, well, so my business is Sunlight Tax. If you go to sunlighttax.com, you’ll find everything there. So if you miss something, sunlighttax.com, I have my podcast, which comes out every Tuesday, Sunlight, um, you can find that on my website, sunlighttax.com. Um, I also have a bunch of free resources like, uh, deductions guide, a visual Guide to Tax Deductions, which you can also find on my website. Um, I offer a lot of free courses, including a recent one about, um, LLCs. If you go to sunlighttax.com/llc, if you happen to have formed an LLC for your side hustle or your business, um, there’s a mandatory, a mandatory new report required, um, from the US Treasury <laugh>. Um, but also I have a program called Money Bootcamp where I teach, um, people how to set up very simple systems to track your taxes, um, pay your estimates and fund your retirement using tax advantage accounts. So, um, all of that you can find @ sunlighttax.com and,

Emily (36:51): Excellent.

Hannah (36:51): Yeah.

Best Financial Advice for Another Early-Career PhD

Emily (36:52): Yes, and I will definitely personally vouch for the podcast because I am a listener every single week and I learn something new every week and I think it’s great. Um, okay, Hannah, I’m gonna end by asking you the question that I ask all my guests, which is, what is your best financial advice for an early career PhD? A grad student, a postdoc, someone recently out of their PhD training? Um, and that can be something that we’ve touched on already that’s related to tax, or it could be something completely aside from what we’ve discussed.

Hannah (37:19): Sure. Um, I’ll say this, it’s a bit of my personal religion, but, um, if you have never played with a compound interest calculator and seeing what the power of your money is when it is invested, um, please do yourself that favor, <laugh>. Um, and I would say do not just write yourself off. Say, I am broke right now. I will wait to put money in an IRA I really highly encourage you, if you do nothing else, maintaining an annual habit of maxing out your IRA will put you in a better position. Um, it, it will, you know, you invest the money inside the IRA so it will grow with compound interest and tax sheltered. So it’s really a wonderful thing that works when you start young <laugh>. You don’t wanna miss five years of compounding because you’re in grad school. Um, if you can, you know, just make it your religion to do it every single year without skipping, I think that is my best piece of advice. And believe you as a 45-year-old woman, woman, <laugh> talking to you, I, I wish for everyone here that we could all have started at the age that you are now. Um, and the age you are now is only it, you know, the best time to start this investments your investments was 20 years ago, but the second best time is now.

Emily (38:41): Love that advice. You touched on my two favorite topics today, taxes and investing. So it’s amazing. <laugh>. I will also just say, I mean, I love the goal of maxing out an IRA, but that’s not gonna be possible for many people. So even if it’s just, um, $50 a month, a hundred, 200, whatever you can do, be in the habit of it. And do as much as you can. And then absolutely, once you get that higher income from your lovely post-PhD job, then you can really ramp it up and use your 401k and use everything else. But having that habit of doing it from earlier and having sort of developing the identity of I am an investor and understanding things like compound interest that is gonna serve you so well later on, um, not just the dollars and the numbers, but all that psychology that comes along with it.

Hannah (39:24): Absolutely. Yeah. They, they show that even very, very poor people who have a savings account save more because just having it there helps you do it. So if you haven’t opened an IRA yet, I encourage you to do it this year. Even if it, even if you put 10 bucks in <laugh>, like open it. The fact that it’s there is setting up the infrastructure to make it easier to do that, you know, thing. And really saving, savings and investing is a muscle. So think of it as like a muscle that you have to get in some reps to get good at.

Emily (39:55): I love it. Hannah, thank you so much for joining me today. It’s been a wonderful episode and thanks again.

Hannah (40:02): Thanks so much, Emily. I really loved joining you today.

Outtro

Emily (40:15): Listeners, thank you for joining me for this episode! I have a gift for you! You know that final question I ask of all my guests regarding their best financial advice? My team has collected short summaries of all the answers ever given on the podcast into a document that is updated with each new episode release. You can gain access to it by registering for my mailing list at PFforPhDs.com/advice/. Would you like to access transcripts or videos of each episode? I link the show notes for each episode from PFforPhDs.com/podcast/. See you in the next episode, and remember: You don’t have to have a PhD to succeed with personal finance… but it helps! Nothing you hear on this podcast should be taken as financial, tax, or legal advice for any individual. The music is “Stages of Awakening” by Podington Bear from the Free Music Archive and is shared under CC by NC. Podcast editing by Dr. Lourdes Bobbio and show notes creation by Dr. Jill Hoffman.

Addressing Fellowship Tax Pain Points through Education, Resources, and Advocacy

April 1, 2024 by Jill Hoffman 1 Comment

In this episode, Emily interviews Jack Mao, the founder of Tax Fellows, a nonprofit organization that prepares pro bono tax returns for Stanford students. Tax Fellows primarily serves first-generation, low-income undergraduate and graduate students, and has a special focus on the tax implications of receiving scholarships and fellowships, such as the Kiddie Tax and estimated tax payments. Jack shares the advocacy approach he’s taking to reform the Kiddie Tax at the federal level and lists ideas for how graduate students across the US can bring more attention and resources to resolve their tax pain points.

Links mentioned in the Episode

Addressing Fellowship Tax Pain Points through Education, Resources, and Advocacy

Teaser

Jack (00:00): Where students aren’t being told to expect significant tax liability on their stipend checks and like making sure that they save money for taxes. There’s no, you know, mechanisms like withholdings where the schools will pay the taxes on the students’ behalf. And so the students just kinda have to like figure it out and learn the hard way during their first tax season. And I feel like, you know, that’s not really the way to go. That there definitely needs to be a lot more resources across all the universities in the country to really help educate these students on their tax liability and really help support them through it as well.

Introduction

Emily (00:54): Welcome to the Personal Finance for PhDs Podcast: A Higher Education in Personal Finance. This podcast is for PhDs and PhDs-to-be who want to explore the hidden curriculum of finances to learn the best practices for money management, career advancement, and advocacy for yourself and others. I’m your host, Dr. Emily Roberts, a financial educator specializing in early-career PhDs and founder of Personal Finance for PhDs.

Emily (01:24): This is Season 17, Episode 7, and today my guest is Jack Mao, the founder of Tax Fellows, a nonprofit organization that prepares pro bono tax returns for Stanford students. Tax Fellows primarily serves first-generation, low-income undergraduate and graduate students, and has a special focus on the tax implications of receiving scholarships and fellowships, such as the Kiddie Tax and estimated tax payments. Jack shares the advocacy approach he’s taking to reform the Kiddie Tax at the federal level and lists ideas for how graduate students across the US can bring more attention and resources to resolve their tax pain points.

Emily (02:04): The tax year 2023 version of my tax return preparation workshop, How to Complete Your PhD Trainee Tax Return (and Understand It, Too!), is now available! This pre-recorded educational workshop explains how to identify, calculate, and report your higher education-related income and expenses on your federal tax return. You’ll hear me reference this workshop once or twice during the interview. Whether you are a graduate student, postdoc, or postbac, domestic or international, there is a version of this workshop designed just for you. Go to PFforPhDs.com/taxreturnworkshop/ to read more details and purchase the workshop. By the way, it’s never too early to start laying the groundwork for university sponsorship. If taxes are a pain point for you, please let the administration at your university know that you would like them to provide additional resources either during next tax season or near the beginning of the academic year, as Jack suggests near the end of the interview. I can license one or both of my asynchronous workshops or deliver a live seminar. Please cc me ([email protected]) if you decide to recommend me! You can find the show notes for this episode at PFforPhDs.com/s17e7/. Without further ado, here’s my interview with Jack Mao of Tax Fellows.

Will You Please Introduce Yourself Further?

Emily (03:40): I have a really special guest joining me on the podcast today. His name is Jack Mao and I’m going to let him introduce himself to you further in just a second. I just wanna say how we got connected, which is that I have been working with Stanford this past tax season to provide my tax workshop to their graduate students and postdocs, and Jack started an organization at Stanford called Tax Fellows. The more serves on the undergraduate side, but definitely some overlapping, um, interests in populations between our two. And so because of our mutual collaborators at Stanford, we got to talking and just had an absolutely fascinating conversation and I knew that I had to bring him onto the podcast. So Jack, we’re gonna get into your whole background, but just really briefly, can you tell us who you are and what you’re up to right now?

Jack (04:23): Sure. Uh, thank you so much for having me on the podcast here, Emily. Um, my name’s Jack. I am, I was a Stanford student, uh, until recently. And, um, I’ve been also a credentialed tax professional, uh, federally credentialed for the past, uh, couple years, but in the industry for about six years so far. Um, and yeah, it serves a lot of, um, you know, college students, that’s kind of my strong suits and so it was natural for me to just kind of start Tax Fellows, uh, in partnership with the IRS and few Stanford offices to help out other college students with their taxes.

Emily (04:58): Yeah, and this is a really unique organization. I haven’t found one like it at any other universities I’ve collaborated with. So I wanna hear more about that. But first I wanna get a little more background on you, Jack, and sort of how as an undergraduate student you became interested in income tax and ultimately, you know, that led you to starting Tax Fellows.

Jack (05:16): Sure, sure. So, um, my background is actually in computer science and so totally different than, you know, tax, um, and accounting. But, um, it was back in high school I was, um, so I come from a low-income background and I was trying to start a small business to help out with family finances. Um, and at the time I just had, you know, my McDonald’s paychecks to pay for everything, which wasn’t really enough to, you know, pay for, uh, you know, accountants or, uh, lawyer’s advice. So what I did was, yeah, it’s a good CS major or do just Google everything. Uh, would not recommend unless you plan on switching ma- uh, you know, majors in industries, um, or careers. But, um, yeah, um, Google, everything. Really loved. Uh, just the way the taxes works, you know, I hate paying taxes, but it’s just, you know, it allows you to have a lot of creativity and flexibility and kind of, uh, finding ways to get around taxes you don’t really want to pay, uh, at times. Uh, and so that was really fun. I really want, uh, go more into it and to decide to volunteer with the IRAs VITA program, um, that works with nonprofits, uh, to provide free tax services to income taxpayers. So been, uh, in that program ever since, uh, and still am in that program, uh, through Tax Fellows today.

Volunteer Income Tax Assistance (VITA) Program & TaxFellows

Emily (06:37): So can you explain a little bit more what the connection is between the VITA Program and Tax Fellows? Is it exactly the same? Is there, is there more to it?

Jack (06:45): Sure. So, um, originally we started out just as a VITA site. And so Tax Fellows is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, it’s a standalone nonprofit, um, that’s separate from Stanford, but we partner with the IRS, where the IRS helps us provide some training, some overhead and, you know, oversight, um, and helps us source a lot of our volunteers as well. Um, but now, now that Tax Fellows, um, has finished their first year and joined to our second tax season, uh, we have been expanding our programs a little bit, um, to also provide a additional pro bono, um, program called Tax Advisors, where we have our credential tax professionals, um, on a team prepare more complicated tax returns for undergrad students with kiddie tax, uh, obligations, uh, just because that is something that is outside the scope of VITA program. Um, and so we couldn’t prepare those in the past. So we kind of are in a way, um, half pro, uh, VITA sites and half a kind of a pro-bono tax in a sense. Um, and so, uh, but you know, we do have a pretty good partnership with the IRS and a few, uh, good stakeholders in the area.

Emily (07:59): And just for the listeners who aren’t familiar with VITA, maybe they’ve never been to, you know, access to services that are available to them at their university or their library in their city or whatever, can you explain like who that program is for?

Jack (08:10): Sure. So Tax Fellows, um, is, uh, or just VITA program in general, um, is for low income taxpayers, um, who might want some, you know, additional help with their taxes, um, but, you know, um, might not be able to afford say, a tax professional. Um, and so VITA sites, they are run by nonprofits at IRS, uh, partners with, uh, usually and, um, they’re staffed by volunteers, many of whom are credential professionals or retired professionals, but a lot of whom are also just newer, um, folks to the industry who want to get some more experience. That was kind of how I got my experience, um, with taxes and, uh, just kind of, uh, having the IRS, you know, train them, uh, on the volunteers on, you know, these basic tax topics so that they can, um, help prepare your tax returns for you, uh, at no charge. Um, these are all out of the volunteers, uh, generosity, um, of their time. And so, um, but it’s a really great program, um, with a lot of guardrails so that, you know, um, the quality control is usually pretty high. Um, and, um, yeah, yeah, definitely a really great program for anyone who makes under around $64,000 every year, um, and have fairly simple, uh, situations, uh, to get their taxes done, uh, really great and for free. So

Emily (09:39): I’m so glad you mentioned that number. ’cause in a lot of the country people are making less than that amount of money, so it really covers, yeah, a broad swath of people, especially my population graduate students, even some postdocs will fall under that, um, level of income. So they can almost always, if they have a VITA site available to ’em, access those services. And I’m really glad you just mentioned, you know, there’s, there’s guardrails there. Um, there’s only, you have to have a simple tax situation to really benefit. And that’s why you mentioned earlier that you started this tax advisors wing of tax fellows. Let’s talk a little bit more about some of these like confusing tax issues that may be common between like the first generation low income population that you serve, and then the funded graduate students and potentially postdocs population that, uh, that I serve.

The Kiddie Tax

Emily (10:22): So you, you mentioned the kiddie tax, um, let’s brief overview right now about what the kiddie tax is for anybody who has the, uh, misfortune of hearing about this for the first time.

Jack (10:32): Yeah. Yeah. So, um, kiddie tax originally, um, the inspiration behind that, uh, on the legislation side was, you know, a lot of these high net worth individuals, uh, your parents especially would, you know, have pretty high marginal tax rates. What they would do is, you know, have tax professionals who would kind of find all these little loopholes. And one of them is, you know, they could just pass along their investments to their children who are basically making no money, right? Uh, especially if they’re a minor. That way they could both save on taxes, Congress didn’t like that. Um, and so they implement kiddie tax where if, uh, the child is a minor, uh, or a full-time student who didn’t, uh, you know, earn, uh, from a job, uh, so earned income, um, more than half of their living expenses, then they’re considered basically, in a sense a soft dependent of their parents.

Jack (11:33): And so any unearned income that the child has now, uh, will be taxed at their parents’ highest tax rate. Um, and so, uh, that way, you know, the richer parents can’t just pass on their investments, uh, through their children because they’ll be tax rate basically. Um, unfortunately the way Congress defined kiddie tax, um, was very broad. And so it also encompasses, you know, college students who have, you know, taxable scholarship, financial aid, uh, you know, fellowships where, uh, you know, if they don’t have earned income from a job that’s more than half of their expenses, especially at, you know, Stanford where cost of tuition and like the, um, the room board are like an 80 to a hundred thousand dollars every year, uh, if not more. And so the student, not only do they have to like work a, you know, um, full-time job, you know, making more than 50 K to get outta it, uh, it is just a lot of qualifications and so too much complexity. Um, and that’s kind of, um, one of the biggest reasons why, um, we’re so popular at Stanford as while just helping students navigate, uh, through all this complexity.

Emily (12:52): Yeah, that makes sense. And this hits my population all the time. When you’re receiving a fellowship, one of the things about the calculation that goes into the kiddie tax is that your expenses include your education expenses and not just like your living expenses. So that scholarship that goes towards paying your tuition, the cost counts as part of your living expenses, but the scholarship that pays for it doesn’t count on like your side of the ledger of like providing half of your own support. Exactly. Exactly. So, right, so like they get hit with this fellowship, um, issue too. Now, what was interesting about the kiddie tax, I think I read into like the history of this and it seemed like there was like a creep going on. Like at first it was just minors, then it was up to age 19, then it was now it’s students, um, up, up, up until, you know, through age 23, under age 24.

Emily (13:34): And so over time it kind of like expanded and expanded. Um, but there was a reform a few years ago with the Tax Cuts and Jobs act that attempted to, um, make some changes to the kiddie tax. Mm-Hmm . And it really hit your population, that low income population because what they did was they, for a couple of years changed the definition so that, um, no longer were you taxed at your parents’ highest marginal tax rate, but you were taxed at the marginal tax rate for trusts, which simplified things certainly because you would just look at a table and see where you fell on that instead of having to, you know, link your tax return with your parents. But if your parents were low income to begin with, maybe that kiddie tax was not so big of a bite. Now, if your parents were high income, of course it was a big bite, but because it really, really increased those marginal tax rates on those low income populations, there was a big outcry. And after a couple of years, I think it got shifted back to the old model of go to your parents’ tax rate. So that was, yeah, just some interesting like shifts that happened with end time. But yeah. Yeah, the kiddie tax is a very unpleasant thing to find out about.

Commercial

Emily (14:33): Emily here for a brief interlude! Tax season is in full swing, and the best place to go for information tailored to you as a grad student, postdoc, or postbac, is PFforPhDs.com/tax/. From that page I have linked to all of my free tax resources, many of which I have updated for this tax year. On that page you will find podcast episodes, videos, and articles on all kinds of tax topics relevant to PhDs and PhDs-to-be. There are also opportunities to join the Personal Finance for PhDs mailing list to receive PDF summaries and spreadsheets that you can work with. Again, you can find all of these free resources linked from PFforPhDs.com/tax/. Now back to the interview.

Paying Estimated Taxes as a Graduate Student

Jack (15:38): Oh yeah. So, uh, especially for like first year grad students, uh, who have like a lot of taxable stipends ’cause they get like stipend checks, uh, usually and, you know, they would owe a pretty significant amount of taxes. Uh, and so to, to a point that they definitely need to pay estimated taxes, not only like to avoid the underpayment penalty, but also to, uh, just not be surprised at the tax bill end the year and try to like, try to recoup all the money, um, to pay, uh, substantial tax liability. And so, uh, we’ve been educating, um, grad students, um, as they come in, especially the first year grad students, uh, kind of how to pay estimate taxes. ‘Cause we also have California and they have like, their kind of special snowflake. They have like very, um, specific percentages, um, where it’s like 30%, 40%, 0%, 30% for like, the amount of estimated taxes that need to be paid.

Jack (16:31): Federal is like pretty straightforward. It’s just one fourth of the tax every quarter. Um, but just kind of educating students on like how to pay those, uh, payments, trying to figure out, um, how much to pay. Uh, and then kind of repercussions if they don’t, uh, pay as many taxes. ’cause you know, uh, students they could be busy and so, uh, you know, I’ll just kinda let them decide based on all the facts available, like whether um, it’s worth the effort of doing as many taxes. Usually it is, ’cause like usually if you don’t do it, um, for students that we have, um, served, their penalties are gonna be around a two, $300 range, uh, in this economy with, uh, the inflation. ’cause the penalties really based on just interest, um, and the interest rate that r assets for, you know, all, all their penalties and interests and, um, it’s just prorated across the year, uh, based on the, um, estimated tax payment you’re supposed to make, uh, from that date on, um, to the tax season. And so right now, uh, usually the past the rate was like 3% and so it wasn’t too bad, but right now the rates are in a 7% range. And so it’s definitely significant.

Emily (17:44): I found that as well that a lot of graduate students are aware of the estimated tax issue, but they just choose to not address it until tax season. And if they go into that with their eyes open, of course that’s their decision. But, uh, like you, I just try to lay out, okay, this is the trade off if you decide you’re going to neglect this.

Jack (18:01): Yeah. Yeah.

Emily (18:03): I think the real tough part is ra- facing that, you know, multi-thousand dollar tax bill that you exactly may not be prepared for.

Jack (18:10): Exactly. Because, you know, yeah. Students are also taxed on your part of the fellowship that goes to room board and room board in the Bay Area is pretty significant. Um, and so not only do students have to usually save for taxes on their stipend checks, you also have to like figure out, um, how much tax to save on housing, uh, stipends and some of the other stipends. And I feel like, you know, right now there’s not really a good way for the students in general, I feel like maybe it’s just more of a lack of re- uh, educational resources in the first place, um, where students aren’t being told, uh, to expect significant tax liability, um, on their stipend checks and like making sure that they save money for taxes. Um, there’s no, you know, mechanisms like withholdings where the schools will pay the taxes on the student’s behalf and so the students just kinda have to like figure it out, um, and learn the hard way , uh, during their first tax season. Um, and I feel like, you know, that’s not really the way to go. Uh, that there definitely needs to be a lot more resources, uh, for across all the universities, uh, in the country, uh, to really help educate these students on their tax liability and really help support them through it as well.

Emily (19:27): Yes. You know, I agree with you of course ’cause this is one of the main missions of my business, but, um, we’ll talk more about how people can sort of get more resources and get more education to their own peers, um, later on. But I just wanna add on that point. I mean, Stanford, obviously, you and I are both working with people at Stanford, so like Stanford’s obviously making a pretty, a relatively large effort in this area. Sure. Um, to get people informed about this. But I, it’s, um, I do not see this at this degree of resources being offered at many other places, which is to add, but I will tell you that there are a couple universities I went to one Duke, um, where they actually did offer income tax withholding on fellowships. I don’t know how or why it happened. I mean, the paychecks were being processed through payroll instead of through financial aid.

Emily (20:10): So there was a mechanism for doing it. Um, and it did generate a weird tax form. We got a 1099 miscellaneous instead of a, you know, 1098 t or whatever. Sure, sure. Yeah. Um, so it caused some downstream tax complications, but they did offer it. So that is something that I know is happening at some places and maybe it could happen at more places and it would certainly be easier on the students than having to engage with the estimated tax system. So Now that we’ve kind of talked about, like, you know, this example of the kiddie tax, how the kiddie taxes changed with time, um, how advocacy actually around after the pa after the passage of the Tax Cuts and Jobs act, when, you know, the tax rates were jacked up for these low income families, there was an outcry and it was reversed. I want you to give us a few examples, if you don’t mind, of Yeah. Some things that have changed within the tax law over time, uh, that relate to students, just so we can see some examples of like, this is not completely static, like these things do change.

Advocacy Around the Kiddie Tax, Taxable Scholarships, and Other Niche Financial Issues

Jack (21:02): Yeah, yeah. So, um, right now we’re actually trying to do some advocacy, uh, around the kiddie tax and the taxable scholarship arena just because, uh, it is, I’d say slightly outdated, uh, set of tax law. Um, you know, it was most recently updated back in, uh, the 1986, um, uh, tax changes. Uh, there, there were some major tax changes back then, uh, and never since, like since then, like I’d say like the, just the way scholarships and financial aid work, especially at like, you know, expensive private universities like Stanford, uh, and like the Ivy League, um, like it tuition has just gone up significantly where I don’t think it really makes sense anymore to put a lot of that tax burden on students. Um, and without any, like, you know, as you mentioned, like, uh, stu- you know, schools have to like put withholdings on a 1099 miscellaneous.

Jack (21:59): Um, so like, there’s not really like a, a mechanism say on a 1098 t or another like educational oriented form, um, to really help students, you know, save a little bit on their taxes, um, you know, having those taxes being taken out already. Uh, and so we’ve been, uh, trying to do some advocacy around their, uh, you know, the legislative side who’ve met with, um, the late Senator Feinstein’s office, uh, and representative Eshoo’s office, uh, who represents the district Stanford’s in, um, to kinda discuss about, um, you the struggles that students are going through with K tax and, uh, especially like undergrads as well, where they don’t get stipend checks really. Um, but even the in kind aid for, you know, room and board, you know, especially on top of like internship income, that is pretty significant. Uh, burden, you know, we typically see like about two, two, $3,000 of burden on in-kind aid, so money that the student never sees.

Jack (22:59): Um, and so they have to like work a, you know, good like on-campus job just to pay the tax on again, money that they never see. And so it, it’s a struggle. I mean, um, we’ve been, um, able to help the students save a little bit on taxes, you know, optimize, uh, with the parents, uh, so that we dumb it down to about, uh, a few hundred dollars, but even a few hundred dollars is pretty significant for these income students. And so we’ve been really help, um, working with in these, um, legislators, um, on, you know, ways that we can really change the tax around us. Um, and, you know, the judicial side as well, trying to poke holes and, um, kind of, uh, tax code surrounding, uh, these topics, uh, through tax court. Uh, and we might even, um, do some advisory, um, and meet with advisors through, uh, President Biden’s office, uh, very soon here. Yeah. Even on this, uh, university side as well, uh, you know, trying to get, you know, support fund going for, uh, you know, students to pay their tax liability, uh, especially in the first years where they might not expect such high liability, uh, and it would be, you know, challenging for them to pay those liability. Uh, but it’s been, it’s been tough working with Stanford, um, for now. Uh, but we’re still keeping at it and, and we’ll see kind how it goes, uh, over time. Yeah,

Emily (24:30): I think the kiddie tax is such a great example of an issue that’s right for change, just because, you know, the way you explained it earlier, which is the way that I understand this as well, is the original, um, conception of the kiddie tax was to make it less advantageous for high net worth parents to pass assets, income generating assets to their children. And that is not at all what is going on with scholarship and fellowship income. It’s, it’s perplexing to me how scholarship and fellowship income even got tied in with investment income in the first place. Yeah. Yeah. I, it’s, it’s completely baffling to me. Yeah.

Jack (25:04): Well, I mean, even with leg- legislators, uh, you have with, uh, it’s been, uh, it’s been challenging for them to just, I guess like, um, everyone has, um, like especially legislators have, you know, lots of, uh, different priorities that they need to kind of first, um, solve. And so I guess we weren’t too high on the set priority list. Uh, I mean, hopefully they’re, that they’re working on it, but, um, it, it’s, it’s, you know, a lot of politics as well. And so it’s a, it’s gonna be a long game, but, um, we we’re pretty committed to, you know, doing long-term advocacy around this, um, gonna go at it, um, as long as this is a thing, uh, and, you know, just some interesting, uh, statistics as well. So, um, you know, yeah, can tax, like, as you mentioned, like it’s definitely for, you know, these high level worth parents, uh, and their children.

Jack (25:58): And so typically the median, uh, an average income that we see for, um, you know, students or just children who have to fill out the kiddie tax form 8615, the me-, uh, the average parents income is actually in a, uh, about $1 million, uh, taxable income. A lot of these low income students, their parents are not making a million dollars . Um, and so like, yeah, this is definitely unintended consequence of the way legislators wrote the tax. Uh, and even for taxable fel- um, scholarship fellowship in general, uh, it’s heavily under-reported, uh, only about $4 billion of taxable financial scholarship and fellowship are, is being recorded. Uh, and so it, it’s, you know, it’s an area of the tax field that, you know, Congress and IRS isn’t really making a lot of money, um, in, in the first place. Uh, and so, uh, you know, using those arguments, you know, we’re hoping to really push along the change a little quicker, uh, especially ahead of the upcoming, uh, sunset of the TCJA, uh, Trump, uh, the Tax Trust and Jobs Act, uh, back when President Trump passed it, uh, just to kind of see if we can push along, um, uh, as a rider on, uh, those big tax bills that are coming up soon on the Congress side.

Jack (27:24): So, so we’ll see. We we’re, we’re definitely, uh, steadfast our commitment, uh, to advocacy here.

Emily (27:30): And I mean, I’m, I’m so excited about this and I hope you keep , keep it up and everything, and I’m just, um, I’m really inspired by like the story of how the definition of taxable compensation change for the purposes of contributing to an individual retirement arrangement. Because that also seems like a very, very tiny niche issue, right? The, the Graduate Student Savings Act to, if anyone is not familiar, it used to be that fellowship income not reported on a W2, was not eligible to be contributed to an IRA. And this was proposed, you know, federally several times in terms of the Grad Student Savings Act to change this definition so that it could be, and it failed several times until it finally got rolled in with the Secure, the Secure Act in 2019, and it was passed. And like, again, it was a thing that mattered so much to like my population, um, and it was amazing that it passed.

Emily (28:17): But yeah, that’s a really, really niche issue. And hopefully, again, some of these other niche issues like the kiddie tax can be addressed too. I actually have one more example. Yeah. So the tuition and fees deduction, they tried to eliminate that over and over and over again, and it kept being like resurrected year after year. It’s finally gone now. But again, for the listeners who were not in graduate school, maybe a few years back, yeah, there are currently three higher education tax benefits, but there used to be four available. The fourth one was the tuition fees deduction. Yeah. And it was the least useful and valuable one, and it ended up, I mean, the reasoning why they kept a congress kept trying to sort of sunset that particular de deduction was that it ultimately just confused people more. And so people would take the tuition fees deduction Mm-Hmm. when really one of the credits, for example, might have been better for their tax liability overall. Mm-Hmm. . So my understanding was it was causing more confusion and they just eliminated it. And it, it kind of sounds bad to like, oh, eliminate a deduction that was available to you, but really there were better ones avail better credits available. Yeah. Yeah. So that was another, I just kept watching it year after year being like, okay, it’s finally gonna die. No, they brought it back again, finally. Now it is gone.

Jack (29:24): No. Yeah, yeah, yeah, it’s definitely confused. Uh, so the students I’ve served in the past as well, um, and like there’s just, I think there’s a lot of different ways Congress is, uh, trying to help with education expenses, uh, through tax code, but, uh, you know, I don’t think, you know, with the taxable financial aid, fellowship scholarship, uh, section, um, there’s definitely a lot more potential there, uh, for, uh, you know, change. And so we’re definitely, uh, um, hope that Congress can, you know, really take up our word. And there’s definitely a lot of other nonprofits like us, uh, that I’ve met with who are also advocating for same thing as well. Um, you know, typically we don’t really see audits rates that high, especially for students. But even then, you know, none of my clients have gone on in knock on wood, uh, yet.

Jack (30:16): And so, uh, but yeah, I’ve definitely heard from a lot of these other nonprofits, some of the students that we’ve been working with. You know, there’s one, uh, one of the organizations that was, uh, serving foster youths, uh, that I met with, and one of their foster youth got audited on their taxable financial aid fellowship, uh, scholarship. And the outcome is not pretty. Um, so, uh, it’s definitely, uh, one of the biggest and one of the most urgent issues that we’re trying to tackle. Um, not only on the legislative side, but also, uh, just kinda on university side as well. Just especially the, um, private institutions like Stanford and, uh, the Ivy League. They have a lot more resources that they can more easily deploy. Um, and, you know, that’s quicker than, you know, trying and, you know, make change on the, uh, policy side of things. But yeah. We’ll, we’ll see.

How Graduate Students Can Advocate for Tax Related Resources at their Universities

Emily (31:11): Do you have any ideas about how graduate students at other universities can, um, do any kind of advocacy work or just ask their university for anything that would help them sort of gain more resources or, um, education or anything that would help them on this, you know, in, in tax season to, to handle things a little bit better? So like, what can they, maybe not, of course, founding a whole organization like you did but some little things they could do at their university to get some more attention to these issues.

Jack (31:39): Yeah, that’s great. Um, I think, uh, you know, for example, let’s say your podcast and kind of your resources are great, you know, great starting point. Uh, you know, one of the partners that we’ve worked with at Mutual Partners here, uh, Mind Over Money, uh, they’ve, uh, spoke really highly of your resources. And so that’s definitely a great starting point and just kind of advocating for universities to, um, kind of, uh, provide resources and kind of distribute resources, um, across, uh, campus. But also I think like, you know, while not, you know, maybe not founding a whole, you know, uh, tax program from scratch, but, you know, if a university has a law program, uh, then definitely would recommend, you know, working with Senate faculty there, uh, to try to set up, uh, maybe in con- conjunction with United Way usually has, uh, VITA programs already set up. And so just kind of, uh, using existing infrastructure in support of, uh, VITA sites and just kind of start, you know, a small one. It could be a small one, just trying to start out, um, kind of helping other students through their taxes, um, and then trying to attract like, you know, tax professionals and lawyers to the organization.

Using Caution When Getting Tax Help as a Graduate Student

Emily (32:47): So I observed with the VITA site at Duke, um, sure. Sorry to speak against them, but, um, yeah, they were not preparing returns properly with the weird fellowship stuff that was going on at Duke. I see. So I would just say whether there is a VITA site or whether you wanna start one, make sure that they know the population that’s gonna come in and the questions that they’re going to have so that they can train their volunteers specifically towards the situations that they’re going to see Now, because of the weird way that Duke did things, like I actually understand why the mistakes that were made were made, and it might be easier at other places that don’t use the 1099 miscellaneous. Sure. Yeah. Um, but yeah, just to let them know like, Hey, I’m gonna tell all my friends to come in and like, make sure that your volunteers can do this Sure. Correctly and easily and quickly. Definitely.

Jack (33:29): Definitely. Yeah. I mean, we don’t really see a lot VITA sites and universities, uh, where we really should. But, um, even a lot of, uh, sites that I’ve seen, um, at universities, you know, I’ve kind of had a connection with Yale, um, and I wanna say, uh, UC, uh, Santa Cruz as well, uh, in California, uh, they, I I wanna say a lot of them only serve low income tax payers that are not students. Um, and like they don’t orient these services to students, which I think is a good approach, especially if they’re newer site starting out, uh, and not have a lot of those more experienced volunteers, uh, or professionals to kind of guide, you know, the volunteers. But yeah, you, you mentioned a really great point, uh, which is that like, you know, not all VITA sites and even tax professionals I’ve worked with in the past, you know, who have like decades of engineers, not all, you know, professionals or VITA sites, understand, um, kind all the ins and outs of the tax code that are relevant to students.

Jack (34:33): Uh, I’ve even had tax professionals think that, you know, taxable financial is not taxable , um, that was, that’s the you highest extreme I would say. But, uh, even just like optimizing, especially for a lot of undergrad students, optimizing, you know, the, um, you know, parts of the tax, you know, involving, you know, like tax credits, you know, deductions, you know, against their financial aid, uh, and along with their parents, you know, their parents who might be, you know, claiming for example, like the earned income tax credit, um, or the premium tax credit for health, uh, insurance or a lot of other tax credits and just like coordinate the, uh, tax credits that both the students and the parents are claiming, uh, to maximize those resources that that takes a lot of expertise, uh, to do correctly. Um, and so I definitely agree with you there.

Jack (35:25): Um, definitely do be careful, um, with, you know, starting VITA sites, uh, and with just tax professionals in general, just making sure that they actually have the expertise, um, and experience serving students, uh, in order to serve you, uh, you know, better and more accurately. And so I think our, our, uh, you know, tax fellows, um, uh, program, I’m very glad I’m able to, uh, you know, help students, uh, using their expertise. Um, and you know, we’ve been invited, uh, to train other volunteers at other VITA sites, uh, in these student tax considerations. And so, you know, if you’re thinking of starting VITA site, uh, please do reach out, uh, to us at Tax Fellows. Uh, happy to kind of, um, kinda walk you through the steps of starting VITA site, uh, and managing a VITA site, but also kinda allow of the student tax, uh, considerations that, uh, you should think about and kind of consider and, you know, we’ll do some more practice together, uh, on it too.

How Universities Can Support Graduate Students Around Taxes

Jack (36:20): But yeah, I think just in general, um, working with university administrators, uh, and the folks who, uh, you know, run orientation programs to add another orientation session might be just, you know, even if it’s just like one hour long, um, just to kind of prep students for what they should expect with taxes. You know, a lot of these like, you know, big picture, you know, policy changes, you know, like, uh, university like, just kinda like resource changes. Those take time. But I think you just adding another program to orientation, uh, for new students, that’s a really good first step that I think doesn’t take too much convincing to do and will be really effective, uh, to really help students, um, kind of foresee what they should expect at tax season, uh, so that they don’t have to, uh, you know, get surprised, you know, kind of play the game of Russian roulette and like try to, you know, guess and pray, you know, for the best I guess. Yeah.

Emily (37:31): Yeah. And I’ll just have to do a self plug because I have a session like that that’s ready to go. It’s perfect for orientations. It’s live, it’s awesome. Um, yeah, so those of you who are listening, if you, if you want me then please, you know, reach out to me, reach out to administrators at your university. But I would actually say just even back up from that, um, yeah, just talking about the issue of, or like the struggle that people that you’re having with your either preparing your tax return or dealing with your estimated tax or whatever it is, just telling the faculty and the administration that you have concerns about this and you want them to provide resources to you is very, very helpful. Um, because a lot of universities are super reticent to touch taxes with a 10 foot pole because of perceived liability issues on their end. Now it’s kind of funny because they, they do help international students to a great degree. They don’t usually offer the same kind of help for domestic students. Um, but if you tell them repeatedly and get a lot of people to tell them that you want more resources around this, then that’s, I think, the best they can figure out how they want to meet that need. But just letting them know that that need is there, that that concern is there is a wonderful first step.

Jack (38:34): Definitely. Definitely. Yeah.

Best Financial Advice for Another Early-Career PhD

Emily (38:36): Okay. So Jack, thank you so much for giving this interview. It’s been wonderful to speak with you. Yeah, thank you so much. And I want to end with our last question. Sure. Which is, what is your best financial advice for a funded graduate student or an early career PhD? And it can be something related to taxes if you want. It could be something that we’ve talked about during the interview, or it could be something completely different.

Jack (38:56): IRAs, I cannot emphasize enough how important and just like life changing that IRAs could be. Um, you know, there’s definitely, you know, for, you know, especially grad students, uh, PhD students, uh, you know, once you, you graduate, you, you might go into academia, but if you go into industry, uh, where you’re getting paid, you know, six figure salaries out-, out the door, it’s gonna be, you know, you could still contribute to say like a Roth IRA, but uh, it’s gonna be a bit more difficult and there’s like backdoor stuff to consider. But um, you know, now is the best time for a lot of, you know, grad students with their income level to contribute to Roth IRA while they still can, uh, easily. And you know, once the money is in, it’s a basically tax free, um, forever, uh, you could invest in, you know, stocks, you know, um, even occasionally startups, if that’s kind of your thing.

Jack (39:58): You know, I’m a little biased. I, I, I’m running a startup and like Stanford really good on startups, but, uh, you, that’s how you know folks like for example, Peter Thiel, um, have, you know, so much money that’s tax free is because he was able to contribute while he was, um, having lower uh, amounts of income in his early days. Uh, and then, you know, once the money’s in, there’s a lot of flexibility, uh, and ways to really help maximize your investments. Uh, while at the same time not having to kind of hinder the compounding growth of this investments with tax payments, yet I have to make, um, you know, on like dividends or interest or whatever. And so, yes, definitely Roth RAs is big and like, you know, lot students are also younger as well. And so the growth potential for those Roth IRAs across, you know, 46 years is gonna be huge. Uh, and so definitely do look into Roth IRAs as soon as you can contribute as much as you can, uh, ’cause you know, later down the line, uh, your future self will definitely thank you for it.

Emily (41:04): Absolutely could not agree more. My current self, thanks my grad student self were contributing to my Roth IRA back then. Not to put an even finer point on it, you know, as a graduate student you’re probably in the 12% federal marginal tax bracket and you may never see that one again. you maybe exactly, you know, above that for the rest of your career. So like exactly, that is the time to do it and it’s incredible and I love this advice because it’s both tax and overall financial, um, advice and it’s wonderful. And Jack, again, thank you so much for coming on the podcast.

Jack (41:34): Yeah, thank you so much for having me, Emily. It was great, uh, chatting with you.

Outtro

Emily (41:48): Listeners, thank you for joining me for this episode! I have a gift for you! You know that final question I ask of all my guests regarding their best financial advice? My team has collected short summaries of all the answers ever given on the podcast into a document that is updated with each new episode release. You can gain access to it by registering for my mailing list at PFforPhDs.com/advice/. Would you like to access transcripts or videos of each episode? I link the show notes for each episode from PFforPhDs.com/podcast/. See you in the next episode, and remember: You don’t have to have a PhD to succeed with personal finance… but it helps! Nothing you hear on this podcast should be taken as financial, tax, or legal advice for any individual. The music is “Stages of Awakening” by Podington Bear from the Free Music Archive and is shared under CC by NC. Podcast editing by Dr. Lourdes Bobbio and show notes creation by Dr. Jill Hoffman.

The Complete Guide to Quarterly Estimated Tax for Fellowship Recipients

April 3, 2019 by Emily

If you’re reading this article, you’ve already done the hard part: You know (or suspect) that you’re supposed to pay quarterly estimated tax on your fellowship using Form 1040-ES. Whether you’re a graduate student, a postdoc, a postbac, or some other kind of fellow or trainee, if you’re not having tax withheld from your income, it’s pretty likely that you have the responsibility of paying quarterly estimated tax. The main obstacle to PhD students and postdocs paying quarterly estimated tax is simply awareness! The process itself is not complicated or difficult, as I’ll show you in this complete guide to quarterly estimated tax for fellows.

If you’re still unsure that you owe income tax at all on your fellowship income—or you want to help your peers understand this issue as well—I have plenty of articles and podcast episodes on that topic in particular.

Further reading and listening:

This article is for US citizens, permanent residents, and resident aliens living and working in the US, and I’ve made the assumption that you are not, in addition to being a fellow, a farmer, fisherman, or business owner/self-employed, that you do not have any household employees, and that your adjusted gross income is less than $150,000. (There are additional factors at play for these groups with respect to calculated estimated tax due.)

This post is for educational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, or financial advice.

This post was most recently updated on 3/21/2024.

What Is Estimated Tax?
Who Has to Pay Estimated Tax?
Who Doesn’t Have to Pay Estimated Tax?
Fill Out the Estimated Tax Worksheet in Form 1040-ES
Method for Irregular Income
Paying Your Quarterly Estimated Tax
Penalties for Underpaying Tax Throughout the Year
State Quarterly Estimated Tax
Set Up a System of Self-Withholding
How to Avoid Paying Estimated Tax Using Your Spouse’s Withholding

This article is an overview of how to handle estimated tax as a fellowship recipient. For an in-depth, line-by-line exploration of the Estimated Tax Worksheet in Form 1040-ES that addresses the common scenarios fellowship recipients face, please consider joining my tax workshop. It comprises pre-recorded videos, a spreadsheet, and quarterly live Q&A calls with me.

Click here to learn more about the quarterly estimated tax workshop for fellows.

What Is Estimated Tax?

The IRS expects to receive tax payments from you throughout the year, not just in the spring when you file your tax return.

To that end, employers offer automatic tax withholding to their employees. The employee files Form W-4 with the employer. This form helps the employee perform a high-level calculation about the amount of income tax the employee will owe for the year, which tells the employer approximately how much income tax to withhold from each paycheck. (Non-student employees will also have FICA tax withheld.)

Non-employees are almost never extended the courtesy of automatic income tax withholding by their university/institution/funding agency. (Income tax withholding for fellowship/training grant recipients is offered in rare cases—Duke University is one, at least while I was there—so it is worth inquiring about, but don’t be surprised if the answer is no.) Instead, the onus is on the individual to manually make tax payments.

By the time a person/household files a tax return in the spring of each year, the IRS expects the tax paid throughout the year to be in excess of or only slightly less than the actual amount owed. Approximately 3 in 4 Americans receive a tax refund (the amount of tax paid throughout the year minus the actual amount owed) after filing their tax returns. The rest, presumably, owe some additional tax when they file their tax returns. If the amount of additional tax due (above the amount paid throughout the year) is too high, the IRS will penalize the taxpayer.

To help taxpayers avoid underpaying tax throughout the year and being penalized, the IRS has set up a method of making manual tax payments four times per year: quarterly estimated tax payments. Anyone whose primary income isn’t subject to automatic withholding (e.g., fellowship recipients, self-employed people) or who has significant income in addition to their employee income (e.g., investment income) should look into making quarterly estimated tax payments.

Who Has to Pay Estimated Tax?

In general, you should expect to pay income tax in the year you receive your fellowship unless:

Your income is particularly low (e.g., you had an income for only part of the year or your fellowship went toward qualified education expenses instead of your personal living expenses) or
Your tax deductions and/or credits are particularly high.

Your tax due for the year might be large enough that you are required to make quarterly estimated tax payments or small enough that you can skip the quarterly payments and pay all the tax due at once with your annual tax return.

The dividing line is $1,000 of tax due at the end of the year in addition to the tax you had withheld and your refundable credits. If you expect to owe more than $1,000 in additional tax for the year, you should make quarterly tax payments, unless you fall into one of the exception categories discussed in the next section. If you expect to owe less than $1,000 in additional tax, you don’t have to make those quarterly payments and will just pay everything you owe with your annual tax return.

For individuals who receive only fellowship income not subject to tax withholding throughout the calendar year, the calculation is straightforward: How much income tax will you owe for the year, greater or less than $1,000?

For individuals/households with fellowship income not subject to withholding plus employee income subject to withholding (e.g., one person with part-year fellowship income and part-year employee income, one spouse with fellowship income and one spouse with employee income), both the total amount of tax owed across all incomes and the amount withheld must be taken into consideration. If you will owe more than $1,000 in additional tax at the end of the year and don’t fall into an exception category, you should file quarterly estimated tax.

Having a combination of fellowship and employee income is very common for PhD trainees, especially if they are married. My tax workshop addresses how to handle this particular scenario in detail.

Click here to learn more about the estimated tax workshop.

Who Doesn’t Have to Pay Estimated Tax?

Some people who owe more than $1,000 in additional tax at the end of the year are not required to make quarterly estimated tax payments.

If you had zero tax liability in the previous tax year, you are not required to make quarterly estimated tax payments in the current tax year. For example, if last year you were a undergrad or grad student with a low enough income that you didn’t pay any income tax, you’re not required to make quarterly estimated tax payments this year. Please note this refers to your overall tax liability for the year, not whether you had to make a payment when you filed your return.
If the sum of your tax withholding throughout the year and refundable credits equals or exceeds 90% of the tax you expect to owe this year, you are not required to make quarterly estimated tax payments. For example, if your spouse earns the lion’s share of your household income and has a generous amount of tax withheld automatically, your household’s overall tax withholding might be sufficient to exempt you from making quarterly estimated tax payments on your fellowship.
If the sum of your tax withholding throughout the year and refundable credits equals or exceeds 100% of the tax you owed last year, you are not required to make quarterly estimated tax payments. For example, if last year you finished undergrad and started grad school with a stipend, your tax owed for the year was likely quite small. If you have assistantship pay with tax withholding for part of this year and then switch to a fellowship with no withholding, your tax withholding from your assistantship might cover 100% of your tax owed from last year, and you wouldn’t be required to make quarterly estimated tax payments.

The best way to estimate your tax due this year along with your withholding and refundable credits and determine whether you are required to pay quarterly estimated tax is to fill out Form 1040-ES.

Psssst… Want to take a shortcut? If you have no interest in filling out Form 1040-ES’s Estimated Tax Worksheet, join my tax workshop. I explain a shortcut method to make sure you pay enough in estimated tax to avoid a fine without having to complete an advance draft your tax return this year. This method will only take a few minutes!

Click here to learn more about the quarterly estimated tax workshop for fellows.

Fill Out the Estimated Tax Worksheet in Form 1040-ES

Form 1040-ES, specifically the Estimated Tax Worksheet (p. 8), guides you through 1) estimating the amount of tax you will owe for the year, 2) determining if you are required to make quarterly estimated tax payments, and 3) calculating the amount of your required estimated tax payment.

I’ll point out a simple approach to filling out the Estimated Tax Worksheet for individual taxpayers/households with only fellowship and employee income. If you additionally have self-employment income or other types of income, your approach will be more nuanced.

If your fellowship income is disbursed frequently throughout the year (e.g., once per month for the entire year), this simple method will work for you. If your fellowship income is disbursed infrequently (e.g., 1-3 times per year) or throughout only part of the year (e.g., only the fall term after switching funding sources), keep reading for an alternative method.

The important numbers a fellowship recipient needs to plug in to Form 1040-ES to fill it out are:

Line 1: Your expected Adjusted Gross Income (AGI), which is your total income for the year less your above-the-line deductions (e.g., deductible portion of student loan interest paid, traditional IRA contributions). Your AGI includes your fellowship income, taxable scholarship income (if applicable), and any wages you (and your spouse) received, e.g., from an assistantship.
Line 2: Your deductions. If you plan to itemize your deductions, you should enter the total of those itemized deductions in line 2a; otherwise, enter the amount of your standard deduction (in 2024: single $14,600, married filing jointly $29,200).
Line 7: The sum of your credits if you plan to take any. Examples of credits include the Lifetime Learning Credit, the Child Tax Credit, and the Child and Dependent Care Credit.
Line 11b: The sum of your refundable credits if you plan to take any, such as the Earned Income Credit or the Additional Child Tax Credit.
Line 12b: Your total tax liability for the prior year.
Line 13: Income tax you expect to be withheld throughout the year. This can generally be extrapolated from your most recent pay stub.

If you come to the worksheet with this set of numbers, all you need to complete it is to follow the arithmetic steps instructed in the form and to look up your tax due using the Tax Rate Schedule on p. 7.

Once you fill out the worksheet, line 11c will tell you the total amount of tax that it is estimated you will have to pay for the year. The rest of the form helps you determine the minimum amount of quarterly estimated tax you have to pay to avoid a penalty, which might be $0. Both of these numbers are key for your tax planning for the year; don’t just make the minimum payments necessary and forget that you might owe additional tax along with you tax return in the spring.

Are you curious about the rest of the lines in the Estimated Tax Worksheet and wondering if you need to fill them out? My workshop devotes a module to explaining each line so you can determine if they apply to you or not.

Click here to learn more about the estimated tax workshop.

Method for Irregular Income

If you receive your income unevenly throughout the year, the IRS has a method for calculating a different amount of estimated tax due in each quarter, the Annualized Income Installment Method (see Publication 505).

Essentially, you calculate your tax due for each quarter based on your cumulative income up to that point of the year. Ultimately, you can pay the lesser of the estimated tax calculated through this worksheet or the quarterly estimated tax calculated from the previous method. (This is helpful if your income is higher later in the year than earlier; you don’t have to pay the extra tax until you actually receive the income.)

If you receive your fellowship income irregularly throughout the year—particularly if you are paid more later in the year than earlier—and want to be very exact about the amount of estimated tax you pay each quarter, you should fill out the Annualized Income Installment Method Worksheet after you complete the Estimated Tax Worksheet.

However, the Annualized Income Installment Method is a very complicated and fiddly worksheet, so if you don’t mind just making the regular quarterly payments, perhaps with guesstimate adjustments, that’s going to be faster and easier. For example, if you have tax withholding in place for much of the year through your assistantship but switch to fellowship funding for just the fall semester, your estimated tax payments all need to be made in the last one or two quarters, not the earlier part when you were having tax withheld.

Join my tax workshop for more details on how to handle quarterly estimated tax when you switch on or off of fellowship mid-year, a common scenario for fellowship recipients.

Click here to learn more about the estimated tax workshop.

Paying Your Quarterly Estimated Tax

If you are required to pay quarterly estimated tax, you have many options for doing so, such as by mail, over the phone, and through the IRS2Go app. The easiest method is most likely through the website IRS.gov/payments, where you can choose to make a direct transfer from your checking account for free or to pay using a debit or credit card for a fee.

The due dates for your 2024 quarterly estimated tax are:

Q1: April 15, 2024
Q2: June 17, 2024
Q3: Sept 16, 2024
Q4: Jan 15, 2025 (or Jan 31, 2025 if you file your annual tax return by that date)

Please note that these dates are not at 3-month intervals. Quarter 1 is three months long; quarter 2 is two months long; quarter 3 is three months long; quarter 4 is four months long.

Penalties for Underpaying Tax throughout the Year

There are penalties for failing to make estimated tax payments when you are required to do so or underpaying your estimated tax. The penalty is calculated separately for each quarter, so you may be penalized for underpaying in an earlier quarter even if you made up for it in a later quarter. The details about the penalties can be found in Publication 505.

State Quarterly Estimated Tax

Your state and/or local government may also require you to make estimated tax payments.

Set Up a System of Self-Withholding

If you are going to owe any income tax for the year and do not have automatic income tax withholding set up, you should intentionally prepare for your tax bill, whether or not that tax is due with your annual tax return or quarterly.

My recommendation is to set up a separate savings account labeled “Income Tax” or similar. With every paycheck you receive, transfer into your savings account the amount of money from it that you expect to pay in income tax. For example, if you receive monthly fellowship paychecks, you should set aside 1/12th of the amount you calculated in Line 11c (rounding up). When you pay tax quarterly or annually, draw the payment from that dedicated savings account.

For more details about how to set up this kind of system and save in advance for each of your tax deadlines, join my tax workshop.

Click here to learn more about the estimated tax workshop.

How to Avoid Paying Estimated Tax Using Your Spouse’s Withholding

If you are married filing jointly with one spouse receiving a fellowship not subject to withholding and one spouse subject to automatic withholding, it is possible to set up the withholding on the employee income so that you don’t have to pay quarterly estimated tax on the fellowship.

The idea is that you will increase the automatic withholding on the employee’s income so that it covers what you owe in tax for the year as a couple. This involves filing a new Form W-4 with your spouse’s employer.

The simplest way to make this change is to enter an additional amount of money on Form W-4 Line 4c to have withheld from each paycheck (Form 1040-ES Line 11c divided by the number of paychecks your spouse receives per year).

Weird Tax Situations for Fellowship and Training Grant Recipients

February 20, 2019 by Emily

One of the most puzzling tax scenarios that is common in academia—but almost unheard of outside of it—is fellowship or training grant funding because it is neither a wage nor self-employment income. Fellowships and training grants, which I call “awarded income,” frequently pay the stipends and salaries of graduate students, postdocs, and postbacs. This post explains the weird tax situations for fellowship and training grant recipients and how to address them. I’ll clarify right up front that you do need to incorporate your awarded income into the gross income you report on your tax return, and you almost certainly will end up paying tax on it (unless your total income is very low or you have lots of other deductions/credits).

This article was last updated on 1/17/2025. It is intended for US citizens, permanent residents, and residents for tax purposes. It is not tax, legal, or financial advice.

Further reading/viewing:

I have to define my terms up front here because “fellowship” is used variously inside and outside of academic research, and these weird tax situations don’t always apply. What I’m talking about is when your income from your academic/research role is not reported on a Form W-2 (and you’re not self-employed).

Often, though not always, winning an external or internal fellowship generates this kind of income. The National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship (GRFP) and the Department of Defense National Defense Science and Engineering Graduate Fellowship (NDSEG) are among the most well-known examples of this type of income at the graduate level for STEM fields. Basically, you’re being paid because you won an award, not because you are directly trading work or time for money. This kind of income can also come from training grants, such as the National Institutes of Health Ruth L. Kirschstein Institutional National Research Service Award (T32), and in those cases you might or might not be labeled a fellow by your institution.

If your income is reported on a Form W-2, whether it’s called a fellowship or not, this post doesn’t apply to you!

Personally, over my time in/near academia, I received awarded income on five occasions:

I was postbaccalaureate fellow at the NIH for a year between undergrad and grad school, and my income was reported on a 1099-G.
I was on a training grant in my first year of grad school, and my income was reported on a 1099-MISC in Box 3.
I won an internal fellowship for my second year of grad school, and my income was reported on a 1099-MISC in Box 3.
I was paid from my advisor’s discretionary funds in my sixth year of grad school, and my income was reported on a 1099-MISC in Box 3.
I was a Christine Mirzayan Science and Technology Policy Fellow at the National Academy of Engineering, and my income was reported on a 1099-MISC in Box 3.

Receiving Unusual Tax Forms

The way to definitively tell that you’re receiving awarded income is that you don’t receive a Form W-2 at tax time for your income, which was likely paid similarly to a regular salary or perhaps in a lump sum per term. Instead, you might see your income reported on some other strange tax form:

Form 1098-T
Form 1099-MISC
Form 1099-NEC
Form 1099-G

There are other possible mechanism for this reporting; these are the four most commonly used by universities and funding agencies.

None of these forms was designed for reporting awarded income and none do it very well, but they do get the job done if you know what you’re looking for.

Form 1098-T

Form 1098-T, which is issued to some students depending on your university’s policies, is sort of a clearinghouse form for the sum of your fellowships/scholarships/grants received (in Box 5) and also the sum of the qualified tuition and related expenses that were paid (Box 1) to your student account. Your fellowship income might be lumped in with your scholarships in Box 5, which makes them a little hard to parse, or Box 5 might only include your scholarships (see next section if so).

The good thing about Form 1098-T if it includes your fellowship income is that it does put front and center two of the important numbers you’ll need to work with when you prepare your tax return, the sum of your awarded (fellowship, scholarship, and grant) income (Box 5) and a subset of your Qualified Education Expenses (Box 1). You don’t really need to know what your fellowship income was independent of your additional scholarship/grant income See Weird Tax Situations for Fully Funded Grad Students for more details about working with Form 1098-T.

Form 1099-MISC

Form 1099-MISC is a slightly confusing form to receive for fellowship income.

Any non-academic who hears/sees that you have income reported on a 1099-MISC is going to think you’re self-employed. Self-employment and contractor income used to be reported in Box 7, which no longer exists following the creation of Form 1099-NEC (see next). Fellowship income usually shows up in Box 3, “Other income.” If you are a grad student or postdoc, you are not self-employed; do not pay self-employment tax!

The instructions for the 1099-MISC tell you to (“generally”) report your Box 3 “Other income” in the “Other income” line on your Form 1040 Schedule 1. There is a precise line on which you should do so: Form 1040 Schedule 1 Line 8r, which is labeled “Scholarship and fellowship grants not reported on Form W-2.”

Form 1099-NEC

The IRS resurrected Form 1099-NEC, which stands for “non-employee compensation,” starting in tax year 2020. All self-employment and contractor income is now supposed to be reported in Box 1.

Unfortunately, a minority of funding agencies are also reporting awarded income on Form 1099-NEC Box 1. Similar to Form 1099-MISC, if you are certain that this income is fellowship or training grant income and not self-employment income, you should report it as fellowship income on your tax return. If you erroneously report it as self-employment income, you will pay self-employment tax (15.3%) and exclude yourself from taking a higher education tax break.

Form 1099-G

Form 1099-G is typically used when the funding body is part of the federal government. The awarded income shows up in Box 6, “Taxable grants.”

Further reading:

Receiving No Tax Forms

Going along with the theme of not receiving a Form W-2 at tax time, you might very well not receive any tax form at all! It’s very common for there to be zero communication between the organization that pays the fellowship and the fellowship recipient. Other times, the fellow might receive what I call a “courtesy letter,” which is just a short, informal letter stating the amount of fellowship money paid.

Further reading: What Is a Courtesy Letter?

Fellows who don’t receive tax forms or whose institutions and funding agencies don’t communicate with them at all about their personal taxes may feel completely adrift. They have no idea where to even start with preparing their tax returns. Many pay no taxes at all (if you know someone like that, send them this article!) since it takes a certain level of awareness of your tax responsibility to even wonder if you need to pay income tax. Even those who suspect they need to report and pay tax on their fellowship income might be daunted by the task of figuring out from scratch exactly how to do that.

Further listening: Do I Owe Income Tax on My Fellowship?

But it’s really a simple process to carry out if you know what to do! You should be able to find the amount of fellowship or training grant income you were paid for the whole year from your bank records. If you’re not a student, you just straight report that number in Form 1040 Schedule 1 Line 8r. If you are a student, you have to work with your other scholarships and qualified education expenses a bit before reporting a number for your awarded income; see Weird Tax Situations for Fully Funded Grad Students for more details.

Further reading: Where to Report Your PhD Trainee Income on Your Tax Return

Quarterly Estimated Tax

In my observation, the great majority of awarded income recipients have the responsibility of paying quarterly estimated tax—and many, many, many neglect to do so. If you need one level of awareness to even understand you’re supposed to pay tax on your fellowship income, you need an even higher level of awareness before you follow through on paying quarterly estimated tax. In fact, if the organization providing you the fellowship didn’t mention this, it’s not a water cooler topic around your department, and/or you’ve never been self-employed or close to someone who is self-employed, you almost certainly wouldn’t know to do it.

The basic principle here is that the IRS expects to receive tax payments throughout the year, not just in April when your tax return is due. If you owe enough additional tax at the end of the year (and don’t qualify for an exception), the IRS is going to demand not only your tax payment but late fees and interest as well.

The main system for sending tax in to the IRS is tax withholding on a normal paycheck. If you don’t do that or your withholding isn’t sufficient, you’re supposed to pay estimated tax. Basically, you send in a payment (no forms need to be filed) to the IRS four times per year to make sure you don’t have too much extra tax due when you file your yearly tax return. You should work through the estimated tax worksheet on p. 8 of Form 1040-ES to figure out if you are required to pay quarterly estimated tax and in what amount; you can also find the instructions for filing it in that form.

Further reading: The Complete Guide to Quarterly Estimated Tax for Fellowship Recipients

Taxable Compensation and Earned Income Tax Breaks

Some of the tax breaks the IRS offers are contingent on the type of income you have, and fellowship income (not reported on From W-2) does not necessarily qualify.

Individual Retirement Arrangement

To contribute to an Individual Retirement Arrangement (IRA), you (or your spouse) must have “taxable compensation.”

Through 2019, the definition of “taxable compensation” did not include fellowship and training grant income not reported on Form W-2. However, starting in 2020, the definition of “taxable compensation” changed for graduate students and postdocs to include fellowship and training grant income even if not reported on From W-2.

Therefore, all types of graduate student and postdoc taxable income, whether reported on a Form W-2 or not, is eligible to be contributed to an IRA starting in 2020.

Further reading:

Earned Income Tax Credit

The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) or Earned Income Credit (EIC) is a credit extended to low-income individuals and families. If your household income is quite low and/or you have one or more children, you might be able to receive the credit. As the name implies, you need “earned income” to qualify for the EITC. Unfortunately, fellowship/scholarship income is not considered “earned income” (Publication 596 p. 18). Puzzlingly, having zero earned income disqualifies you from the credit, but having too much non-earned income also disqualifies you from the credit. The definition of earned income also plays into the calculations for the Child Tax Credit and Additional Child Tax Credit.

Dependent Status

When you are trying to determine if you should file a tax return as an independent adult vs. a dependent of your parents, it is more difficult to qualify as independent with fellowship income rather than an equal amount of W-2 income. (This only applies to students under age 24.) While education expenses count as part of the amount of money that goes toward your “support,” scholarships and fellowships that you won do not count as you providing your own support.

Kiddie Tax

Fellowship income counts as unearned income for the purposes of being subject to the Kiddie Tax. If you are under the age of 24 on December 31 and a student, your “unearned” income exceeding $2,500 may be subject to a higher tax rate than the ordinary rate.

Further reading: Fellowship Income Can Trigger the Kiddie Tax

Weird Tax Situations for Fully Funded Grad Students

February 20, 2019 by Emily

“Actually, I get paid to go to school.” How many times have you said that to distant relatives and new acquaintances? If you look at it that way, being a funded grad student is a pretty sweet gig. But there are definitely downsides, like the low pay, sub-par benefits, and the weird tax situations that come with getting paid to be a grad student in the US. Receiving a 1098-T that has seemingly no basis in reality and having to incorporate it into your tax return—or worse, not receiving one—can become a real time- and energy-suck. The whole tax return support system seems to have been set up to help people who are in the red with their universities, not people who are in the black. Fortunately, there are solutions to these weird tax situations for fully funded grad students, and I’ve brought them to light for you in this point.

The points covered in this post are strictly to do with being a funded graduate student (“candidate for a degree”) at a US university. It is primarily written for graduate students who are US citizens, permanent residents, and residents for tax purposes.

This article was most recently updated on 1/17/2025. It is not tax, financial, or legal advice.

Further reading:

You Might or Might Not Receive a 1098-T

Form 1098-T looks like a super official tax form, rather like Form W-2. However, it’s not as weighty of a form as other tax forms you might receive for the purpose of reporting income. Form 1098-T’s primary purpose is to let the IRS know that a student (or a student’s parents) might try to take a higher education tax credit so that it can check the amount of the tax break claimed; it’s not designed and is not well-suited for reporting income, which is primarily what funded graduate students need to do. In fact, it’s optional for universities to even generate a Form 1098-T for a student for whom the Form 1098-T’s Box 5 (“Scholarships or grants”) would be greater than Box 1 (“Payments received for qualified tuition and related expenses”), which is often the case for funded graduate students. So as a fully funded graduate student, you might receive a 1098-T or you might not; the choice belongs to your university.

Further reading: What Is a 1098-T?

Your 1098-T Might Mislead You

The only thing worse than not receiving a 1098-T is receiving one that is misleading.

Further reading: Form 1098-T: Still Causing Trouble for Funded Graduate Students

When a 1098-T is issued, it is supposed to contain all of the scholarships and grants that were processed through the graduate student’s account (Box 5) as well as the payments received (Box 1) for qualified tuition and related expenses. In addition, your fellowship stipend might appear in Box 5 (or it might not). You would think this would be straightforward bookkeeping, yet I’ve spoken with numerous graduate students who, even after careful study of the transactions in their student accounts, could not understand how the sums were calculated.

Even if your Form 1098-T is a straightforward representation of the transactions in your student account, the net fellowship/scholarship income you should report on your tax return is not necessarily Box 5 minus Box 1. More on that next!

You Have to Calculate Your Taxable Awarded Income

It’s really straightforward to report your Form W-2 income, which I call “employee income,” on your tax return. The number is right there in Box 1, and it goes into Form 1040 Line 1a.

However, you have to calculate the taxable portion of your fellowship/scholarship/grant income, which I call “awarded income,” before reporting it on your tax return.

This is because, as a student (“candidate for a degree”), you’re eligible for a higher education tax break called tax-free scholarships and fellowships, which is detailed in Publication 970 Chapter 1. This means that the awarded income that you receive is taxable only to the extent that it exceeds your “qualified education expenses.”

To calculate your taxable awarded income, you need to add up all of your awarded income and then subtract all of your qualified education expenses. (This is not the same calculation as subtracting your Form 1098-T Box 1 from your Form 1098-T Box 5—more on that next!) Sometimes, this will net out to zero, like if the scholarship for your tuition exactly pays the amount of your tuition. Sometimes, there will be excess income or excess qualified education expenses.

In fact, funded graduate students often overpay their true tax liability because they miss accounting for some of their qualified education expenses! This could happen because they forgot about an education expense they paid for out of pocket or because they misunderstood that a charge in their student account actually was a qualified education expenses under this benefit.

Further reading: Where to Report Your PhD Trainee Income on Your Tax Return

You Have to Figure Out Your Own Qualified Education Expenses

To expand on that point, there is a lot of well-deserved confusion over what a “qualified education expense” actually is. This is because the definition of a Qualified Education Expense is slightly different depending on the tax break you’re trying to take. Yeah, that’s another weird tax situation for fully funded grad students.

IRS Publication 970 p. 4:

“Even though the same term, such as qualified education expenses, is used to label a basic component of many of the education benefits, the same expenses aren’t necessarily allowed for each benefit.”

Tuition is considered a qualified education expense for tax-free scholarships and fellowships and the two higher education tax credits, but some additional expenses, such as required fees and course-related expenses, e.g., books and supplies, are included in the definition for tax-free scholarships and fellowships. Even a personal computer could be considered a qualified education expense for tax-free scholarships and fellowships under very well-defined circumstances. These types of expenses are unlikely to appear on your 1098-T in Box 1 because they’re usually paid out of pocket. You should refer to Publication 970 for the full definitions of qualified education expenses under the three different education benefits.

Furthermore, the number that appears in Box 1 of your Form 1098-T is not the sum of your qualified education expenses that are processed by your student account. Box 1 of Form 1098-T reflects “qualified tuition and related expenses,” which has its own definition that excludes certain expenses that are qualified education expenses under tax-free scholarships and fellowships.

Further reading: What Are Qualified Education Expenses?

One controversial point is whether your student health insurance premium is a required fee/qualified education expense for the purpose of making the scholarship that pays it tax-free. Insurance and student health fees, along with some other expenses, are explicitly disallowed as qualified education expenses for the Lifetime Learning Credit, but not for making scholarships tax-free.

My tax return preparation workshop contains a complete discussion of qualified education expenses, including common gray-area examples that graduate students encounter, and how to calculate the taxable portion of your awarded income.

You Might or Might Not Be a Dependent of Your Parents

Because graduate students are students, they might be considered dependents of their parents (or another relative) for tax purposes if they were under age 24 on 12/31. Many parents (and their tax preparers) try to claim their of-age children as dependents without referencing the relevant definitions. If your parents assume you are a dependent but you believe you are not, together you can go through the definition carefully to make the final determination.

The conditions for being considered a dependent of your parent are:

You are age 23 or younger at the end of the calendar year.
You were enrolled as a student in at least 5 calendar months (doesn’t have to be consecutive).
You lived with your parents for at least half the year (being away for educational reasons can count as living with them).
You are not filing a joint return (with a caveat).
You must meet the “Support Test”: You did not provide more than half of your own support in the calendar year (see Publication 17 Worksheet 3-1).

For any years that the first three points above apply to you, you should fill out the Support Test to determine if you provided enough of your own support to qualify as independent. Keep in mind that education expenses count as “support” that you needed, but scholarships and fellowships that paid that support don’t count as being provided by you, the student.

You’re (Mostly) Not Paying FICA Tax

FICA (Social Security and Medicare) taxes seem like an unavoidable burden for employees and self-employed people. But even if you’re an employee of your university (i.e., you receive a W-2 at tax time), you’re most likely not paying FICA tax because you have a student exemption. This exemption depends on both the primary function of the organization that employs you (i.e., educational) and your primary relationship with the organization (i.e., as a student rather than an employee).

The student exemption is almost universal for graduate students, but I have come across two exceptions that depend heavily on the exact wording of the exemption:

1) Graduate students at research institutions that are not primarily universities might not receive the exemption.

2) Graduate students, even at universities, whose primary relationship with their employer is as an employee rather than a student may pay FICA tax. For example, this might occur during the summer vs. during the academic year, and could happen without the student even perceiving a difference in roles. (This is not common, but I have seen it a few times.)

Graduate students receiving fellowships also do not pay FICA tax, but that is because they are not receiving wages rather than due to their student status.

You Cannot Take the Saver’s Credit

The Saver’s Credit is a very valuable credit that low-income earners can take if they contribute to a retirement account, such as an IRA. However, full-time students are not eligible for the credit.

Yes, there are a lot of weird tax situations for fully funded grad students. You have to do a bit of legwork instead of just blindly entering numbers from your 1098-T into tax software or ignoring your excess scholarship income. But if you break the issues down one by one, it’s actually straightforward to determine how to resolve them.

How to Prepare Your Grad Student Tax Return (Tax Year 2024)

January 24, 2019 by Emily

It’s common for funded graduate students to be a bit intimidated by preparing their own tax returns, particularly if they are inexperienced in doing so. The sources of PhD student funding, namely fellowship stipends and the scholarships or waivers that pay tuition and fees, are rather unusual, so most people and even most professional tax preparers don’t have any experience with them. The strategies that apply for undergraduate-level taxes are pretty different from those that apply for graduate-level taxes. But learning how to prepare your grad student tax return isn’t actually difficult, nor are the resulting steps complicated. There’s no reason to be intimidated! This post covers the essential points you need to know to prepare your grad student tax return, whether you do it manually, with tax software, or with the help of another person.

This post is for tax year 2024. This post only covers federal tax due for graduate students in the United States who are citizens, permanent residents, or residents for tax purposes; you may have additional state and local tax due. I am detailing only the aspects of preparing your grad student tax return that are specific to higher education; I am not covering more general tax information that applies to the population at large.

This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, or financial advice advice. It was last updated on 1/17/2025. For more tax content, visit the Personal Finance for PhDs Tax Center.

Table of Contents (Links)

Preliminary Remarks
Collect All Your Income Sources
Categorize Your Income
Decide Which Education Tax Benefit(s) to Use on Your Grad Student Tax Return
Fill Out Your Grad Student Tax Return
Other Education Tax Benefits
If You Were Under Age 24
Conclusion

Preliminary Remarks

This post is a step-by-step guide on how to prepare your grad student tax return. I want to clear up some confusion right up front so that you can work your way through the guide without becoming sidetracked.

All of your income is potentially taxable. The purpose of your tax return is to show that you don’t have to pay tax on all of it. What graduate students don’t often realize is that they have income sources aside from the one(s) that hits their bank accounts or is reported on an official tax document, and they need to deal with those incomes on their tax returns.

You have your stipend/salary that serves as your take-home pay; this is potentially taxable, even if you don’t receive an official tax form about it and you didn’t have any taxes withheld. In fact, I’ll say you’re very likely to end up owing tax on it unless it’s quite low and/or you have a lot of tax deductions and/or credits.

You also have another kind of potentially taxable income if you are funded: the money that pays your tuition, fees, and other education expenses. Your university might refer to this as scholarships, waivers, remissions, etc. Even if this money never passes through your personal bank account, it does pass through your name via your student account, which makes it potentially taxable to you as an individual. There is a very high chance you can use an education tax benefit to reduce your taxable income and/or reduce your tax due, but you have to sit down and do the arithmetic on it, not just assume that you won’t owe any tax on it. (In fact, doing the arithmetic may very well help you pay even less tax than if you ignored it!) This guide shows you exactly how to do that.

Further reading:

This article includes publicly available information on taxes for students and fellowship recipients, largely derived from IRS Publication 970 and my examinations of the tax policies of many universities across the US.

If you want a more in-depth and intuitive presentation of this material, designed for you to prepare your tax return as you go through it, that includes my interpretations of the tricky IRS language and the insight I gained from hiring a CPA to research grad student taxes…

Please consider joining my tax workshop. It comprises pre-recorded videos, worksheets, and live Q&A calls with me.

Click here to learn more about the grad student tax return workshop.

Collect All Your Income Sources

The first step to prepare your grad student tax return, and any tax return, is to collect all your income sources. These income sources include wages as well as non-wage income such as interest and investment income and self-employment income, but does not include loan disbursements.

With respect to your grad student status, you have income sources that are unusual and may be officially reported to you or not (so check for all of them):

Your employee income for your stipend or salary will be reported to you on a Form W-2. This typically comes from a teaching assistantship, research assistantship, or graduate assistantship.
Your awarded income that pays your stipend or salary may be reported to you on a 1098-T in Box 5, on a 1099-MISC in Box 3, on a Form 1099-NEC in Box 1, on a 1099-G in Box 6, on a courtesy letter, or not at all. Awarded income typically comes from fellowships, training grants, and awards. If your university does not send you any documentation of your fellowship income for 2024, you have to sum all the payments you received to figure out what it was.
Your awarded income that pays your education expenses may be reported to you on a 1098-T in Box 5 or not at all. Awarded income typically comes from scholarships, waivers, remissions, and awards. If you did not receive a 1098-T from your university, you should look at the transactions in your student account (e.g., Bursar’s account, Cashier’s account) to see the money posted there on your behalf.

Your university may not use the exact terminology that I did, but the tax forms and documentation (or lack thereof) will help you differentiate among the three types.

Further reading:

At this stage, you may be thinking that the total of all this income is way too high. There’s no way you want to pay tax on all this income! Stick with me: We are going to reduce either your taxable income or your tax due in a subsequent step. But for now, work with all of your incomes.

Would you like the opportunity to ask me a question about your tax situation? I hold monthly live Q&A calls throughout tax season for my workshop participants!

Click here to learn more about the tax return workshop.

Categorize Your Income

Your grad student income (assistantship pay, fellowships, scholarships, etc.) falls into two broad categories: employee income and awarded income.

Employee income is easy to define, as you will receive a Form W-2 for it.

Awarded income is best defined as any grad student-related income that is reported somewhere other than a W-2 or not reported. According to the IRS, it is “various types of educational assistance you may receive if you are studying, teaching, or researching in the United States… includ[ing] scholarships, fellowship grants, need-based education grants, qualified tuition reductions” (Publication 970 p. 5), but the way the IRS uses those terms doesn’t completely match how we use the terms in academia.

Decide Which Education Tax Benefit(s) to Use on Your Grad Student Tax Return

For tax year 2024, there are two* relevant education tax benefits that you can access to reduce your tax burden: making awarded income tax-free and the Lifetime Learning Credit.

You use your qualified education expenses (QEEs) to take a deduction (by making your awarded income tax-free) or take a credit (by taking the Lifetime Learning Credit). A tax deduction reduces your taxable income, while a tax credit reduces your tax due directly. You can apply either one or both of these benefits, but you have to use different QEE dollars.

(* There is one more education tax benefit, the American Opportunity Tax Credit, which is each beneficial for a very small percentage of graduate students. See the section at the end of the article for more details on this benefit and whether it might apply to you.)

Generally speaking, graduate students should make their awarded income tax-free to the greatest extent possible before applying any remaining QEEs to the Lifetime Learning Credit; this is how tax software will prepare your return. However, some graduate students may be eligible to prioritize the Lifetime Learning Credit (or the American Opportunity Tax Credit) over making awarded income tax-free to further reduce their tax liability (could be worth hundreds of dollars); this scenario is discussed in detail inside my tax workshop.

Qualified Education Expenses

The definition of a QEE changes slightly for each tax benefit. From Publication 970 p. 4:

Tuition at an eligible education institution is a QEE for both tax benefits (although to make awarded income tax-free you have to be a degree candidate). “Required fees” are QEEs for making awarded income tax-free. The Lifetime Learning Credit uses the wording “the fees and expenses [that] must be paid to the institution for enrollment or attendance” to define a QEE. Other fees and expenses beyond tuition may be QEEs; you should refer to the definition of a QEE with respect to each benefit.

If you received a 1098-T from your university, Box 1 will contain the sum of the payments for your the “qualified tuition and related expenses” that were processed by the office at your university that prepared the form. You may have additional QEEs not reported on the Form 1098-T, because the qualified tuition and related expenses on Form 1098-T do not include “charges and fees for room, board, insurance, medical expenses (including student health fees), transportation, and similar personal, living, or family expenses” (Form 1098-T Instructions, p. 2)

Further reading: What Is a 1098-T?

Whether you received a 1098-T or not, you should examine the transactions in your student account to make the final determination about the qualified education expenses that were processed by that office.

You may have additional QEEs not reported on your 1098-T or in your student account, such as required course-related expenses (keep your receipts!).

It’s very worthwhile to examine the definition of a QEE because uncovering additional QEEs almost always translates to a lower tax liability.

Make Awarded Income Tax-Free

The awarded income that you receive can directly cancel against your QEEs to become tax-free. For example, if the tuition that you are charged and the scholarship or tuition reduction that pays it are exactly the same amount, they net to zero and you won’t be taxed on that portion of your awarded income. In fact, you don’t even have to show the IRS this calculation; you only have to report the portion of your awarded income that exceeds your QEEs.

The definition of a QEE to make awarded income tax-free is (excerpted from Publication 970 Chapter 1 p. 6):

Qualified education expenses. For purposes of tax-free scholarships and fellowship grants, these are expenses for:

Tuition and fees required to enroll at or attend an eligible educational institution; and
Course-related expenses, such as fees, books, supplies, and equipment that are required for the courses at the eligible educational institution. These items must be required of all students in your course of instruction.

Expenses that don’t qualify. Qualified education expenses don’t include the cost of:

Room and board,
Travel,
Research,
Clerical help, or
Equipment and other expenses that aren’t required for enrollment in or attendance at an eligible educational institution.“

Are you unsure whether one of your expenses is a “qualified education expense” to net against awarded income? In my tax workshop, I present the common higher education-related expenses that graduate students incur and tell you whether or not they are QEEs under each of the education tax benefits.

Click here to learn more about the tax return workshop.

Lifetime Learning Credit

The Lifetime Learning Credit reduces your tax burden and may be beneficial to apply if 1) your QEEs exceed your awarded income and/or 2) a 20% credit is more valuable to you than a deduction.

The Lifetime Learning Credit is a 20% credit; that means that if you use $1,000 in QEE expenses for the Lifetime Learning Credit, your tax due will be reduced by $200. There is a $10,000 limit on QEEs that can be used for the Lifetime Learning Credit, so the maximum benefit is $2,000 even if you have additional QEEs.

The modified adjust gross income phase-out for this deduction begins at $80,000 for a single person and $160,000 for a married couple filing jointly.

The definition of a QEE for the Lifetime Learning Credit is (excerpted from Publication 970 Chapter 3 p. 24, 28):

“Qualified Education Expenses

For purposes of the lifetime learning credit, qualified education expenses are tuition and certain related expenses required for enrollment in a course at an eligible educational institution. The course must be either part of a postsecondary degree program or taken by the student to acquire or improve job skills.

Related expenses. Student activity fees and expenses for course-related books, supplies, and equipment are included in qualified education expenses only if the fees and expenses must be paid to the institution for enrollment or attendance.

Expenses That Don’t Qualify

Qualified education expenses don’t include amounts paid for:

Insurance;
Medical expenses (including student health fees);
Room and board;
Transportation; or
Similar personal, living, or family expenses.

This is true even if the amount must be paid to the institution as a condition of enrollment or attendance.“

If you take the Lifetime Learning Credit, you must fill out and file Form 8863.

The Numbers You Need for Your Tax Return

Once you have decided how you would like to use your QEEs, you should bring a few numbers with you to enter into your federal tax return:

Your total amount of employee income (W-2 pay with respect to your grad student income),
Your net awarded income (after applying your QEEs to reduce it),
The amount of your Lifetime Learning Credit (maximum $2,000) from Form 8863, and
The amount of income tax you already paid, whether through withholding or estimated tax.

You now have an idea of the actions to take and decisions to make regarding your grad student tax return. I know it can seem overwhelming! I don’t want you to spend hours and hours feeling frustrated paging through IRS documentation or wrestling with tax software.

Commit a couple hours to taking my tax return workshop, feel confident and supported, and emerge with an accurate and minimized tax return!

Click here to learn more about the grad student tax return workshop.

Fill Out Your Grad Student Tax Return

With respect to your taxable grad student income, Lifetime Learning Credit, and tax already paid, how to report them on your tax return is very straightforward. Of course, you will fill out the rest of your tax return by following the form instructions; this section only relates to the grad student aspects of your return.

Report Your Income

Write your employee income (reported on your Form W-2) on Form 1040 Line 1a.

Write your taxable awarded income on Form 1040 Schedule 1 Line 8r. (This dedicated line is new as of 2022!)

Further reading: Where to Report Your PhD Trainee Income on Your Tax Return

Report Your Lifetime Learning Credit

Report your Lifetime Learning Credit on Line 3 of Form 1040 Schedule 3; you will also file Form 8863. The amount of this credit will directly reduce your tax due.

Report Your Tax Already Paid

If you received a Form W-2 and/or Form 1099 for part or all of your grad student income, you will enter the amount of federal tax that was withheld from your income in Line 25 of Form 1040. There are different parts of the line depending on which form was used.

Further reading: The Complete Guide to Quarterly Estimated Tax for Fellowship Recipients

If you paid quarterly estimated tax on your fellowship income, report the total of the estimated tax payments you made in Line 26 of Form 1040.

Other Education Tax Benefits

I have omitted from detailed discussion two education tax benefits that you may be familiar with from past experiences preparing your tax return.

American Opportunity Tax Credit

The American Opportunity Tax Credit is typically used during the undergraduate years only. It can be claimed in only 4 tax years and not in any tax year after the one in which you finish your first four years of postsecondary education. Therefore, if you graduated from college in 2024 (in four years) and you (or your parents) claimed the American Opportunity Tax Credit in no more than 3 previous tax years (e.g., freshman spring/sophomore fall, sophomore spring/junior fall, and junior spring/senior fall but not freshman fall), you may be eligible to claim it for 2024.

The American Opportunity Tax Credit is the most valuable education tax benefit available, so if you are eligible for it, you will almost certainly want to use it to the greatest degree you can. It is a 100% credit on up to $2,000 of QEEs and a 25% credit on up to $2,000 of QEEs.

The definition of a QEE for the American Opportunity Tax Credit is distinct from the definition for other education tax benefits.

If you claim the American Opportunity Tax Credit, you cannot use the Lifetime Learning Credit or the Tuition and Fees Deduction. If you are considered a dependent on your parents’ tax return in 2024, you cannot claim the credit (your parents would).

To claim the American Opportunity Tax Credit, you need to fill out and file Form 8863.

Tuition and Fees Deduction

The Tuition and Fees Deduction expired at the end of 2020.

Would you like the opportunity to ask me a question about your tax situation? I hold monthly live Q&A calls throughout tax season for my workshop participants!

Click here to learn more about the tax return workshop.

If You Were Under Age 24

If you were age 23 or younger on December 31, 2024 and a full-time student for at least five months of the year, you may be subject to an alternative, higher tax known as the Kiddie Tax. This could be the case if your income was primary awarded income.

Further reading: Fellowship Income Can Trigger the Kiddie Tax

As a full-time student (for at least part of 5 calendar months) and under age 24, your parents (or another relative) might also be able to claim you as a dependent, though you will have to pass the ‘residency test’ and ‘support test.’

One entire module of my tax return workshop is devoted to the special tax considerations of graduate students under the age of 24. Please consider joining the workshop for much more details about the Kiddie Tax and dependency.

Click here to learn more about the tax return workshop.

Conclusion

The most challenging aspect of this process is simply knowing the various aspects that you have to consider. The most complicated aspect is collecting and categorizing all of your income sources and education expenses.

Best of luck to you as you prepare your grad student tax return this year! If you need additional support:

Please consider sharing this post with your peers through social media or a list-serv!

Taxes

Links mentioned in the Episode

Teaser

Introduction

Will You Please Introduce Yourself Further?

Similarities Between Academics and Creatives

How Do You Know When You’ve Actually Started a Business?

Commercial

Best Financial Practices for Early Career Academics With Businesses

Preparing for Tax Season as a Business Owner

Side Hustles and Estimated Tax

Sunlight Tax and the Sunlight Podcast

Best Financial Advice for Another Early-Career PhD

Outtro

Links mentioned in the Episode

Teaser

Introduction

Will You Please Introduce Yourself Further?

Volunteer Income Tax Assistance (VITA) Program & TaxFellows

The Kiddie Tax

Commercial

Paying Estimated Taxes as a Graduate Student

Advocacy Around the Kiddie Tax, Taxable Scholarships, and Other Niche Financial Issues

How Graduate Students Can Advocate for Tax Related Resources at their Universities

Using Caution When Getting Tax Help as a Graduate Student

How Universities Can Support Graduate Students Around Taxes

Best Financial Advice for Another Early-Career PhD

Outtro

Table of Contents

What Is Estimated Tax?

Who Has to Pay Estimated Tax?

Who Doesn’t Have to Pay Estimated Tax?

Fill Out the Estimated Tax Worksheet in Form 1040-ES

Method for Irregular Income

Paying Your Quarterly Estimated Tax

Penalties for Underpaying Tax throughout the Year

State Quarterly Estimated Tax

Set Up a System of Self-Withholding

How to Avoid Paying Estimated Tax Using Your Spouse’s Withholding

Receiving Unusual Tax Forms

Form 1098-T

Form 1099-MISC

Form 1099-NEC

Form 1099-G

Receiving No Tax Forms

Quarterly Estimated Tax

Taxable Compensation and Earned Income Tax Breaks

Individual Retirement Arrangement

Earned Income Tax Credit

Dependent Status

Kiddie Tax

You Might or Might Not Receive a 1098-T

Your 1098-T Might Mislead You

You Have to Calculate Your Taxable Awarded Income

You Have to Figure Out Your Own Qualified Education Expenses

You Might or Might Not Be a Dependent of Your Parents

You’re (Mostly) Not Paying FICA Tax

You Cannot Take the Saver’s Credit

Table of Contents (Links)

Preliminary Remarks

Collect All Your Income Sources

Categorize Your Income

Decide Which Education Tax Benefit(s) to Use on Your Grad Student Tax Return

Qualified Education Expenses

Make Awarded Income Tax-Free

Lifetime Learning Credit

The Numbers You Need for Your Tax Return

Fill Out Your Grad Student Tax Return

Report Your Income

Report Your Lifetime Learning Credit

Report Your Tax Already Paid

Other Education Tax Benefits

American Opportunity Tax Credit

Tuition and Fees Deduction

If You Were Under Age 24

Conclusion

Footer

Sign Up for More Awesome Content